Is Don Mattingly #1 worth grading?
Baseball · Baseball Cards 1986 Fleer All Stars · full price guide →
Worth grading — even a PSA 9 beats raw
A PSA 10 Don Mattingly #1 sells for $370 against $2.99 raw: a $367 spread, 124× the ungraded price. Even a PSA 9 ($41.90) clears the raw price after an economy-tier ~$25 fee, so a near-miss still comes out ahead. Centering is the usual reason a clean copy misses the 10 — measure it before you submit.
- Raw (NM)
- $2.99
- PSA 10
- $370
- PSA 9
- $41.90
- Gem premium
- 124×
- As of
- Jul 11, 2026
Break-even by outcome and fee
| If it comes back… | Sells for | Economy / bulk (~$25.00) | Standard (~$50.00) | Express (~$150) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gem — PSA 10 | $370 | +$342 | +$317 | +$217 |
| PSA 9 | $41.90 | +$13.91 | −$11.09 | −$111 |
| PSA 8 | $5.50 | −$22.49 | −$47.49 | −$147 |
Net = sale price − $2.99 raw value − fee. Fee tiers are illustrative; plug your grader's current price into the calculator below.
Expected value — how often does it need to gem?
| Chance it gems | Expected sale | Expected net (standard fee) |
|---|---|---|
| 25% | $124 | +$70.94 |
| 50% | $206 | +$153 |
| 75% | $288 | +$235 |
Break-even gem rate at the standard fee: about 3%. Centering is the usual reason a clean copy misses — measure it before you decide.
Which grader pays the most — and what a 10 takes
All centering standards →| Grader | 10 sells for | vs best | Front centering for a 10 | Back |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BGS 10 | $481 | best | 55/45 | 70/30 |
| PSA 10 | $370 | −$111 | 55/45 | 75/25 |
| CGC 10 | $222 | −$259 | 55/45 | 75/25 |
| SGC 10 | $222 | −$259 | 55/45 | 75/25 |
Tolerances are each company's published centering standard for its top grade; surface, corners and edges must also be clean. Centering is the one you can measure yourself before you pay.
Full grade ladder
Raw conditions & history →| Grade | PSA | CGC | BGS | SGC | Graded |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | $370 | $222 | $481 | $222 | — |
| 9.5 | — | — | — | — | $66.18 |
| 9 | — | — | — | — | $41.90 |
| 8 | — | — | — | — | $5.50 |
| 7 | — | — | — | — | $5.50 |
Run your own numbers
Should I pay this?
Enter the seller’s asking price to see your net outcome per grade.
Other 1986 Fleer All Stars cards worth checking
Full set checklist →
Grading Don Mattingly #1 — FAQ
Is Don Mattingly #1 worth grading?
A PSA 10 Don Mattingly #1 sells for $370 against $2.99 raw: a $367 spread, 124× the ungraded price. Even a PSA 9 ($41.90) clears the raw price after an economy-tier ~$25 fee, so a near-miss still comes out ahead. Centering is the usual reason a clean copy misses the 10 — measure it before you submit.
How much is a PSA 10 Don Mattingly #1 worth compared with raw?
A PSA 10 Don Mattingly #1 (Baseball Cards 1986 Fleer All Stars) sells for about $370 versus $2.99 for a raw near-mint copy — a 124× premium as of Jul 11, 2026.
Which grading company is best for Don Mattingly #1?
By resale value, BGS 10 leads at $481, ahead of PSA 10 at $370. Fees and turnaround differ, so the best-paying label is not always the best net.
What centering does Don Mattingly #1 need for a BGS 10?
BGS publishes 55/45 front and 70/30 back centering as the tolerance for a 10 (Gem Mint). Off-center copies are capped below the top grade regardless of surface — measure yours before paying the fee.
What gem rate makes grading Don Mattingly #1 break even?
At a standard ~$50 fee, submitting Don Mattingly #1 breaks even when it gems about 3% of the time (a miss assumed to sell at the PSA 9 price of $41.90).
Is your baseball card centered well enough to grade?
Centering makes or breaks a PSA 10. Scan any card with Midpoint to measure its exact centering, get a grade estimate, and see what your copy is actually worth.
Check my card free