Football set
1958 Topps Checklist & Card Prices
Football1958118 cards118 pricedTopps
1958 Topps (Football) has 118 cards in our price guide, 118 of them with live market values. The most valuable is Jim Brown #62 at $153,619 in PSA 10 ($550 raw). Across the set, PSA 10 copies total $348K and raw copies $1.1K.
- Cards
- 118
- With prices
- 118
- PSA 10 total
- $348K
- Raw total
- $1.1K
- Top card
- $153,619
Most valuable cards
The 12 highest-value cards in 1958 Topps, ranked by PSA 10 price (best graded or raw where no PSA 10 sale exists).
12
3
4
5
6
78
9
101112
Jim Brown #62
Raw $550PSA 10 $153,6190% 30d
Bart Starr #66
Raw $45.04PSA 10 $25,2000% 30d
George Blanda #129
Raw $10.23Graded $15,1800% 30d
Raymond Berry #120
Raw $10.05PSA 10 $14,4000% 30d
Sonny Jurgensen #90
Raw $42.00PSA 10 $8,4300% 30d
Frank Gifford #73
Raw $13.25PSA 10 $7,2000% 30d
Milt Plum #5
Raw $4.68Graded $6,6160% 30d
John Unitas #22
Raw $29.49PSA 10 $6,1220% 30d
Johnny Carson #47
Raw $3.95PSA 10 $5,6160% 30d
Yale Lary #18
Raw $4.11PSA 10 $5,4720% 30d
John Olszewski #107
Raw $1.75Graded $4,9680% 30d
Gary Knafelc #56
Raw $2.64PSA 10 $4,8000% 30d
Best cards to grade
Dick Nolan #131 shows the biggest jump in 1958 Topps: $1.76 raw to $4,464 in PSA 10, a 2536× premium. Ranked by PSA 10 price ÷ raw price; only cards with a PSA 10 value of $20 or more are shown.
- 12536×Dick Nolan #131$1.76 raw → $4,464 PSA 10
- 2
1984×Larry Morris #50$2.25 raw → $4,464 PSA 10 - 31818×Gary Knafelc #56$2.64 raw → $4,800 PSA 10
- 41433×Raymond Berry #120$10.05 raw → $14,400 PSA 10
- 51422×Johnny Carson #47$3.95 raw → $5,616 PSA 10
- 61331×Yale Lary #18$4.11 raw → $5,472 PSA 10
- 7
1223×Alan Ameche #12$3.18 raw → $3,888 PSA 10 - 8
1217×Ray Renfro #17$3.43 raw → $4,176 PSA 10
Full checklist
All 118 cards we track from 1958 Topps, with the latest raw and graded market values. Tap any card for its full price history.
| Card | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | CGC 10 | BGS 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Al Carmichael #31Al Carmichael | $5.61 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Alan Ameche #12Alan Ameche | $3.18 | $3,240 | $3,888 | $2,333 | — | 0% |
| Andy Robustelli #15Andy Robustelli | $3.74 | $118 | $750 | $450 | $975 | 0% |
| Art Donovan #106Art Donovan | $6.01 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Babe Parilli #118Babe Parilli | $6.51 | $172 | $1,110 | $666 | $1,443 | 0% |
| Baltimore Colts #110Baltimore Colts | $4.87 | $167 | $1,073 | $644 | $1,396 | 0% |
| Bart Starr #66Bart Starr | $45.04 | $21,000 | $25,200 | $15,120 | $32,760 | 0% |
| Bert Rechichar #74Bert Rechichar | $2.25 | $1,440 | $1,728 | $1,037 | $2,246 | 0% |
| Bill Barnes #4Bill Barnes | $3.00 | $2,040 | $2,448 | $1,469 | $3,182 | 0% |
| Bill George #119Bill George | $5.75 | $165 | $1,066 | $639 | $1,385 | 0% |
| Bill Wade #38Bill Wade | $4.77 | $169 | $1,087 | $652 | $1,414 | 0% |
| Billy Howton #6Billy Howton | $3.80 | $243 | $718 | $431 | $934 | 0% |
| Billy Wilson #95Billy Wilson | $2.17 | $70.21 | $431 | $259 | $561 | 0% |
| Bob Boyd #21Bob Boyd | $1.93 | $630 | $756 | $454 | $983 | 0% |
| Bobby Dillon #32Bobby Dillon | $3.25 | $117 | $630 | $378 | $819 | 0% |
| Bobby Layne #2Bobby Layne | $9.90 | $2,562 | $3,074 | $1,844 | $3,996 | 0% |
| Bobby Walston #87Bobby Walston | $1.77 | $600 | $720 | $432 | $936 | 0% |
| Carl Brettschnieder #28Carl Brettschnieder | $2.63 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Charley Conerly #84Charley Conerly | $4.10 | $930 | $1,116 | $670 | $1,451 | 0% |
| Chet Hanulak #45Chet Hanulak | $2.26 | $102 | $454 | $272 | $590 | 0% |
| Chicago Bears #29Chicago Bears | $4.67 | $172 | $1,111 | $667 | $1,445 | 0% |
| Chicago Cardinals #69Chicago Cardinals | $3.07 | $363 | $652 | $391 | $848 | 0% |
| Chuck Bednarik #35Chuck Bednarik | $9.25 | $288 | $1,886 | $1,131 | $2,451 | 0% |
| Cleveland Browns #9Cleveland Browns | $7.50 | $1,924 | $2,309 | $1,385 | $3,002 | 0% |
| Dale Dodrill #46Dale Dodrill | $2.87 | $1,950 | $2,340 | $1,404 | $3,042 | 0% |
| Detroit Lions #115Detroit Lions | $2.30 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Dick Bielski #111Dick Bielski | $1.90 | $160 | $482 | $289 | $626 | 0% |
| Dick Deschaine #48Dick Deschaine | $3.66 | $900 | $1,080 | $648 | $1,404 | 0% |
| Dick Moegle #124Dick Moegle | $2.24 | $900 | $1,080 | $648 | $1,404 | 0% |
| Dick Nolan #131Dick Nolan | $1.76 | $3,720 | $4,464 | $2,678 | — | 0% |
| Dick Stanfel #39Dick Stanfel | $4.06 | $195 | $831 | $498 | $1,080 | 0% |
| Don Bosseler #132Don Bosseler | $4.00 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Don Chandler #54Don Chandler | $2.64 | $1,500 | $1,800 | $1,080 | $2,340 | 0% |
| Don Heinrich #83Don Heinrich | $3.04 | $102 | $640 | $384 | $832 | 0% |
| Don McIlhenny #71Don McIlhenny | $3.68 | $125 | $794 | $477 | $1,033 | 0% |
| Don Paul #91Don Paul | $2.58 | $120 | $636 | $382 | $827 | 0% |
| Duane Putnam #55Duane Putnam | $3.13 | $133 | $851 | $510 | $1,106 | 0% |
| Earl Morrall #57Earl Morrall | $4.28 | $138 | $883 | $530 | $1,148 | 0% |
| Ed Brown #123Ed Brown | $5.08 | $185 | $1,196 | $718 | $1,555 | 0% |
| Eddie LeBaron #112Eddie LeBaron | $5.48 | $481 | $1,073 | $644 | $1,395 | 0% |
| Emlen Tunnell #42Emlen Tunnell | $5.93 | $206 | $1,334 | $801 | $1,735 | 0% |
| Felt Initial Card | $18.50 | $567 | $3,743 | $2,246 | $4,866 | 0% |
| Frank Gifford #73Frank Gifford | $13.25 | $6,000 | $7,200 | $4,320 | $9,360 | 0% |
| Frank Varrichione #77Frank Varrichione | $2.46 | $256 | $540 | $324 | $701 | 0% |
| Gary Knafelc #56Gary Knafelc | $2.64 | $4,000 | $4,800 | $2,880 | — | 0% |
| Gene Brito #113Gene Brito | $2.65 | $89.77 | $562 | $337 | $730 | 0% |
| George Blanda #129George Blanda | $10.23 | $13,800 | — | $9,936 | — | 0% |
| George Tarasovic #37George Tarasovic | $3.97 | $60.00 | $804 | $483 | $1,046 | 0% |
| Gern Nagler #60Gern Nagler | $2.15 | $92.81 | $582 | $349 | $757 | 0% |
| Gino Marchetti #16Gino Marchetti | $4.30 | $202 | $929 | $557 | $1,208 | 0% |
| Gordon Soltau #130Gordon Soltau | $3.07 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Harlon Hill #80Harlon Hill | $2.96 | $136 | $602 | $361 | $782 | 0% |
| Howard Cassady #7Howard Cassady | $3.28 | $230 | $550 | $330 | $715 | 0% |
| Hugh McElhenny #122Hugh McElhenny | $3.61 | $900 | $1,080 | $648 | $1,404 | 0% |
| Jack Butler #76Jack Butler | $3.43 | $114 | $724 | $434 | $941 | 0% |
| Jack Christiansen #70Jack Christiansen | $2.63 | $4,225 | — | $3,042 | — | 0% |
| Jack McClairen #51Jack McClairen | $3.68 | $1,035 | $1,242 | $745 | $1,615 | 0% |
| James Dooley #8James Dooley | $2.24 | $131 | $471 | $283 | $613 | 0% |
| Jerry Norton #40Jerry Norton | $2.25 | $1,020 | $1,224 | $734 | $1,591 | 0% |
| Jim Brown #62Jim Brown | $550 | $23,052 | $153,619 | $92,172 | $199,705 | 0% |
| Jim David #13Jim David | $3.01 | $147 | $941 | $565 | $1,224 | 0% |
| Jim Doran #43Jim Doran | $2.83 | $2,520 | $3,024 | $1,814 | $3,931 | 0% |
| Jim Mutscheller #14Jim Mutscheller | $1.97 | $63.30 | $385 | $231 | $501 | 0% |
| Jim Podoley #121Jim Podoley | $1.87 | $104 | $472 | $283 | $613 | 0% |
| Jim Ringo #103Jim Ringo | $4.50 | $1,560 | $1,872 | $1,123 | $2,434 | 0% |
| Jimmy Carr #65Jimmy Carr | $2.92 | $100 | $632 | $379 | $822 | 0% |
| Joe Marconi #63Joe Marconi | $2.54 | $108 | $682 | $409 | $887 | 0% |
| Joe Perry #93Joe Perry | $4.05 | $1,260 | $1,354 | $812 | $1,760 | 0% |
| Joe Schmidt #3Joe Schmidt | $4.64 | $136 | $869 | $521 | $1,130 | 0% |
| John Carson #47John Carson | $2.34 | $1,110 | — | — | — | 0% |
| John Henry Johnson #75John Henry Johnson | $3.01 | $344 | $634 | $380 | $824 | 0% |
| John Olszewski #107John Olszewski | $1.75 | — | — | $4,968 | — | 0% |
| John Unitas #22John Unitas | $29.49 | $2,092 | $6,122 | $3,673 | $7,959 | 0% |
| Johnny Carson #47Johnny Carson | $3.95 | $4,680 | $5,616 | $3,370 | — | 0% |
| Jon Arnett #20Jon Arnett | $3.25 | $2,340 | $2,808 | $1,685 | $3,650 | 0% |
| Ken Keller #108Ken Keller | $2.12 | $77.75 | $482 | $289 | $626 | 0% |
| Kenny Konz #26Kenny Konz | $4.61 | $149 | $957 | $574 | $1,244 | 0% |
| L.G. Dupre #117L.G. Dupre | $2.40 | $1,900 | $2,280 | $1,368 | $2,964 | 0% |
| Lamar McHan #68Lamar McHan | $4.97 | $3,000 | $3,600 | $2,160 | $4,680 | 0% |
| Larry Morris #50Larry Morris | $2.25 | $3,720 | $4,464 | $2,678 | — | 0% |
| Lenny Moore #10Lenny Moore | $5.26 | $280 | $1,372 | $823 | $1,784 | 0% |
| Leo Elter #25Leo Elter | $2.04 | $416 | $499 | $299 | $649 | 0% |
| Leo Nomellini #89Leo Nomellini | $3.81 | $124 | $792 | $475 | $1,030 | 0% |
| Les Richter #105Les Richter | $3.48 | $106 | $668 | $401 | $868 | 0% |
| Los Angeles Rams #85Los Angeles Rams | $4.25 | $870 | $1,354 | $812 | $1,760 | 0% |
| Lou Creekmur #81Lou Creekmur | $3.10 | $780 | $936 | $562 | $1,217 | 0% |
| Lou Groza #52Lou Groza | $5.78 | $194 | $1,260 | $756 | $1,638 | 0% |
| Matt Hazeltine #100Matt Hazeltine | $2.99 | $108 | $517 | $310 | $673 | 0% |
| Mike McCormack #59Mike McCormack | $5.20 | $166 | $1,071 | $643 | $1,393 | 0% |
| Milt Plum #5Milt Plum | $4.68 | — | — | $6,616 | — | 0% |
| Ollie Matson #127Ollie Matson | $5.18 | $160 | $1,033 | $620 | $1,343 | 0% |
| Pete Brewster #11Pete Brewster | $2.00 | $81.00 | $431 | $259 | $561 | 0% |
| Philadelphia Eagles #109Philadelphia Eagles | $2.69 | $173 | $606 | $364 | $788 | 0% |
| Pittsburgh Steelers #116Pittsburgh Steelers | $3.16 | $552 | $664 | $398 | $863 | 0% |
| Preston Carpenter #128Preston Carpenter | $2.09 | $4,680 | — | $3,370 | — | 0% |
| R.C. Owens [Error Photo Is Don Owens] #64R.C. Owens | $1.99 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Ray Mathews #78Ray Mathews | $3.04 | $1,740 | $2,088 | $1,253 | $2,714 | 0% |
| Ray Renfro #17Ray Renfro | $3.43 | $3,480 | $4,176 | $2,506 | — | 0% |
| Raymond Berry #120Raymond Berry | $10.05 | $12,000 | $14,400 | $8,640 | — | 0% |
| Rick Casares #53Rick Casares | $2.52 | $184 | $540 | $324 | $702 | 0% |
| Ron Kramer #58Ron Kramer | $6.08 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Ron Waller #72Ron Waller | $3.01 | — | — | $3,629 | — | 0% |
| Roosevelt Brown #102Roosevelt Brown | $4.14 | $276 | $947 | $568 | $1,231 | 0% |
| Sam Baker #34Sam Baker | $2.36 | $810 | $972 | $583 | $1,264 | 0% |
| San Francisco 49ers #41San Francisco 49ers | $3.15 | $252 | $831 | $498 | $1,080 | 0% |
| Sonny Jurgensen #90Sonny Jurgensen | $42.00 | $4,342 | $8,430 | $5,058 | $10,958 | 0% |
| Steve Meilinger #33Steve Meilinger | $3.25 | $840 | $1,008 | $605 | $1,310 | 0% |
| Ted Marchibroda #44Ted Marchibroda | $4.09 | $358 | $879 | $527 | $1,143 | 0% |
| Tobin Rote #94Tobin Rote | $3.70 | $120 | $684 | $410 | $889 | 0% |
| Tom Scott #125Tom Scott | $2.30 | $470 | $482 | $289 | $626 | 0% |
| Tom Wilson #67Tom Wilson | $2.47 | $160 | $532 | $319 | $691 | 0% |
| Vic Zucco #36Vic Zucco | $3.69 | $108 | $682 | $409 | $887 | 0% |
| Washington Redskins #27Washington Redskins | $3.20 | $660 | $792 | $475 | $1,030 | 0% |
| Willie Galimore #114Willie Galimore | $3.84 | $515 | $710 | $426 | $923 | 0% |
| Woodley Lewis [Misspelled Woodly Front] #82Woodley Lewis | $0.99 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Y.A. Tittle #86Y.A. Tittle | $6.36 | $3,773 | $4,528 | $2,717 | $5,886 | 0% |
| Yale Lary #18Yale Lary | $4.11 | $4,560 | $5,472 | $3,283 | — | 0% |
| Zeke Bratkowski #23Zeke Bratkowski | $4.35 | $140 | $895 | $537 | $1,163 | 0% |
Players in this set
All Football players →About this set
1958 Topps is a Football set from 1958. Midpoint tracks 118 cards from it, 118 with market prices from recent sales and 102 with a PSA 10 value. The set's most valuable card is Jim Brown #62 at $153,619 in PSA 10 ($550 raw). Priced raw copies add up to $1.1K, and PSA 10 copies to $348K.
Frequently asked questions
- How many cards are in 1958 Topps?
- Our Football price guide lists 118 cards for 1958 Topps, 118 of them with live market prices.
- What is the most valuable card in 1958 Topps?
- The most valuable card in 1958 Topps is Jim Brown #62 at $153,619 in PSA 10 ($550 raw).
- Is Jim Brown #62 worth grading?
- A PSA 10 Jim Brown #62 sells for $153,619 vs $550 raw — a 279× premium. That gap is what makes grading a well-centered, clean copy worthwhile.
- When was 1958 Topps released?
- 1958 Topps was released in 1958.
More Football sets from 1958
All 1958 sets →
Best on iPhone & Android
Check your football card in the Midpoint app
Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.
