MidpointCard Centering Grading Portfolio App
Willie Mays #261 card

Willie Mays Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

527 cards · 310 sets · 1951–2026

Midpoint tracks 527 Willie Mays baseball cards across 310 sets (1951–2026), 429 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is Willie Mays #261 at $979,149 in PSA 10. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards
527
Sets
310
Priced
429
Top card (PSA 10)
$979,149
Raw total
$41K

Most valuable Willie Mays cards

1
Willie Mays #261 1952 Topps card
Willie Mays #261
1952 Topps
Raw $3,644PSA 10 $979,149
2
Willie Mays #305 1951 Bowman card
Willie Mays #305
1951 Bowman
Raw $2,526PSA 10 $616,625
3
Willie Mays #244 1953 Topps card
Willie Mays #244
1953 Topps
Raw $1,240PSA 10 $291,747
4
Willie Mays #218 1952 Bowman card
Willie Mays #218
1952 Bowman
Raw $1,048PSA 10 $250,730
5
Willie Mays #90 1954 Topps card
Willie Mays #90
1954 Topps
Raw $426PSA 10 $97,254
6
Willie Mays #194 1955 Topps card
Willie Mays #194
1955 Topps
Raw $330PSA 10 $79,200
7
Willie Mays #89 1954 Bowman card
Willie Mays #89
1954 Bowman
Raw $238PSA 10 $75,600
8
Willie Mays [Gray Back] #130 1956 Topps card
Willie Mays [Gray Back] #130
1956 Topps
Raw $281PSA 10 $60,216
9
Willie Mays [White Back] #130 1956 Topps card
Willie Mays [White Back] #130
1956 Topps
Raw $226PSA 10 $48,329
10
Willie Mays #184 1955 Bowman card
Willie Mays #184
1955 Bowman
Raw $177PSA 10 $42,814
11
Willie Mays #7 1955 Red Man Tobacco card
Willie Mays #7
1955 Red Man Tobacco
Raw $191PSA 10 $41,512
12
Willie Mays 1964 Topps Stand Up card
Willie Mays
1964 Topps Stand Up
Raw $239PSA 10 $38,978

Cards by year

Every tracked Willie Mays card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

20267 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #HL-402026 Topps Series 2 Heavy Lumber$37.39$69.43$2040%
Willie Mays #FIF-222026 Topps Finest Forces$8.38$21.78$64.680%
Willie Mays #GW-62026 Topps Series 2 Glove Work$1.80$12.86$38.360%
Willie Mays [Pink Foil] #GW-62026 Topps Series 2 Glove Work$1.75$12.78$38.140%
Willie Mays [All Star Game] #91B2-172026 Topps Series 2 1991$1.72$12.68$37.830%
Willie Mays #RVA-52026 Topps Chrome Rivals Away$1.54$12.49$37.350%
Willie Mays #91B2-172026 Topps Series 2 1991$1.50$12.27$36.640%

202532 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #AK-142025 Topps All Kings$323$650$1,2730%
Willie Mays [Dual] #T1LR-WM2025 Topps Tier One Legends Relic$750——0%
Willie Mays [Red Foil] #CTH-222025 Topps Call to the Hall$325——0%
Willie Mays #MFR-WM2025 Topps Allen and Ginter Mini Framed Relic$52.00$89.05$2490%
Willie Mays [Green] #T1LR-WM2025 Topps Tier One Legends Relic—$195——
Willie Mays #HL-142025 Topps Heavy Lumber$41.57$67.40$1800%
Willie Mays #SPR-WM2025 Topps Diamond Icons Single Player Relic$135——0%
Willie Mays #T1LR-WM2025 Topps Tier One Legends Relic$128——0%
Willie Mays [Red Foil] #MV-342025 Topps Update Most Valuable$125——0%
Willie Mays [Pink Sparkle] #3412025 Topps Heritage$2.38$13.41$70.000%
Willie Mays #B51-102025 Topps Shoebox Treasures 1951 Bowman Short Print$13.91$30.57$55.000%
Willie Mays [Topps Refractor] #4692025 Topps Chrome Platinum$5.00$17.92$53.09-4%
Willie Mays [Color of the Year] #3412025 Topps Heritage$21.19$40.09$49.990%
Willie Mays [Pink Foil] #MV-342025 Topps Update Most Valuable$4.39$16.62$48.140%
Willie Mays [Blue Sparkle Variation] #3412025 Topps Heritage$3.07$14.69$45.000%
Willie Mays [Allen Ginter Mini] #302025 Topps Allen and Ginter$2.92$14.49$42.65—
Willie Mays #3412025 Topps Heritage$1.44$12.08$41.500%
Willie Mays [Pink Foil] #CTH-222025 Topps Call to the Hall$2.13$13.02$37.630%
Willie Mays [Refractor Chrome Variation] #302025 Topps Allen and Ginter$1.94$16.50$37.520%
Willie Mays #ASGG-482025 Topps All-Star Game Greats$1.77$12.60$36.860%
Willie Mays #2242025 Topps Archives$1.45$12.21$36.130%
Willie Mays #MV-342025 Topps Update Most Valuable$1.49$12.23$36.100%
Willie Mays #CTH-222025 Topps Call to the Hall$1.69$12.39$36.030%
Willie Mays #90AS-302025 Topps 1990 All-Star$1.42$12.16$35.670%
Willie Mays [Chrome Variation] #302025 Topps Allen and Ginter$1.27$11.96$35.430%
Willie Mays #07AS-212025 Topps Archives 2007 All-Stars$1.25$11.90$35.280%
Willie Mays #90ASC-302025 Topps 1990 Chrome All-Star$1.25$11.87$34.890%
Willie Mays #442025 Topps Tribute$1.25$7.78$34.650%
Willie Mays [Black Foil] #CTH-222025 Topps Call to the Hall$33.00——0%
Willie Mays [Orange Mojo] #90ASC-302025 Topps 1990 Chrome All-Star$31.00——0%
Willie Mays [Wood Stock]2025 Topps T205$26.58——0%
Willie Mays [Red] #07AS-212025 Topps Archives 2007 All-Stars$24.76——0%

202439 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #CS-WMA2024 Topps Luminaries Cut Signature$5,000——0%
Willie Mays #102024 Panini Three and Two Downtown$419$425$1,0200%
Willie Mays [Platinum] #GOG-32024 Topps Grand Gamers$900——0%
Willie Mays #BRIP-WM2024 Topps Allen & Ginter Boxloader Rip Card$200——0%
Willie Mays [Platinum] #AC-62024 Topps Update All Class$119——0%
Willie Mays [Blue Xplosion] #202024 Donruss Bomb Squad$26.05$45.15$1120%
Willie Mays [Green Ice] #202024 Donruss Bomb Squad$100——0%
Willie Mays [Gold] #BG-212024 Topps Update Black Gold$19.99$37.55$96.480%
Willie Mays [Wood Stock]2024 Topps 206——$90.000%
Willie Mays [Green] #TVN-52024 Topps Stadium Club Triumvirates Nickname$3.75—$75.000%
Willie Mays [Black] #TVN-52024 Topps Stadium Club Triumvirates Nickname$10.47$24.49$65.300%
Willie Mays [Red Xplosion] #202024 Donruss Bomb Squad$16.99$32.91$65.000%
Willie Mays [Black] #PP-32024 Topps Stadium Club Power Packed$6.29$18.66$50.830%
Willie Mays #BG-212024 Topps Update Black Gold$1.32$17.25$46.470%
Willie Mays #TVN-52024 Topps Stadium Club Triumvirates Nickname$4.46$17.99$46.120%
Willie Mays [Holo] #202024 Donruss Bomb Squad$5.00$16.74$45.690%
Willie Mays [Blue] #BG-212024 Topps Update Black Gold$4.13$15.69$43.730%
Willie Mays [Red Prizm] #182024 Panini Select Icons$3.24$14.63$41.500%
Willie Mays #712024 Topps Triple Threads$3.19$14.48$41.110%
Willie Mays [Blue] #AT-182024 Topps Update Autumn Tales$2.99$14.13$39.970%
Willie Mays #TVN-62024 Topps Stadium Club Triumvirates Nickname$2.78$13.78$39.210%
Willie Mays [Black] #GOG-32024 Topps Grand Gamers$3.06$14.00$38.860%
Willie Mays #182024 Panini Select Icons$2.06$13.00$37.690%
Willie Mays [Blue] #89US-32024 Topps Update 1989$2.01$12.78$36.720%
Willie Mays #T89CU-232024 Topps Update 1989 Chrome Silver Pack$1.99$12.76$36.670%
Willie Mays #AT-182024 Topps Update Autumn Tales$1.75$12.42$35.850%
Willie Mays #202024 Donruss Bomb Squad$1.83$12.47$35.760%
Willie Mays #PP-32024 Topps Stadium Club Power Packed$1.59$8.50$35.370%
Willie Mays #89ASB-42024 Topps 1989 All-Stars$1.65$9.00$35.140%
Willie Mays [Green] #TVN-62024 Topps Stadium Club Triumvirates Nickname$35.14——0%
Willie Mays [Black] #AC-62024 Topps Update All Class$1.49$12.06$34.990%
Willie Mays #AC-62024 Topps Update All Class$1.49$14.99$34.980%
Willie Mays #32024 Donruss Milestones$1.50$12.02$34.710%
Willie Mays #GOG-32024 Topps Grand Gamers$1.62$15.00$34.680%
Willie Mays #952024 Donruss$1.25$11.71$34.07—
Willie Mays [Red] #AC-62024 Topps Update All Class$33.97——0%
Willie Mays [Blue] #89ASB-42024 Topps 1989 All-Stars$1.25$11.68$33.900%
Willie Mays [Blue] #AC-62024 Topps Update All Class$1.00$11.38$33.340%
Willie Mays #TVN-42024 Topps Stadium Club Triumvirates Nickname$2.78$15.00$29.500%

202317 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #HL-172023 Topps Heavy Lumber$49.75$50.51$1540%
Willie Mays [Alizarin Crimson] #642023 Topps X Bob Ross The Joy Of$125——0%
Willie Mays #MVP-WM2023 Topps Update MVP Medallion$6.39$17.94$45.920%
Willie Mays [Gold] #WC-82023 Topps Welcome to the Club$6.61—$45.000%
Willie Mays [Black] #WC-82023 Topps Welcome to the Club$3.00$13.72$37.450%
Willie Mays [Red] #T-292023 Stadium Club Triumvirates$5.49$16.82$36.000%
Willie Mays #OBG122023 Panini Prizm The Old Ball Game$1.20$11.50$34.990%
Willie Mays #T88C-462023 Topps Silver Pack 1988 Chrome$1.99$12.47$34.970%
Willie Mays #SB-102023 Topps Archives 1997 Seasons Best$1.99$12.47$34.940%
Willie Mays #69T-362023 Topps Archives 1969 Single Player Foil$1.70$12.13$34.270%
Willie Mays [Silver] #TB52023 Panini Prizm The Blueprints$1.33$11.66$33.340%
Willie Mays #TB52023 Panini Prizm The Blueprints$1.23$11.53$33.080%
Willie Mays #T-292023 Stadium Club Triumvirates$1.49$7.00$29.990%
Willie Mays #74PS-WM2023 Topps Heritage 1974 US Postage Stamp Relics$28.50——0%
Willie Mays #WC-232023 Topps Welcome to the Club$1.78$14.00$27.330%
Willie Mays #12023 Topps Allen & Ginter$1.59$12.03$26.990%
Willie Mays #SS-322023 Topps Allen & Ginter Spotless Spans$1.57$11.95$24.990%

202215 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays [Shipwreck Wood] #A-62022 Topps X Naturel 1952 Encased Art$193——0%
Willie Mays #LHA-52022 Topps Legendary Home Field Advantage$410$175—0%
Willie Mays [SSP Variation] #US242022 Topps Update$4.63$40.00$78.380%
Willie Mays #73PS-WM2022 Topps Heritage 1973 U.S. Postage Stamp Relics$73.08——0%
Willie Mays [Orange] #T-42022 Stadium Club Triumvirates$1.18—$54.890%
Willie Mays [Onyx] #1492022 Topps Fire$47.94——0%
Willie Mays #A-62022 Topps X Naturel 1952 Encased Art$7.50$18.71$45.010%
Willie Mays #BS-22022 Topps Allen & Ginter Banner Seasons$1.89$14.99$39.990%
Willie Mays #72022 Topps Game Within Game$3.99$35.00$37.990%
Willie Mays #682022 Topps Museum Collection$2.94$13.45$35.940%
Willie Mays #2822022 Topps Archives$1.69$9.99$33.880%
Willie Mays #DGC-252022 Topps Chrome Update Diamond Greats Die Cuts$1.70$11.99$33.430%
Willie Mays #T-192022 Stadium Club Triumvirates$1.49$11.73$32.980%
Willie Mays #CC42022 Topps X Naturel 1952 ComplexCon$29.99——0%
Willie Mays [Orange] #T-192022 Stadium Club Triumvirates$5.50$9.36—0%

20218 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #302021 Topps Project 70$11.99$49.99$60.000%
Willie Mays [Framed Mini Cloth]2021 Topps Allen & Ginter$50.00——0%
Willie Mays [Orange] #242021 Topps X Sports Illustrated$49.95——0%
Willie Mays #1762021 Topps Project 70$13.52$21.25$36.000%
Willie Mays #MILB-32021 Topps Pro Debut MiLB Legends$1.99$12.21$33.380%
Willie Mays #882021 Topps Triple Threads$1.99$12.18$33.220%
Willie Mays [Class 1] #102021 Topps Gold Label$1.75$11.92$32.840%
Willie Mays #22021 Topps 1951 Blake Jamieson$1.84$17.50$32.300%

20209 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #3002020 Topps Living$30.30$22.23$70.010%
Willie Mays #612020 Topps Project 2020$5.99$18.50$58.990%
Willie Mays #942020 Topps X Steve Aoki$1.96$19.24$49.950%
Willie Mays #152020 Topps Project 2020$43.59——0%
Willie Mays #802020 Topps Project 2020$6.00$7.00$38.130%
Willie Mays #482020 Topps Project 2020$23.79——0%
Willie Mays #272020 Topps Project 2020$35.00——0%
Willie Mays #DB-62020 Topps Decades' Best$1.00—$29.990%
WILLIE MAYS #DB-192020 Topps Update Decades' Best$1.21$11.27$24.990%

20191 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #T84U-362019 Topps Update 1984 Baseball 35th Anniversary$1.97$11.98$32.330%

20161 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #MLBD-222016 Topps MLB Debut$1.86$11.90$32.590%

20153 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #1002015 Topps Gypsy Queen$1.88$11.99$39.990%
Willie Mays #A-232015 Topps Archetypes$1.37$11.44$32.290%
Willie Mays #3002015 Topps Archives$1.79$21.56$29.990%

20142 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #532014 Stadium Club$1.97$12.17$34.070%
Willie Mays #932014 Topps Allen & Ginter$1.99$9.12$31.940%

20132 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #CTC-232013 Topps Cut to the Chase$1.96$11.99$35.070%
Willie Mays #TM-422013 Topps 1972 Minis$1.86—$31.500%

20123 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #FFAWM2012 Topps Archives Fan Favorite Autographs—$731——
Willie Mays #MBC22012 Topps Retail Refractor$1.99$28.00$50.010%
Willie Mays #BF-WM2012 Topps Heritage Baseball Flashbacks$2.16—$30.310%

20033 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays [Knothole Design] #1712003 Bowman Heritage$1.98$14.99$49.990%
Willie Mays #1712003 Bowman Heritage$1.25$13.42$47.150%
Willie Mays [Variation] #12003 Topps Gallery HOF$2.00—$32.000%

20023 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #ETC122002 Etopps Classic$17.99$31.00$99.990%
Willie Mays #922002 Topps Archives Reserve$2.83$10.00$73.430%
Willie Mays #12002 Topps Archives$2.00$14.99$60.900%

200114 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #TT1R2001 Topps Team Legends Autograph$500$1,056$4,0000%
Willie Mays #B-WM2001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers Cooperstown Collection Bat$39.47$132$6790%
Willie Mays [Significant Signatures] #1642001 Donruss Classics$692——0%
Willie Mays #TT1F2001 Topps Team Legends Autograph$246——0%
Willie Mays [1952 Reprint] #912001 Topps Archives Reserve$4.99$76.00$1170%
Willie Mays #142001 Fleer Tradition Stitches in Time$9.00$17.28$68.760%
Willie Mays2001 Topps Archives Baseball Bucks$1.00$13.37$47.940%
Willie Mays #192001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers$1.99$19.95$39.990%
Willie Mays [Foil, Retail Portrait] #502001 Topps Gallery$2.63$8.99$39.670%
Willie Mays #732001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers$1.17$14.92$36.990%
Willie Mays #502001 Topps Gallery$3.18$12.00$28.030%
Willie Mays #ES102001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers Endless Summer$1.90—$24.990%
Willie Mays [Foil, Hta Batting] #502001 Topps Gallery$3.71$16.20$24.610%
Willie Mays #GA42001 Topps Golden Anniversary$1.69—$24.470%

20001 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #J-WM2000 Upper Deck Legends Legendary Game Jerseys$3,800——0%

19994 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays1999 Upper Deck Piece of History 500 HR Club$396—$1,7500%
Willie Mays1999 Sports Illustrated Greats of the Game Autographs$495——0%
Willie Mays [Gold] #1031999 Upper Deck Retro$20.32—$89.000%
Willie Mays #1031999 Upper Deck Retro$1.25$14.99$28.990%

19977 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #61997 Topps Willie Mays$3.93$27.87$1330%
Willie Mays #151997 Topps Willie Mays$7.54$26.67$1260%
Willie Mays #221997 Topps Willie Mays$35.82$23.37$1070%
Willie Mays #251997 Topps Willie Mays$2.99$23.34$1070%
Willie Mays #191997 Topps Willie Mays$2.81$23.03$1050%
Willie Mays #81997 Topps Willie Mays$2.55$66.00—0%
Willie Mays #131997 Topps Willie Mays$10.00$54.63$66.000%

19934 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #TN181993 Upper Deck Then & Now$1.56$22.50$45.000%
Willie Mays #LC31993 Ted Williams Co. Locklear Collection$4.59—$34.990%
Willie Mays #21993 Stadium Club Ultra Pro$1.75$29.99—0%
Willie Mays #61993 Stadium Club Ultra Pro$1.65——0%

19921 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #81992 Ziploc$1.80$17.70$51.470%

19912 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #2441991 Topps Archives 1953$2.00$14.99$1130%
Willie Mays #31991 Kellogg's$1.95$26.25$73.000%

19891 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays1989 Kenner Starting Lineup Baseball Greats$1.99$85.00$1870%

19881 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #241988 Pacific Legends$1.36$10.00$30.250%

19871 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #81987 Kmart$2.25—$43.270%

19863 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays [Turn Back the Clock] #4031986 Topps Tiffany$1.99$23.55$64.150%
Willie Mays #501986 Sportflics Decade Greats$1.45$13.73$50.850%
Willie Mays #4031986 Topps$1.18$20.89$41.340%

19852 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #31985 Circle K$1.68$17.43$81.500%
Willie Mays #261985 Woolworth$1.22—$73.500%

19831 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #31983 Topps Stickers$2.23$45.00$1840%

19822 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays [White Back] #431982 TCMA Greatest Sluggers$1.50$27.03$1400%
Willie Mays #81982 Kmart$1.00—$86.610%

19811 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #1681981 Perez Steele HOF Postcard——$89.990%

19801 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #101980 Laughlin 300/400/500$4.70$47.00—0%

19773 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #81977 TCMA Renata Galasso$3.60$40.00$1050%
Willie Mays1977 Baseball's Great Hall of Fame Exhibits$12.75$77.00—0%
Willie Mays1977 Sertoma Stars$11.51——0%

19761 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #181976 Laughlin Diamond Jubilee$6.62$59.00$1200%

19752 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #6161975 SSPC$4.42$28.00$66.010%
Willie Mays #351975 SSPC Superstars$7.99——0%

19733 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #3051973 Topps$18.00$2,250$14,7900%
Willie Mays #3051973 O Pee Chee$48.93$1,300$5,5820%
Willie Mays1973 Topps Candy Lids$132——0%

19726 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #491972 Topps$23.16$1,378$17,1440%
Willie Mays [In Action] #501972 Topps$4.51$2,565—0%
Willie Mays #491972 O Pee Chee$35.17$1,439$4,1970%
Willie Mays [In Action] #501972 O Pee Chee$11.22$2,500$3,0000%
Willie Mays [RBI 1856] #541972 Kellogg's$14.90$193$1,0480%
Willie Mays [RBI 1855] #541972 Kellogg's$13.61$234$8210%

19719 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #6001971 O Pee Chee$247$4,412$29,0140%
Willie Mays #6001971 Topps$29.50$11,211$13,4530%
Willie Mays #561971 Topps Super$37.50$815$5,0440%
Willie Mays #411971 Topps Greatest Moments$298$4,050—0%
Willie Mays #11971 Milk Duds Complete Box$275$3,800—0%
Willie Mays #1531971 Topps Coins$12.75$249$1,6060%
Willie Mays #31971 Milk Duds Complete Box$190$1,179—0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut] #471971 Bazooka Numbered$300——0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut]1971 Milk Duds$28.00——0%

19706 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #181970 Topps Super$21.50$586$18,5410%
Willie Mays #6001970 Topps$26.84$3,625$4,0570%
Willie Mays #121970 Kellogg's$26.61$158$7530%
Willie Mays [Square Corner Proof] #181970 Topps Super$497——0%
Willie Mays1970 Transogram Hand Cut$170——0%
Willie Mays1970 Milton Bradley$21.50$67.00$1540%

196911 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #1901969 Topps$37.11$4,651$12,0000%
Willie Mays #1901969 O Pee Chee$68.86$1,150$7,5540%
Willie Mays1969 O Pee Chee Deckle$40.78$847$5,5550%
Willie Mays #651969 Topps Super$506$3,605—0%
Willie Mays #331969 Topps Deckle Edge$13.07$1,197$1,794-12%
Willie Mays1969 Topps Decals$18.94$99.99$4000%
Willie Mays1969 MLBPA Pins$6.75——0%
Willie Mays1969 Topps Stamps$10.26$72.70—0%
Willie Mays [Ace of Hearts]1969 Globe Imports Playing Cards$4.99——0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut]1969 Transogram$27.62——0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut]1969 Nabisco Team Flakes$26.75——0%

19687 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #501968 Topps$37.25$3,255$21,5350%
Willie Mays #501968 Venezuela Topps$403——0%
Willie Mays #501968 O Pee Chee$83.23$2,331$15,3680%
Willie Mays #81968 Topps Game$13.69$491$2,0220%
Willie Mays #51968 Topps Action All Star Stickers$404——0%
Willie Mays [Tipps From the Topps Hand Cut] #141968 Bazooka$281——0%
Willie Mays1968 Dexter Press Postcards$60.37——0%

19672 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #2001967 Topps$48.73$6,000$9,4090%
Willie Mays #121967 Topps Pin Ups$16.07$2,420$2,9040%

19662 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #11966 Topps$35.50$23,630$28,3560%
Willie Mays #11966 O Pee Chee$95.50$13,860$14,4500%

19654 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #2501965 Topps$55.08$6,093$8,5800%
Willie Mays #271965 Topps Embossed$10.63$352$1,3630%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut Looking Down] #121965 Bazooka$195——0%
Willie Mays1965 Topps Transfers$62.68——0%

19644 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays1964 Topps Stand Up$239$5,879$38,9780%
Willie Mays #511964 Topps Giants$126$1,444$18,625-1%
Willie Mays #1501964 Topps$55.40$11,000$13,2000%
Willie Mays1964 Wheaties Stamps$36.00$378$3,0250%

19635 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #3001963 Topps$108$2,936$19,4630%
Willie Mays #51963 Fleer$87.44$2,223$14,7980%
Willie Mays1963 Exhibits Statistic Back————
Willie Mays [Instruction Back]1963 Topps Peel Offs$32.58——0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut Bat in Front] #121963 Bazooka$116——0%

19627 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #3001962 Topps$72.07$18,007$21,6080%
Willie Mays [All Star] #3951962 Topps$34.00$3,000$5,9790%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut] #1421962 Post Cereal$13.80$1,437$1,8850%
Willie Mays1962 Exhibits Statistic Back$24.50——0%
Willie Mays1962 Topps Bucks$73.78——0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut]1962 Bazooka$330——0%
Willie Mays [Tony Kubek]1962 Topps Stamp Panels$34.39——0%

19615 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #5791961 Topps$74.54$4,940$13,5680%
Willie Mays #1501961 Topps$50.34$9,373$11,2480%
Willie Mays [MVP] #4821961 Topps$40.50$3,928$6,802-7%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut] #231961 Bazooka$114——0%
Willie Mays1961 Chemstrand Iron on Patch$45.37$225—0%

19603 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #2001960 Topps$106$26,605$31,9260%
Willie Mays [All Star] #5641960 Topps$71.56$3,000$12,8850%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut] #131960 Bazooka$175——0%

19597 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #501959 Topps$79.00$20,539$24,6470%
Willie Mays1959 Home Run Derby$1,500——0%
Willie Mays #5631959 Topps$60.50$4,448$11,3290%
Willie Mays #4641959 Topps$41.54$3,942$8,874+2%
Willie Mays [Baseball Thrills - Mays Catch Makes Series History] #4641959 Topps$59.06$3,650—0%
Willie Mays #501959 Venezuela Topps$703——0%
Willie Mays1959 Bazooka Hand Cut$375——0%

19583 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #51958 Topps$91.00$8,453$18,7430%
Willie Mays [All Star] #4861958 Topps$75.38$2,276$15,1330%
Willie Mays1958 San Francisco Call Bulletin Giants————

19571 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #101957 Topps$179$25,102$37,8600%

19562 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays [Gray Back] #1301956 Topps$281$42,000$60,2160%
Willie Mays [White Back] #1301956 Topps$226$7,248$48,3290%

19554 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #1941955 Topps$330$66,000$79,2000%
Willie Mays #1841955 Bowman$177$5,508$42,8140%
Willie Mays #71955 Red Man Tobacco$191$6,223$41,5120%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut Without Tab] #71955 Red Man Tobacco$93.88——0%

19545 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #901954 Topps$426$48,000$97,254+3%
Willie Mays #891954 Bowman$238$63,000$75,6000%
Willie Mays #251954 Red Man Tobacco$90.00$2,702$18,0140%
Willie Mays1954 NY Journal American$500——0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut Without Tab] #251954 Red Man Tobacco$76.76——0%

19531 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #2441953 Topps$1,240$53,680$291,7470%

19525 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #2611952 Topps$3,644$346,550$979,149+54%
Willie Mays #2181952 Bowman$1,048$139,238$250,7300%
Willie Mays #151952 Red Man Tobacco$200——0%
Willie Mays1952 Berk Ross$2,209$4,440—0%
Willie Mays [Hand Cut Without Tab]1952 Red Man Tobacco$229——0%

19511 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Willie Mays #3051951 Bowman$2,526$108,763$616,625-6%

Sets featuring Willie Mays

All Baseball sets →
1952 Topps (1)1951 Bowman (1)1953 Topps (1)1952 Bowman (1)1954 Topps (1)1955 Topps (1)1954 Bowman (1)1956 Topps (2)1955 Bowman (1)1955 Red Man Tobacco (2)1964 Topps Stand Up (1)1957 Topps (1)1960 Topps (2)1971 O Pee Chee (1)1966 Topps (1)1959 Topps (4)1962 Topps (2)1968 Topps (1)1968 Venezuela Topps (1)1963 Topps (1)1958 Topps (2)1964 Topps Giants (1)1970 Topps Super (2)1954 Red Man Tobacco (2)

Best Willie Mays cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

  1. 1
    Willie Mays #18 1970 Topps Super card
    Willie Mays #18
    1970 Topps Super
    Raw $21.50PSA 10 $18,541862× premium
  2. 2
    Willie Mays #305 1973 Topps card
    Willie Mays #305
    1973 Topps
    Raw $18.00PSA 10 $14,790822× premium
  3. 3
    Willie Mays #1 1966 Topps card
    Willie Mays #1
    1966 Topps
    Raw $35.50PSA 10 $28,356799× premium
  4. 4
    Willie Mays #49
    1972 Topps
    Raw $23.16PSA 10 $17,144740× premium
  5. 5
    Willie Mays #50 1968 Topps card
    Willie Mays #50
    1968 Topps
    Raw $37.25PSA 10 $21,535578× premium
  6. 6
    Willie Mays #600 1971 Topps card
    Willie Mays #600
    1971 Topps
    Raw $29.50PSA 10 $13,453456× premium

FAQ

How many Willie Mays cards are there?
Midpoint tracks 527 Willie Mays baseball cards across 310 sets, released between 1951 and 2026. 429 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What is the most valuable Willie Mays card?
The most valuable Willie Mays card tracked by Midpoint is Willie Mays #261 from 1952 Topps, currently $979,149 in PSA 10 (raw $3,644).
What years are Willie Mays cards from?
Willie Mays cards tracked by Midpoint run from 1951 to 2026; the earliest cards are from 1951.

Related

All Baseball playersBaseball card pricesBaseball setsAll sports

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your baseball card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Or try it on the web →

Best on iPhone & Android

The full Midpoint experience is in the app

Scan with your camera, get AI grades with corner and edge close-ups, issue Grade Certificates, set price alerts, track your portfolio and talk to other collectors — everything here, plus the parts a browser can't do. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play