How many Billy Wagner cards are there?

Midpoint tracks 162 Billy Wagner baseball cards across 110 sets, released between 1993 and 2025. 137 of them have live raw or graded market values.

What is the most valuable Billy Wagner card?

The most valuable Billy Wagner card tracked by Midpoint is Billy Wagner [Foil] #18 from 1994 SP, currently $987 in PSA 10 (raw $4.28).

What years are Billy Wagner cards from?

Billy Wagner cards tracked by Midpoint run from 1993 to 2025; the earliest cards are from 1993.

Billy Wagner Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

162 cards · 110 sets · 1993–2025

Midpoint tracks 162 Billy Wagner baseball cards across 110 sets (1993–2025), 137 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is Billy Wagner [Foil] #18 at $987 in PSA 10. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards: 162
Sets: 110
Priced: 137
Top card (PSA 10): $987
Raw total: $1.0K

Most valuable Billy Wagner cards

Billy Wagner [Foil] #18

$Billy Wagner [Blue Refractor] #19 1994 Bowman's Best card$

Billy Wagner [Blue Refractor] #19

1994 Bowman's Best

Raw $64.13PSA 10 $833

Billy Wagner [Gold Signature] #29

1994 Collector's Choice

Raw $13.63PSA 10 $553

$Billy Wagner [Blue Refractor] #32 1995 Bowman's Best card$

Billy Wagner [Blue Refractor] #32

1995 Bowman's Best

Raw $10.00PSA 10 $335

Billy Wagner #CLA-BW

2025 Topps Chrome Update Legends Autograph

Raw $81.00PSA 10 $328

Billy Wagner #264

1994 Pinnacle Museum Collection

Billy Wagner [Foil Die Cut] #18

1994 SP

Raw $3.09PSA 10 $283

Billy Wagner [Electric Diamond] #524

1994 Upper Deck

Raw $2.20PSA 10 $260

Billy Wagner [Blue] #19

1994 Bowman's Best

Raw $4.05PSA 10 $249

$Billy Wagner [Refractor] #74 1996 Topps Chrome card$

Billy Wagner [Refractor] #74

1996 Topps Chrome

Raw $47.93Graded $238

Cards by year

Every tracked Billy Wagner card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

20254 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #CLA-BW	2025 Topps Chrome Update Legends Autograph	$81.00	$95.00	$328	0%
Billy Wagner	2025 Topps T205 Autograph	$33.00	$59.23	$163	0%
Billy Wagner #852	2025 Topps Living Set	$7.99	$24.99	$60.53	0%
Billy Wagner #852	2025 Topps Living	$4.00	—	—	0%

20179 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #SCA-BW	2017 Stadium Club Autographs	$29.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #1987A-BW	2017 Topps 1987 Autographs	$28.91	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Black & White Orange] #102	2017 Stadium Club	$8.00	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #102	2017 Stadium Club	$3.45	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Black Foil] #102	2017 Stadium Club	$2.13	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold Foil] #102	2017 Stadium Club	$1.82	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Sepia] #102	2017 Stadium Club	$0.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [First Day Issue] #102	2017 Stadium Club	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [Members Only] #102	2017 Stadium Club	—	—	—	—

201610 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #HT-BW	2016 Topps High Tek Autograph	$22.72	$28.66	$55.39	0%
Billy Wagner #FFA-BW	2016 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Autograph	$34.00	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Red Border] #FFA-BW	2016 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Autograph	$47.21	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Blue Border] #FFA-BW	2016 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Autograph	$29.95	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Tidal Diffractor] #HT-BW	2016 Topps High Tek Autograph	$27.50	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Red Orbit Diffractor] #HT-BW	2016 Topps High Tek	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [5X7 Gold] #HT-BW	2016 Topps High Tek	$7.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #HT-BW	2016 Topps High Tek	$3.56	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Tidal Diffractor] #HT-BW	2016 Topps High Tek	$1.04	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [5X7] #HT-BW	2016 Topps High Tek	—	—	—	—

20111 card

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Gold] #13	2011 Topps	—	—	—	—

20102 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Gold] #US-266	2010 Topps Update	$4.49	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #CMT-159	2010 Topps Cards Your Mother Threw Out	—	—	—	—

20091 card

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #257	2009 Upper Deck	$0.99	—	$19.99	0%

20082 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Factory Set] #126	2008 Upper Deck First Edition	$0.25	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold] #UH328	2008 Topps Update & Highlights	—	—	—	—

20076 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #114	2007 Ultra	$0.25	—	$34.99	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold] #109	2007 Topps	$2.69	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Retail] #114	2007 Ultra	$0.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Predictor Blue] #386	2007 Upper Deck	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [Predictor Green] #386	2007 Upper Deck	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [Predictor Purple] #386	2007 Upper Deck	—	—	—	—

20065 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Gold] #207	2006 Topps	$5.99	$22.50	$85.08	0%
Billy Wagner #42	2006 Topps Heritage Chrome	$1.72	—	$20.50	0%
Billy Wagner [Chrome Black Refractor] #42	2006 Topps Heritage Chrome	$3.98	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #256	2006 Fleer	$1.77	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #198	2006 Bowman Heritage	$0.25	—	—	0%

20057 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #117	2005 Topps Chrome	$6.50	—	$35.00	0%
Billy Wagner #148	2005 Upper Deck	$2.97	$14.99	$18.00	0%
Billy Wagner #117	2005 Topps Opening Day	$0.74	—	$15.18	0%
Billy Wagner #291	2005 Donruss	$1.79	$9.99	$14.99	0%
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #117	2005 Topps Chrome	$4.50	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [First Edition] #117	2005 Topps	$0.25	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold] #117	2005 Topps	—	—	—	—

200411 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #145	2004 Topps	$1.75	$22.00	$99.99	0%
Billy Wagner #129	2004 Ultra	$1.59	—	$33.00	0%
Billy Wagner #140	2004 Upper Deck	$0.25	—	$24.99	0%
Billy Wagner #275	2004 Donruss	$4.53	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #240	2004 Fleer Tradition	$1.00	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [High Gloss] #140	2004 Upper Deck	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [High Gloss] #265	2004 Upper Deck	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [Gold] #T15	2004 Topps Traded	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [1st Edition] #145	2004 Topps	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [Gold] #145	2004 Topps	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner #FG-BW	2004 Topps Chrome Fashionably Great Relics	—	—	—	—

20035 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #95	2003 Topps	$1.66	$14.42	$41.55	0%
Billy Wagner #140	2003 Upper Deck	$4.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Home Team Advantage] #95	2003 Topps	$1.69	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold] #27	2003 Ultra	$1.84	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold] #95	2003 Topps	—	—	—	—

20029 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Gold Refractor] #172	2002 Topps Chrome	$7.61	$32.54	$147	0%
Billy Wagner #172	2002 Topps	$1.43	$39.99	$49.99	0%
Billy Wagner #170	2002 Topps Ten	$1.79	—	$27.79	0%
Billy Wagner #670	2002 Topps Total	$0.25	—	$13.50	0%
Billy Wagner #194	2002 Topps Heritage	$1.75	$11.99	—	0%
Billy Wagner #93	2002 Donruss Elite	$2.49	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Die Cut] #170	2002 Topps Ten	$1.49	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #138	2002 Donruss Best of Fan Club	$0.25	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold Medallion] #113	2002 Ultra	—	—	—	—

20015 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #468	2001 Topps	$1.99	$90.00	—	0%
Billy Wagner #186	2001 Fleer Platinum	$1.99	—	$31.00	0%
Billy Wagner [Platinum Edition] #186	2001 Fleer Platinum	$2.84	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Black Back] #69	2001 Topps Heritage	$2.25	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #81	2001 Bowman Heritage	$0.25	—	—	0%

20009 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #129	2000 Topps	$1.56	$40.00	$59.93	0%
Billy Wagner #RT10	2000 Topps Chrome All Star Rookie Team	$3.37	—	$39.99	0%
Billy Wagner #57	2000 Topps Opening Day	$0.25	—	$26.99	0%
Billy Wagner #128	2000 Skybox Dominion	$0.25	—	$26.99	0%
Billy Wagner #10	2000 Pacific Invincible	$1.93	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #129	2000 Upper Deck	$1.35	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #66	2000 Pacific Aurora	$0.25	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #129	2000 Topps Chrome	—	—	—	—
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #129	2000 Topps Chrome	—	—	—	—

19994 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #BWa	1999 SP Signature Autographs	$29.98	$89.99	$125	0%
Billy Wagner #31	1999 Skybox Thunder	$10.75	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #176	1999 Skybox Premium	$0.33	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #127	1999 Skybox Molten Metal	—	—	—	—

199810 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Devil Rays Inaugural] #3	1998 Topps	$2.53	—	$77.49	0%
Billy Wagner	1998 Donruss Signature Century Marks	$27.78	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #3	1998 Topps	$1.51	$34.95	$44.98	0%
Billy Wagner [Diamondbacks Inaugural] #3	1998 Topps	$2.75	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold Medallion] #59G	1998 Ultra	$1.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #281	1998 SPx Finite	$1.95	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Radiance] #281	1998 SPx Finite	$1.76	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #104	1998 Upper Deck	$1.74	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #59	1998 Ultra	$1.73	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Spectrum] #281	1998 SPx Finite	—	—	—	—

199714 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #42	1997 Bowman Chrome International	$37.99	$190	—	0%
Billy Wagner #42	1997 Bowman Chrome International	$3.79	—	$176	0%
Billy Wagner [Silver Press Proof] #91	1997 Panini Donruss	$1.99	$18.77	$80.43	0%
Billy Wagner #22	1997 Topps	$1.75	$11.50	$74.99	0%
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #102	1997 Finest Embossed	$29.00	$56.24	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Club Edition] #131	1997 Pinnacle Inside	$42.95	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #42	1997 Bowman Chrome	$1.25	$19.99	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Diamond Edition] #131	1997 Pinnacle Inside	$85.00	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #42	1997 Bowman Chrome	$2.83	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #33	1997 Stadium Club	$2.15	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Bronze] #135	1997 Panini Donruss Preferred	$1.50	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #131	1997 Pinnacle Inside	$1.05	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #AI 19	1997 Topps Awesome Impact	$0.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #98	1997 Pinnacle X Press	$0.25	—	—	0%

199620 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #74	1996 Topps Chrome	$47.93	$217	—	0%
Billy Wagner #74	1996 Topps Chrome	$3.75	$25.98	$136	0%
Billy Wagner [Atomic Refractor] #148	1996 Bowman's Best	$6.62	$14.50	$125	0%
Billy Wagner #218	1996 Leaf	$1.04	$15.00	$59.21	0%
Billy Wagner #425	1996 Collector's Choice	$0.99	$24.50	$57.77	0%
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #313	1996 Finest	$13.38	$40.00	—	0%
Billy Wagner #148	1996 Bowman's Best	$1.47	$13.99	$36.00	0%
Billy Wagner #398	1996 Panini Donruss	$1.69	—	$35.99	0%
Billy Wagner #422	1996 Fleer	$1.69	—	$29.99	0%
Billy Wagner #112	1996 Zenith	$1.90	$25.00	—	0%
Billy Wagner #336	1996 Bowman	$2.55	$24.99	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Atomic Refractor] #BBP8	1996 Bowman's Best Preview	$5.62	—	$24.50	0%
Billy Wagner [Refractor] #BBP8	1996 Bowman's Best Preview	$5.92	$21.29	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Foil] #12	1996 SP	$0.99	$21.00	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Bronze Press Proof] #218	1996 Leaf	$5.50	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #POY13	1996 Bowman	$1.95	$4.76	—	0%
Billy Wagner #422	1996 Fleer Tiffany	$3.56	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Silver Press Proof] #218	1996 Leaf	$1.99	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #168	1996 Danbury Mint 22KT Gold	—	—	—	—
billy wagner #32	1996 Score	—	—	—	—

19955 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Blue Refractor] #32	1995 Bowman's Best	$10.00	$65.44	$335	0%
Billy Wagner #60	1995 Upper Deck Minor League	$1.39	$8.69	$83.00	0%
Billy Wagner [Blue] #32	1995 Bowman's Best	$2.35	$18.42	—	0%
Billy Wagner [Future Stock] #60	1995 Upper Deck Minor League	$2.00	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #48	1995 Action Packed	$1.03	—	—	0%

199421 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner [Foil] #18	1994 SP	$4.28	$141	$987	0%
Billy Wagner #642	1994 Bowman	$5.43	$90.52	$975	0%
Billy Wagner [Blue Refractor] #19	1994 Bowman's Best	$64.13	$158	$833	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold Signature] #29	1994 Collector's Choice	$13.63	$123	$553	0%
Billy Wagner #264	1994 Pinnacle Museum Collection	$5.52	$57.00	$325	0%
Billy Wagner #209	1994 Topps Gold	$3.40	$55.00	$321	0%
Billy Wagner [Foil Die Cut] #18	1994 SP	$3.09	$236	$283	0%
Billy Wagner [Electric Diamond] #524	1994 Upper Deck	$2.20	$73.33	$260	0%
Billy Wagner [Blue] #19	1994 Bowman's Best	$4.05	$53.12	$249	0%
Billy Wagner #209	1994 Topps	$1.77	$26.99	$199	0%
Billy Wagner [Silver Signature] #29	1994 Collector's Choice	$1.62	$10.01	$171	0%
Billy Wagner [Gold Rush] #536	1994 Score	$2.76	$55.31	$122	0%
Billy Wagner #524	1994 Upper Deck	$1.64	$25.30	$98.75	0%
Billy Wagner #536	1994 Score	$1.03	$31.00	$65.16	0%
Billy Wagner #209	1994 Topps Bilingual	$2.00	$51.00	—	0%
Billy Wagner #29	1994 Collector's Choice	$1.00	$31.00	$44.99	0%
Billy Wagner #49	1994 Signature Rookies	$10.47	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #86	1994 Upper Deck Minors	$1.89	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #134	1994 Ted Williams Co	$1.79	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner #60	1994 Upper Deck Top Prospects	$0.25	—	—	0%
Billy Wagner [PRO FILES] #OP-12	1994 Upper Deck Top Prospects	—	—	—	—

19932 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Billy Wagner #269	1993 Classic	$0.99	$15.37	$180	0%
Billy Wagner #209	1993 Fleer Excel	$1.05	$19.99	$158	0%

Best Billy Wagner cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

FAQ

How many Billy Wagner cards are there?: Midpoint tracks 162 Billy Wagner baseball cards across 110 sets, released between 1993 and 2025. 137 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What is the most valuable Billy Wagner card?: The most valuable Billy Wagner card tracked by Midpoint is Billy Wagner [Foil] #18 from 1994 SP, currently $987 in PSA 10 (raw $4.28).
What years are Billy Wagner cards from?: Billy Wagner cards tracked by Midpoint run from 1993 to 2025; the earliest cards are from 1993.

All Baseball players Baseball card prices Baseball sets All sports

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your baseball card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Or try it on the web →