MidpointCard Centering Grading Portfolio App
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #207 card

Colt McCoy Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

102 cards · 54 sets · 2010–2025

Midpoint tracks 102 Colt McCoy football cards across 54 sets (2010–2025), 77 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is Colt McCoy [Autograph Jersey] #102 at $52.50 raw. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards
102
Sets
54
Priced
77
Top card (raw)
$52.50
Raw total
$624

Most valuable Colt McCoy cards

1
Colt McCoy [Autograph Jersey] #102
2010 SP Authentic
Raw $52.50Graded $339
2
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #207 2010 Playoff Contenders card
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #207
2010 Playoff Contenders
Raw $15.99PSA 10 $106
3
Colt McCoy #BCR8
2010 Bowman Chrome Rookie Preview
Raw $1.23Graded $88.00
4
Colt McCoy [Cracked Ice] #17
2018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks Season Ticket Signatures
Raw $79.41
5
Colt McCoy [Brown Jersey Autograph] #207 2010 Playoff Contenders card
Colt McCoy [Brown Jersey Autograph] #207
2010 Playoff Contenders
Raw $25.00PSA 10 $67.00
6
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #222
2012 Topps Magic
Raw $7.29PSA 10 $53.14
7
Colt McCoy [White Jersey Autograph] #207 2010 Playoff Contenders card
Colt McCoy [White Jersey Autograph] #207
2010 Playoff Contenders
Raw $14.15PSA 10 $50.21
8
Colt McCoy #6 2011 Topps 1950 Bowman card
Colt McCoy #6
2011 Topps 1950 Bowman
Raw $1.99PSA 10 $46.00
9
Colt McCoy [Throwing, No Ball] #194
2010 Topps
Raw $43.00
10
Colt McCoy [Signature Material Gold] #307
2010 Playoff National Treasures
Raw $41.00
11
Colt McCoy [Patch Autograph Blue Team Logo] #262
2010 Panini Rookies & Stars
Raw $40.96
12
Colt McCoy [Refractor] #77
2010 Topps Finest
Raw $8.10Graded $39.99

Cards by year

Every tracked Colt McCoy card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

20254 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Colt McCoy #222025 Panini Flawless Game Used Memorabilia————
Colt McCoy #172025 Panini Prizm Black Sensational Signatures————
Colt McCoy [Silver] #172025 Panini Prizm Black Sensational Signatures————
Colt McCoy [Holo Gold] #102025 Panini Silhouette Profile Signatures————

20195 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Colt McCoy [White Shimmer] #612019 Panini Phoenix$17.63——0%
Colt McCoy [Color Burst] #612019 Panini Phoenix$2.51——0%
Colt McCoy [Silver] #612019 Panini Phoenix$2.00——0%
Colt McCoy #612019 Panini Phoenix$1.57——0%
Colt McCoy [Fire Burst] #612019 Panini Phoenix————

201812 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Colt McCoy [Cracked Ice] #172018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks Season Ticket Signatures$79.41——0%
Colt McCoy #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks$1.66$11.66$31.910%
Colt McCoy [Building Blocks] #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks$20.00——0%
Colt McCoy [Diamond] #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks$4.40——0%
Colt McCoy [Bowl] #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks$2.84——0%
Colt McCoy [Cracked Ice] #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks————
Colt McCoy [Blue Foil] #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks————
Colt McCoy [Fame] #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks————
Colt McCoy [Red Foil] #222018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks————
Colt McCoy [Blue Foil] #172018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks Season Ticket Signatures————
Colt McCoy [Bowl] #172018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks Season Ticket Signatures————
Colt McCoy [Playoff] #172018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks Season Ticket Signatures————

201218 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #2222012 Topps Magic$7.29$19.06$53.140%
Colt McCoy [Mini Blue Border] #2222012 Topps Magic$4.00——0%
Colt McCoy [Gold] #42012 Topps$2.98——0%
Colt McCoy #2222012 Topps Magic$2.48——0%
Colt McCoy [Scorecard] #2832012 Panini Score$2.25——0%
Colt McCoy [Mini] #2222012 Topps Magic$1.85——0%
Colt McCoy #252012 Panini Elite$1.69——0%
Colt McCoy #782012 Bowman$1.65——0%
Colt McCoy #2832012 Panini Score$1.60——0%
Colt McCoy #432012 Panini Prestige$1.50——0%
Colt McCoy #FM-CM2012 Topps Finest Moments$1.24——0%
Colt McCoy [Extra Points Gold] #432012 Panini Prestige$0.25——0%
Colt McCoy [True Blue] #332012 Panini Rookies & Stars$0.25——0%
Colt McCoy [Glossy] #2832012 Panini Score$0.25——0%
Colt McCoy [Silver O's] #442012 Panini Gridiron————
Colt McCoy [Silver X's] #442012 Panini Gridiron————
Colt McCoy [Mini Black Border] #2222012 Topps Magic————
Colt McCoy [Gold Zone] #2832012 Panini Score————

20119 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Colt McCoy #62011 Topps 1950 Bowman$1.99—$46.000%
Colt McCoy #192011 Panini Crown Royale$4.40——0%
Colt McCoy #162011 Topps$2.32——0%
Colt McCoy #222011 Playoff Contenders$1.79——0%
Colt McCoy #292011 Panini Gridiron Gear$1.74——0%
Colt McCoy #352011 Panini Threads$1.58——0%
Colt McCoy #232011 Panini Donruss Elite$1.52——0%
Colt McCoy #62011 Topps Rising Rookies$1.47——0%
Colt McCoy #682011 Panini Score$0.25——0%

201054 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Colt McCoy [Autograph Jersey] #1022010 SP Authentic$52.50$308—0%
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #2072010 Playoff Contenders$15.99$31.00$1060%
Colt McCoy #BCR82010 Bowman Chrome Rookie Preview$1.23$79.99—0%
Colt McCoy [Brown Jersey Autograph] #2072010 Playoff Contenders$25.00—$67.000%
Colt McCoy [White Jersey Autograph] #2072010 Playoff Contenders$14.15$25.96$50.210%
Colt McCoy [Throwing, No Ball] #1942010 Topps$43.00——0%
Colt McCoy [Signature Material Gold] #3072010 Playoff National Treasures$41.00——0%
Colt McCoy [Patch Autograph Blue Team Logo] #2622010 Panini Rookies & Stars$40.96——0%
Colt McCoy [Refractor] #772010 Topps Finest$8.10——0%
Colt McCoy #52B-222010 Topps 1952 Bowman$1.69$12.47$38.010%
Colt McCoy [Significant Signatures Gold] #1232010 Panini Classics$10.00——0%
Colt McCoy [Black Refractor] #BSACM2010 Bowman Sterling Autographs$17.50——0%
Colt McCoy #122010 Sage Hit$1.67$12.44$29.990%
Colt McCoy [Turn of the Century Autograph] #1902010 Panini Donruss Elite$12.00——0%
Colt McCoy #1332010 Topps Platinum$1.70$8.00$20.250%
Colt McCoy [Black Refractor] #772010 Topps Finest$11.13$10.00—0%
Colt McCoy [Signed Patch Red Refractor] #772010 Topps Finest$19.98——0%
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #2252010 Panini Crown Royale$12.14——0%
Colt McCoy #772010 Topps Finest$1.49$14.99$18.000%
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #1262010 Topps Unrivaled$15.00$15.67—0%
Colt McCoy [Jersey Autograph] #2772010 Panini Certified$15.18——0%
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #2232010 Panini Epix$14.15——0%
Colt McCoy [Xfractor] #772010 Topps Finest$6.00$10.00—0%
Colt McCoy #1232010 Panini Classics$2.68—$10.000%
Colt McCoy #3232010 Panini Score$3.51$5.77$10.00—
Colt McCoy [Rookie Premiere Materials Autograph] #2032010 Panini Absolute Memorabilia$9.99——0%
Colt McCoy [With Helmet Blue] #1942010 Topps$9.94——0%
Colt McCoy #1902010 Panini Donruss Elite$2.45——0%
Colt McCoy [With Helmet Black] #1942010 Topps$4.99——0%
Colt McCoy #192010 Panini Donruss Rated Rookies$1.47——0%
Colt McCoy [Timeless Tributes Silver] #1232010 Panini Classics$3.36——0%
Colt McCoy [Gold] #1232010 Panini Classics Significant Signatures$2.99——0%
Colt McCoy [Draft Picks Rights Autograph] #2232010 Panini Prestige$2.95——0%
Colt McCoy [Xtra Points Red] #2232010 Panini Prestige$2.54——0%
Colt McCoy #1262010 Topps Unrivaled$2.26——0%
Colt McCoy #1482010 Topps Magic$2.12——0%
Colt McCoy [Scorecard] #182010 Panini Score Hot Rookies$2.00——0%
Colt McCoy #2232010 Panini Prestige$1.65——0%
Colt McCoy #RS-142010 Topps Magic Rookie Stars$1.60——0%
Colt McCoy #762010 Sage Hit$1.49——0%
Colt McCoy #182010 Panini Score Hot Rookies$1.49——0%
Colt McCoy [With Helmet Gold] #1942010 Topps$1.44——0%
Colt McCoy [Mini] #1482010 Topps Magic$1.28——0%
Colt McCoy #WS72010 Sage Hit the Write Stuff$1.00——0%
Colt McCoy [Retail] #202010 Topps Prime$0.92——0%
Colt McCoy [Platinum] #1232010 Panini Classics Significant Signatures————
Colt McCoy [Xtra Points Orange] #2232010 Panini Prestige————
Colt McCoy2010 Topps Attax————
Colt McCoy [Autograph] #192010 Panini Donruss Rated Rookies————
Colt McCoy [Rke. Prem. Mat. Autograph AFC] #2032010 Panini Absolute Memorabilia————
Colt McCoy [Patch Autograph Emerald] #2622010 Panini Rookies & Stars————
Colt McCoy #1242010 Upper Deck Sweet Spot————
Colt McCoy #242010 Panini Rookies & Stars Cross Training————
Colt McCoy [Materials Autograph] #242010 Panini Rookies & Stars Cross Training————

Sets featuring Colt McCoy

All Football sets →
2010 SP Authentic (1)2010 Playoff Contenders (3)2010 Bowman Chrome Rookie Preview (1)2018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks Season Ticket Signatures (4)2012 Topps Magic (5)2011 Topps 1950 Bowman (1)2010 Topps (4)2010 Playoff National Treasures (1)2010 Panini Rookies & Stars (2)2010 Topps Finest (5)2010 Topps 1952 Bowman (1)2010 Panini Classics (3)2010 Bowman Sterling Autographs (1)2018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks (8)2010 Sage Hit (2)2010 Panini Donruss Elite (2)2010 Topps Platinum (1)2010 Panini Crown Royale (1)2019 Panini Phoenix (5)2010 Topps Unrivaled (2)2010 Panini Certified (1)2010 Panini Epix (1)2010 Panini Score (1)2010 Panini Absolute Memorabilia (2)

Best Colt McCoy cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

  1. 1
    Colt McCoy #6 2011 Topps 1950 Bowman card
    Colt McCoy #6
    2011 Topps 1950 Bowman
    Raw $1.99PSA 10 $46.0023× premium
  2. 2
    Colt McCoy #52B-22
    2010 Topps 1952 Bowman
    Raw $1.69PSA 10 $38.0122× premium
  3. 3
    Colt McCoy #22
    2018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks
    Raw $1.66PSA 10 $31.9119× premium
  4. 4
    Colt McCoy #12
    2010 Sage Hit
    Raw $1.67PSA 10 $29.9918× premium
  5. 5
    Colt McCoy #133
    2010 Topps Platinum
    Raw $1.70PSA 10 $20.2512× premium
  6. 6
    Colt McCoy [Autograph] #222
    2012 Topps Magic
    Raw $7.29PSA 10 $53.147.3× premium

FAQ

How many Colt McCoy cards are there?
Midpoint tracks 102 Colt McCoy football cards across 54 sets, released between 2010 and 2025. 77 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What is the most valuable Colt McCoy card?
The most valuable Colt McCoy card tracked by Midpoint is Colt McCoy [Autograph Jersey] #102 from 2010 SP Authentic, currently $52.50 raw.
What years are Colt McCoy cards from?
Colt McCoy cards tracked by Midpoint run from 2010 to 2025; the earliest cards are from 2010.

Related

All Football playersFootball card pricesFootball setsAll sports

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your football card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Or try it on the web →

Best on iPhone & Android

The full Midpoint experience is in the app

Scan with your camera, get AI grades with corner and edge close-ups, issue Grade Certificates, set price alerts, track your portfolio and talk to other collectors — everything here, plus the parts a browser can't do. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play