MidpointCard Centering Grading Portfolio App
Andrew Benintendi #AB card

Andrew Benintendi Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

328 cards · 146 sets · 2015–2026

Midpoint tracks 328 Andrew Benintendi baseball cards across 146 sets (2015–2026), 238 of them with live raw and graded market values. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards
328
Sets
146
Priced
238
Raw total
$1.6K

Most valuable Andrew Benintendi cards

1
Andrew Benintendi [Red Refractor] #ANB
2015 Bowman's Best of Autographs
Raw —Graded $140
2
Andrew Benintendi #ABE
2019 Topps Finest Blue Chips
Raw $1.44PSA 10 $128
3
Andrew Benintendi #ABE
2017 Topps Update 1987 Autographs
Raw $110
4
Andrew Benintendi [Chrome Gold Refractor] #CRA-ABE
2017 Bowman Rookie Autographs
Raw —Graded $100
5
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #CAAU-ANB
2017 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs
Raw $100
6
Andrew Benintendi #1987A-ABE
2017 Topps 1987 Autographs
Raw $11.50PSA 10 $92.45
7
Andrew Benintendi [Dugout Interview] #283
2017 Topps
Raw $24.23PSA 10 $66.74
8
Andrew Benintendi [Camo] #283
2017 Topps
Raw $57.00
9
Andrew Benintendi [Blue Wave Refractor] #FF-AB
2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs
Raw —Graded $50.00
10
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Minted] #SCC-77
2017 Stadium Club Chrome
Raw $49.99
11
Andrew Benintendi #NT-3
2017 Topps Heritage Now and Then
Raw $1.90PSA 10 $49.99
12
Andrew Benintendi #5T-49
2017 Topps Five Tool
Raw $0.60PSA 10 $49.97

Cards by year

Every tracked Andrew Benintendi card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

20262 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #3452026 Topps$1.61$12.50$37.070%
Andrew Benintendi #3452026 Topps$1.30$12.29$36.460%

20259 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #CCR-ABE2025 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Relic$2.30$13.28$38.470%
Andrew Benintendi #PR-AB2025 Topps Holiday Player Relic$1.95$12.96$38.090%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #3442025 Topps$1.91$12.72$36.870%
Andrew Benintendi [Chrome Variation] #772025 Topps Heritage$1.39$12.00$35.180%
Andrew Benintendi #772025 Topps Heritage$0.99$11.43$33.690%
Andrew Benintendi #3442025 Topps$0.30$10.40$31.000%
Andrew Benintendi #1972025 Topps Chrome$0.25$10.37$30.980%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #CCR-ABE2025 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Relic$5.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #H842025 Topps Holiday$0.50——0%

20244 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #3062024 Topps$1.79$12.35$35.200%
Andrew Benintendi #H1312024 Topps Holiday$1.50$12.10$35.130%
Andrew Benintendi #SJR-ABE2024 Topps Triple Threads Single Jumbo Relic$5.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #332024 Topps Chrome$0.49——0%

20236 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #US282023 Topps Update$1.66$12.06$34.130%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #1972023 Topps$1.32$11.64$33.290%
Andrew Benintendi #1972023 Topps$1.30$7.00$33.240%
Andrew Benintendi #USCS282023 Topps Chrome Update Sapphire$1.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi #US282023 Topps Update$1.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #502023 Topps Finest Flashbacks$1.30——0%

202210 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #4962022 Topps Living$4.52$16.27$47.130%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #VA-AB2022 Topps Gallery Veteran Autographs$9.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #T87C-72022 Topps Update 1987 Chrome$1.75—$9.380%
Andrew Benintendi #VA-AB2022 Topps Gallery Veteran Autographs$5.80——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #4752022 Topps$1.69——0%
Andrew Benintendi #87TB-182022 Topps 1987 Series 2$1.49——0%
Andrew Benintendi #212022 Topps Finest Flashback$1.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #282022 Topps Opening Day————
Andrew Benintendi #T87CA-AB2022 Topps Update 1987 Chrome Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #QJA-AB2022 Panini Three and Two Quad Jersey Autographs————

20217 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #CBA-ABE2021 Topps Chrome Black Autographs$7.57$18.26$42.250%
Andrew Benintendi #CUSA-AB2021 Topps Chrome Update Autographs$36.16——0%
Andrew Benintendi #86c-332021 Topps Update 1986 Chrome Silver Pack$2.79——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #1542021 Topps$1.48——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #US3002021 Topps Update$1.33——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Lenox Brown Wave 2]2021 Topps 206————
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #86c-332021 Topps Update 1986 Chrome Silver Pack————

202019 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #ROA-AB2020 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs$18.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi #352020 Bowman Platinum$0.08——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Black] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo$3.42——0%
Andrew Benintendi #1172020 Topps Gypsy Queen Chrome Box Toppers$2.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Silver Holo Foil] #1912020 Topps Archives$2.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi #312020 Topps X Steve Aoki$1.89——0%
Andrew Benintendi #1912020 Topps Archives$1.48——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #1962020 Topps$1.35——0%
Andrew Benintendi #WHR-AN2020 Topps Holiday Relics$1.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo$1.24——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo————
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo————
Andrew Benintendi [Green] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo————
Andrew Benintendi [Orange] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo————
Andrew Benintendi [Purple] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo————
Andrew Benintendi [Red] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo————
Andrew Benintendi [SuperFractor] #CPC-262020 Topps Update Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Promo————
ANDREW BENINTENDI [GOLD] #SPQR-AB2020 Topps Museum Collection Single Player Primary Pieces Quad Relic Legends————
Andrew Benintendi [Pink Frosting Holographic Foilboard] #312020 Topps X Steve Aoki————

201915 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2019 Topps Finest Blue Chips$1.44—$1280%
Andrew Benintendi #AB2019 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Relics$2.98$13.02$33.560%
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2019 Topps Major League Material$1.97—$22.000%
Andrew Benintendi [Metallic] #HW1222019 Topps Holiday Mega Box$1.06—$11.500%
Andrew Benintendi #752019 Bowman Platinum$1.02—$9.880%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #AB2019 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Relics$5.88——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #5792019 Topps$1.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2019 Topps 1984 Baseball Relics$2.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #ABE2019 Topps Finest Blue Chips$1.78——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Class 1] #102019 Topps Gold Label$1.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #HT-292019 Topps Gallery Heritage$0.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Framed Mini Cloth]2019 Topps Allen & Ginter————
Andrew Benintendi [Red] #ABE2019 Topps Finest Blue Chips————
Andrew Benintendi [150th Anniversary] #ABE2019 Topps 1984 Baseball Relics————
Andrew Benintendi #AB2019 Topps Chrome Autographs————

201847 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2018 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs$20.00$22.50$28.390%
Andrew Benintendi #BNR-AB2018 Bowman Chrome National Convention$5.26$25.00—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Minted] #SCC-1782018 Stadium Club Chrome$15.48——0%
Andrew Benintendi #622018 Topps Living$2.99$7.63$12.990%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #H-142018 Topps Gallery Heritage$9.45——0%
Andrew Benintendi #FS-132018 Topps Chrome Future Stars$1.78—$9.220%
Andrew Benintendi [Green Refractor] #FS-132018 Topps Chrome Future Stars$3.07$7.46—0%
Andrew Benintendi #II-102018 Topps Instant Impact$1.17$5.99—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Orange] #NC-AB2018 Stadium Club Never Compromise$5.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Limited] #5562018 Topps$4.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Class 2 Black] #242018 Topps Gold Label$3.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi #172018 Topps Heritage 1969 Deckle Edge$1.64—$3.040%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #5562018 Topps$2.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Red] #NC-AB2018 Stadium Club Never Compromise$2.84——0%
Andrew Benintendi #OD222018 Topps Now Road to Opening Day$2.69——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Black] #FS-192018 Topps Future Stars$2.55——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Sky Blue] #402018 Bowman Platinum$2.49——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Red] #BT-AB2018 Stadium Club Beam Team$2.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #2762018 Topps Big League$2.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi #BT-AB2018 Stadium Club Beam Team$1.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #II-102018 Topps Instant Impact$1.88——0%
Andrew Benintendi #HT-ABE2018 Topps High Tek$1.79——0%
Andrew Benintendi #H-142018 Topps Gallery Heritage$1.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi #FS-192018 Topps Future Stars$1.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi #402018 Bowman Platinum$1.74——0%
Andrew Benintendi #552018 Topps Inception$1.72——0%
Andrew Benintendi #TS-622018 Topps Salute$1.67——0%
Andrew Benintendi #AB2018 Topps Legends in the Making$1.33——0%
Andrew Benintendi #NC-AB2018 Stadium Club Never Compromise$1.31——0%
Andrew Benintendi [White Jersey Blue Foil] #1502018 Topps Opening Day$1.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi #2762018 Topps Big League$1.02——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Black] #NC-AB2018 Stadium Club Never Compromise$0.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Orange Refractor] #FS-132018 Topps Chrome Future Stars$0.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [High Number] #ABE2018 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Relics$0.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Black] #AB2018 Topps Legends in the Making$0.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #2762018 Topps Big League$0.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Class 1] #242018 Topps Gold Label$0.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi [White Jersey] #1502018 Topps Opening Day$0.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi #222018 Bowman's Best$0.12——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Batting 1st Day Issue] #1782018 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Batting Rainbow Foil] #1782018 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Batting Black & White] #1782018 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Red Refractor] #FS-132018 Topps Chrome Future Stars————
Andrew Benintendi [Onyx] #1692018 Topps Fire————
Andrew Benintendi [Orange] #H-142018 Topps Gallery Heritage————
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2018 Topps Update 1983 Baseball Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #ABE2018 Topps Update 1983 Baseball Autographs————

2017152 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2017 Topps Update 1987 Autographs$110——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Chrome Gold Refractor] #CRA-ABE2017 Bowman Rookie Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #CAAU-ANB2017 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs$100——0%
Andrew Benintendi #1987A-ABE2017 Topps 1987 Autographs$11.50$24.00$92.450%
Andrew Benintendi [Dugout Interview] #2832017 Topps$24.23—$66.740%
Andrew Benintendi [Camo] #2832017 Topps$57.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue Wave Refractor] #FF-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs—$45.00——
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Minted] #SCC-772017 Stadium Club Chrome$49.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi #NT-32017 Topps Heritage Now and Then$1.90—$49.990%
Andrew Benintendi #5T-492017 Topps Five Tool$0.60$2.25$49.970%
Andrew Benintendi [Batting] #132017 Bowman Platinum$1.00$33.00$40.000%
Andrew Benintendi #922017 Topps Museum Collection$1.49—$39.990%
Andrew Benintendi [Chrome] #CRA-ABE2017 Bowman Rookie Autographs$11.22——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Refractor] #B17-ABE2017 Bowman's Best of Autograph——$36.000%
Andrew Benintendi #RA-ABE2017 Topps Chrome Rookie Autographs$16.18$19.00$35.000%
Andrew Benintendi [Green Refractor] #FF-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs$8.65$15.50—0%
Andrew Benintendi #252017 Topps Update 1987$80.00$4.73$34.990%
Andrew Benintendi [Autograph] #RR-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Rookie Radar$10.50$31.00—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Orange Refractor] #87T-252017 Topps Chrome 1987$3.75$27.99$34.000%
Andrew Benintendi [Batting Powder Blue] #2832017 Topps$15.75$30.69—0%
Andrew Benintendi #87-1642017 Topps 1987$1.99—$32.530%
Andrew Benintendi #TH-AB2017 Topps Holiday Bowman$2.17$27.84—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #87-AB2017 Topps Silver Pack Promo——$30.000%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue Refractor] #FF-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs$6.13——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Refractor] #FF-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi [Mini] #3572017 Topps Allen & Ginter$30.00—$27.340%
Andrew Benintendi #97BC-ABE2017 Bowman's Best 1997 Cuts$1.56—$26.850%
Andrew Benintendi #B17-ABE2017 Bowman's Best of Autograph$13.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Batting Rainbow Foil] #2832017 Topps$1.79—$25.550%
Andrew Benintendi [Autograph] #PP-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Presence$10.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #FA-AB2017 Topps Finest Autographs$25.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [White Sparkle] #342017 Panini Donruss Optic$24.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi #FFA-ABE2017 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Autographs$12.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Chrome Blue Refractor] #CRA-ABE2017 Bowman Rookie Autographs$39.64—$24.270%
Andrew Benintendi [Chrome Green Refractor] #CRA-ABE2017 Bowman Rookie Autographs$23.01——0%
Andrew Benintendi #CAAU-AB2017 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs$84.07$19.99—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Holding Bat] #2832017 Topps$3.95$18.02$22.000%
Andrew Benintendi [Peach] #FFA-ABE2017 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Autographs$21.72——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Red Wave Refractor] #FF-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi [Autograph] #ABE2017 Topps High Tek$6.06——0%
Andrew Benintendi #72017 Topps Now$1.99—$20.150%
Andrew Benintendi #RS-32017 Topps Archives 1960 Rookie Star$1.62$8.27$19.990%
Andrew Benintendi [Red Refractor] #87T-252017 Topps Chrome 1987$19.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2017 Topps Archives 1960 Rookie Star Autographs$19.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Autograph] #AS-ABE2017 Topps Archives Snapshots$19.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #42017 Panini Chronicles Prizm$1.23—$19.180%
Andrew Benintendi #87T-252017 Topps Chrome 1987$1.35$14.99$18.000%
Andrew Benintendi #FF-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs$6.90—$17.500%
Andrew Benintendi [Holo] #342017 Panini Donruss Optic$1.43$14.00$17.000%
Andrew Benintendi [Hot Box Foil] #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter$1.49$7.53$16.500%
Andrew Benintendi [Red Jersey] #2832017 Topps Complete Set Exclusives——$16.240%
Andrew Benintendi #82017 Topps Heritage 1968 Game Rookies$5.03—$16.060%
Andrew Benintendi [Purple] #RR-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Rookie Radar$2.26——0%
Andrew Benintendi #GQA-ABE2017 Topps Gypsy Queen Autographs$12.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi #FSI-ABE2017 Topps Five Star Signature$14.88——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Pink] #342017 Panini Donruss Optic$2.00$12.50—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Green Refractor] #FF-202017 Topps Chrome Freshman Flash$13.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #662017 Topps Finest$1.05$5.00$13.130%
Andrew Benintendi #S-922017 Topps Salute$1.50—$13.120%
Andrew Benintendi [Batting Gold] #2832017 Topps$5.69——0%
Andrew Benintendi #112017 Topps Bunt$1.19—$12.280%
Andrew Benintendi #87-AB2017 Topps Silver Pack Promo$4.49$10.01$11.990%
Andrew Benintendi #SCA-AB2017 Stadium Club Autographs$11.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Green] #PP-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Presence$10.89——0%
Andrew Benintendi #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter$1.79—$10.750%
Andrew Benintendi [Black & White] #AS-ABE2017 Topps Archives Snapshots$6.99—$10.500%
Andrew Benintendi [Missing Blackplate] #GQA-ABE2017 Topps Gypsy Queen Autographs$8.58——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Red] #TR42017 Panini Donruss Optic the Rookies$1.95—$10.000%
Andrew Benintendi [White Jersey Framed Gray] #1312017 Panini Diamond Kings——$10.000%
Andrew Benintendi [Orange Refractor] #FF-202017 Topps Chrome Freshman Flash$1.27—$9.970%
Andrew Benintendi [Green] #TR42017 Panini Donruss Optic the Rookies$9.70——0%
Andrew Benintendi #OS-152017 Topps Now Off Season$1.21$3.25$9.620%
Andrew Benintendi #87-632017 Topps 1987$1.60—$9.500%
Andrew Benintendi #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter X$2.00$7.10$9.000%
Andrew Benintendi #2832017 Topps$1.50$8.01$9.000%
Andrew Benintendi #FF-202017 Topps Chrome Freshman Flash$1.49—$8.690%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue Refractor] #FA-AB2017 Topps Finest Autographs$8.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #CAAU-ANB2017 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs$8.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #342017 Panini Donruss Optic$1.88$3.26$8.260%
Andrew Benintendi #342017 Panini Donruss$1.89—$7.990%
Andrew Benintendi [Red Holiday Sweater] #TH-AB2017 Topps Holiday Bowman$7.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Batting] #2832017 Topps$0.90$6.20$7.500%
Andrew Benintendi #ABE2017 Topps High Tek$0.99—$7.420%
Andrew Benintendi [Mini Black Border] #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter$4.90$5.00—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Mini] #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter X$4.50—$5.680%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #112017 Topps Bunt$2.99—$5.500%
Andrew Benintendi #OS-322017 Topps Now Off Season—$4.50$5.500%
Andrew Benintendi #BT-AB2017 Stadium Club Beam Team$2.10—$5.500%
Andrew Benintendi [Green Holiday Sweater] #TH-AB2017 Topps Holiday Bowman$5.14——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Batting Purple] #2832017 Topps$4.51——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Green] #RR-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Rookie Radar$4.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Outfield Wall] #1492017 Stadium Club$1.99$3.91—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Mini] #87-1642017 Topps 1987$3.70——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue Winter Wonderland] #TH-AB2017 Topps Holiday Bowman$3.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi #AB2017 Topps Heritage Rookie Performers$2.95——0%
Andrew Benintendi #RR-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Rookie Radar$1.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi #SCC-772017 Stadium Club Chrome$2.79——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Orange] #RR-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Rookie Radar$2.78——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Refractor] #SCC-772017 Stadium Club Chrome$2.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi #PP-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Presence$2.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Mini] #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter$2.23——0%
Andrew Benintendi #AS-ABE2017 Topps Archives Snapshots$2.12——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Atomic Refractor] #97BC-ABE2017 Bowman's Best 1997 Cuts$2.09——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue] #TR42017 Panini Donruss Optic the Rookies$1.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi #TR42017 Panini Donruss Optic the Rookies$1.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi #USS-292017 Topps Update Salute$1.69——0%
Andrew Benintendi #ROYF-52017 Bowman Rookie of the Year Favorites$1.64——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Outfield Wall Gold Foil] #1492017 Stadium Club$1.62——0%
Andrew Benintendi #TR-42017 Panini Donruss the Rookies$1.59——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Refractor] #ROYF-52017 Bowman Rookie of the Year Favorites$1.49——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Press Proof] #TR-42017 Panini Donruss the Rookies$1.39——0%
Andrew Benintendi #FFI-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts$1.32——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Press Proof] #TR-42017 Panini Donruss the Rookies$1.04——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Turkey] #TH-AB2017 Topps Holiday Bowman$1.04——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Cyan Back] #TR-42017 Panini Donruss the Rookies$0.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Class 2] #482017 Topps Gold Label$0.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Hand Near Face] #132017 Bowman Platinum————
Andrew Benintendi [Orange] #PP-ABE2017 Bowman Platinum Presence————
Andrew Benintendi #ROYFI-ABE2017 Bowman Mega Box Chrome Rookie of the Year Favorites————
Andrew Benintendi [Green Refractor] #ROYFI-ABE2017 Bowman Mega Box Chrome Rookie of the Year Favorites————
Andrew Benintendi [Orange Refractor] #ROYFI-ABE2017 Bowman Mega Box Chrome Rookie of the Year Favorites————
Andrew Benintendi [Purple Refractor] #ROYFI-ABE2017 Bowman Mega Box Chrome Rookie of the Year Favorites————
Andrew Benintendi [Chrome Orange Refractor] #CRA-ABE2017 Bowman Rookie Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Refractor] #97BC-ABE2017 Bowman's Best 1997 Cuts————
Andrew Benintendi #97BCA-ABE2017 Bowman's Best 1997 Cuts Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi [Aqueous Test Proof] #TR-42017 Panini Donruss the Rookies————
Andrew Benintendi [Artist Proof] #TR-42017 Panini Donruss the Rookies————
Andrew Benintendi [Green] #RRS-AX2017 Panini Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Signatures————
Andrew Benintendi [Holo] #RRS-AX2017 Panini Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Signatures————
Andrew Benintendi [Orange] #RRS-AX2017 Panini Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Signatures————
Andrew Benintendi [Gold] #TR42017 Panini Donruss Optic the Rookies————
Andrew Benintendi [Orange Refractor] #FFI-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts————
Andrew Benintendi [Red Refractor] #FFI-AB2017 Topps Finest Firsts————
Andrew Benintendi [Flash] #42017 Panini Chronicles Prizm————
Andrew Benintendi [White Jersey] #1312017 Panini Diamond Kings————
Andrew Benintendi [Blue Jersey] #1312017 Panini Diamond Kings————
Andrew Benintendi [White Jersey Framed Green] #1312017 Panini Diamond Kings————
Andrew Benintendi [With Teammate] #1492017 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Outfield Wall Black Foil] #1492017 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Outfield Wall Black & White Orange] #1492017 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Outfield Wall First Day Issue] #1492017 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Outfield Wall Members Only] #1492017 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Outfield Wall Sepia] #1492017 Stadium Club————
Andrew Benintendi [Mini Gold Border] #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter————
Andrew Benintendi [Mini No Number]2017 Topps Allen & Ginter————
Andrew Benintendi [Glossy] #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter X————
Andrew Benintendi [Mini Brooklyn Back] #2372017 Topps Allen & Ginter X————
Andrew Benintendi [Light Blue] #RS-32017 Topps Archives 1960 Rookie Star————
Andrew Benintendi [Soft Red] #RS-32017 Topps Archives 1960 Rookie Star————
Andrew Benintendi #C-172017 Topps Archives Manufactured Coins————
Andrew Benintendi [Sky Blue] #C-172017 Topps Archives Manufactured Coins————
Andrew Benintendi [Black] #112017 Topps Bunt————

201613 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi #PA-ABE2016 Bowman Inception Prospect Autographs$15.75——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Orange] #PP-82016 Bowman Platinum Presence$32.74——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Green] #TPA-ABE2016 Bowman Platinum Top Prospects Autograph$29.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi #B16-ABE2016 Bowman's Best of 2016 Autograph$7.62—$20.500%
Andrew Benintendi #BP622016 Bowman Prospects$1.31$6.07$14.150%
Andrew Benintendi #TPA-ABE2016 Bowman Platinum Top Prospects Autograph$11.50——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Atomic Refractor] #96BB-AB2016 Bowman's Best 1996$5.00——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Green] #PP-82016 Bowman Platinum Presence$2.38——0%
Andrew Benintendi #96BB-AB2016 Bowman's Best 1996$1.94——0%
Andrew Benintendi #PP-82016 Bowman Platinum Presence$1.93——0%
Andrew Benintendi #TP-ABE2016 Bowman Platinum Top Prospects$1.25——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Yellow] #BP622016 Bowman Prospects$0.99——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Silver] #BP622016 Bowman Prospects$0.25——0%

201516 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Andrew Benintendi [Red Refractor] #ANB2015 Bowman's Best of Autographs————
Andrew Benintendi #ANB2015 Bowman's Best of Autographs$7.19$10.00$46.240%
Andrew Benintendi [Green Refractor] #ANB2015 Bowman's Best of Autographs$17.15$17.00$45.240%
Andrew Benintendi [Atomic Refractor] #ANB2015 Bowman's Best of Autographs$19.38$9.50—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Aspirations Die Cut Signature] #82015 Panini Elite Extra Edition$5.14$27.00—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Refractor] #ANB2015 Bowman's Best of Autographs$9.99$21.00$24.870%
Andrew Benintendi [Refractor] #TP-372015 Bowman's Best Top Prospects$1.77—$20.500%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Refractor] #TP-372015 Bowman's Best Top Prospects——$16.100%
Andrew Benintendi [Atomic Refractor] #TP-372015 Bowman's Best Top Prospects$4.99—$12.800%
Andrew Benintendi [Gold Refractor] #1822015 Bowman Chrome$3.70$9.00$11.750%
Andrew Benintendi [Blue Refractor] #TP-372015 Bowman's Best Top Prospects—$6.50$10.500%
Andrew Benintendi #BSIAB2015 Bowman Chrome Draft Scouts Fantasy Impact$22.95—$5.030%
Andrew Benintendi [Prospects Signature] #82015 Panini Elite Extra Edition$13.13$4.25—0%
Andrew Benintendi [Green Refractor] #TP-372015 Bowman's Best Top Prospects$2.94——0%
Andrew Benintendi [Aspirations Die Cut] #82015 Panini Elite Extra Edition$1.92——0%
Andrew Benintendi #82015 Panini Elite Extra Edition$0.99——0%

Sets featuring Andrew Benintendi

All Baseball sets →
2015 Bowman's Best of Autographs (5)2019 Topps Finest Blue Chips (3)2017 Topps Update 1987 Autographs (2)2017 Bowman Rookie Autographs (5)2017 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs (3)2017 Topps 1987 Autographs (1)2017 Topps (13)2017 Topps Finest Firsts Autographs (6)2017 Stadium Club Chrome (3)2017 Topps Heritage Now and Then (1)2017 Topps Five Tool (1)2022 Topps Living (1)2021 Topps Chrome Black Autographs (1)2016 Bowman Inception Prospect Autographs (1)2017 Bowman Platinum (2)2017 Topps Museum Collection (1)2025 Topps Heritage Clubhouse Collection Relic (2)2025 Topps Holiday Player Relic (1)2026 Topps (2)2025 Topps (2)2021 Topps Chrome Update Autographs (1)2017 Bowman's Best of Autograph (2)2024 Topps (1)2025 Topps Heritage (2)

Best Andrew Benintendi cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

  1. 1
    Andrew Benintendi #197
    2025 Topps Chrome
    Raw $0.25PSA 10 $30.98124× premium
  2. 2
    Andrew Benintendi #344
    2025 Topps
    Raw $0.30PSA 10 $31.00103× premium
  3. 3
    Andrew Benintendi #ABE
    2019 Topps Finest Blue Chips
    Raw $1.44PSA 10 $12889× premium
  4. 4
    Andrew Benintendi #5T-49
    2017 Topps Five Tool
    Raw $0.60PSA 10 $49.9783× premium
  5. 5
    Andrew Benintendi [Batting] #13
    2017 Bowman Platinum
    Raw $1.00PSA 10 $40.0040× premium
  6. 6
    Andrew Benintendi #77
    2025 Topps Heritage
    Raw $0.99PSA 10 $33.6934× premium

FAQ

How many Andrew Benintendi cards are there?
Midpoint tracks 328 Andrew Benintendi baseball cards across 146 sets, released between 2015 and 2026. 238 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What years are Andrew Benintendi cards from?
Andrew Benintendi cards tracked by Midpoint run from 2015 to 2026; the earliest cards are from 2015.

Related

All Baseball playersBaseball card pricesBaseball setsAll sports

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your baseball card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Or try it on the web →

Best on iPhone & Android

The full Midpoint experience is in the app

Scan with your camera, get AI grades with corner and edge close-ups, issue Grade Certificates, set price alerts, track your portfolio and talk to other collectors — everything here, plus the parts a browser can't do. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play