Wrestling sets by year

1991 Wrestling Cards — Sets, Checklists & Prices

WrestlingAll years2 sets13 cards13 priced

Midpoint's price guide covers 2 Wrestling sets from 1991, with 13 cards (13 priced). The most valuable 1991 Wrestling set is 1991 Classic WWF, whose PSA 10 copies total $2.2K. The single most valuable 1991 wrestling card is Undertaker #64 (1991 Classic WWF) at $906 in PSA 10.

Sets: 2
Cards: 13
With prices: 13
PSA 10 total: $2.5K
Raw total: $118

Sets released in 1991

1991 Classic WWF
Classic WWF · 8 cards · 8 priced
Undertaker #64
$906 PSA 10
1991 Merlin WWF
Merlin WWF · 5 cards · 5 priced
Macho Man Randy Savage, Miss Elizabeth [Italian] #8
$175 PSA 10

Most valuable 1991 Wrestling cards

The 13 highest-value wrestling cards from 1991 sets, ranked by PSA 10 price (best graded or raw where no PSA 10 sale exists).

Undertaker #64

1991 Classic WWF

Raw $19.99PSA 10 $906

Macho Man Randy Savage, Miss Elizabeth [Italian] #8

Macho Man Randy Savage [German] #115

1991 Merlin WWF

Raw $12.83PSA 10 $143

Raw $1.42PSA 10 $76.05

Andre the Giant [Italian] #35

1991 Merlin WWF

Raw $12.53Graded $68.00

Macho Man Randy Savage #18

1991 Merlin WWF

Raw $40.00

Macho Man Randy Savage, Miss Elizabeth #17

1991 Merlin WWF

Raw $6.02

Frequently asked questions

What is the most valuable 1991 Wrestling card?: The single most valuable 1991 wrestling card is Undertaker #64 (1991 Classic WWF) at $906 in PSA 10.
Which 1991 Wrestling set is worth the most?: The most valuable 1991 Wrestling set is 1991 Classic WWF, whose PSA 10 copies total $2.2K. Its top card is Undertaker #64.
How many 1991 Wrestling sets are in the price guide?: Midpoint's price guide covers 2 Wrestling sets from 1991, with 13 cards (13 priced).

Is your wrestling card centered well enough to grade?

Centering makes or breaks a PSA 10. Scan any card with Midpoint to measure its exact centering, get a grade estimate, and see what your copy is actually worth.

Check my card free