Football set
1957 Topps Checklist & Card Prices
Football1957136 cards134 pricedTopps
1957 Topps (Football) has 136 cards in our price guide, 134 of them with live market values. The most valuable is Bart Starr #119 at $124,797 in PSA 10 ($600 raw). Across the set, PSA 10 copies total $501K and raw copies $2.4K.
- Cards
- 136
- With prices
- 134
- PSA 10 total
- $501K
- Raw total
- $2.4K
- Top card
- $124,797
Most valuable cards
The 12 highest-value cards in 1957 Topps, ranked by PSA 10 price (best graded or raw where no PSA 10 sale exists).
12
3
45
6
7
89
10
11
12
Bart Starr #119
Raw $600PSA 10 $124,797-33% 30d
John Unitas #138
Raw $362PSA 10 $82,9290% 30d
Paul Hornung #151
Raw $348PSA 10 $72,6850% 30d
Raymond Berry #94
Raw $92.83PSA 10 $18,6700% 30d
Dick Lane #85
Raw $42.65PSA 10 $8,5700% 30d
Lenny Moore #128
Raw $27.50PSA 10 $8,1000% 30d
Tank Younger #152
Raw $8.10PSA 10 $4,9930% 30d
Ed Modzelewski #127
Raw $3.35PSA 10 $4,9200% 30d
Earl Morrall #104
Raw $21.74PSA 10 $4,5370% 30d
Norm Van Brocklin #22
Raw $19.66PSA 10 $4,0850% 30d
Frank Gifford #88
Raw $16.65PSA 10 $3,9990% 30d
Hugh McElhenny #95
Raw $18.91PSA 10 $3,9490% 30d
Best cards to grade
Ed Modzelewski #127 shows the biggest jump in 1957 Topps: $3.35 raw to $4,920 in PSA 10, a 1469× premium. Ranked by PSA 10 price ÷ raw price; only cards with a PSA 10 value of $20 or more are shown.
- 11469×Ed Modzelewski #127$3.35 raw → $4,920 PSA 10
- 2
643×Zeke Bratkowski #140$3.40 raw → $2,186 PSA 10 - 3616×Tank Younger #152$8.10 raw → $4,993 PSA 10
- 4
600×Clarence Peaks #37$3.42 raw → $2,052 PSA 10 - 5
577×Ollie Matson #26$5.94 raw → $3,427 PSA 10 - 6
425×Joe Perry #129$8.62 raw → $3,661 PSA 10 - 7
393×Les Richter #10$3.45 raw → $1,355 PSA 10 - 8382×Sam Baker #72$2.78 raw → $1,063 PSA 10
Full checklist
All 136 cards we track from 1957 Topps, with the latest raw and graded market values. Tap any card for its full price history.
| Card | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | CGC 10 | BGS 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Al Carmichael #57Al Carmichael | $3.22 | $111 | $704 | $422 | $915 | 0% |
| Al Dorow #24Al Dorow | $3.45 | $134 | $857 | $514 | $1,114 | 0% |
| Alan Ameche #53Alan Ameche | $5.02 | $150 | $963 | $578 | $1,252 | 0% |
| Andy Robustelli #71Andy Robustelli | $3.78 | $124 | $793 | $476 | $1,031 | 0% |
| Art Donovan #65Art Donovan | $10.29 | $1,150 | $2,110 | $1,266 | $2,742 | 0% |
| Art Spinney #17Art Spinney | $3.29 | $544 | $718 | $431 | $934 | 0% |
| Bart Starr #119Bart Starr | $600 | $18,716 | $124,797 | $74,878 | $162,237 | -33% |
| Bert Rechichar #41Bert Rechichar | $3.50 | $425 | $793 | $476 | $1,031 | 0% |
| Bill Forester #69Bill Forester | $3.23 | $360 | $774 | $465 | $1,007 | 0% |
| Bill Howton #33Bill Howton | $4.25 | $560 | $706 | $423 | $918 | 0% |
| Bill McPeak #51Bill McPeak | $2.90 | $109 | $694 | $416 | $902 | 0% |
| Bill Sherman [Cor. Rams Team on Front] #58Bill Sherman | $9.00 | $292 | — | — | — | 0% |
| Bill Sherman [Err. No Team, Position] #58Bill Sherman | $110 | — | — | — | — | 0% |
| Bill Sherman [Err. No Team, W Position] #58Bill Sherman | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Bill Wade #34Bill Wade | $3.75 | $126 | $804 | $482 | $1,045 | 0% |
| Bill Wightkin #130Bill Wightkin | $9.33 | $283 | $1,853 | $1,112 | $2,409 | 0% |
| Billy Vessels #29Billy Vessels | $2.65 | $149 | $636 | $381 | $826 | 0% |
| Billy Wilson #42Billy Wilson | $3.25 | $299 | $673 | $404 | $875 | 0% |
| Bob Boyd #70Bob Boyd | $3.11 | $256 | $559 | $335 | $726 | 0% |
| Bob St. Clair #18Bob St. Clair | $5.50 | $1,406 | $1,479 | $888 | $1,923 | 0% |
| Bob Toneff #148Bob Toneff | $3.37 | $142 | $911 | $547 | $1,184 | 0% |
| Bobby Dillon #9Bobby Dillon | $6.11 | $121 | $1,282 | $769 | $1,667 | 0% |
| Bobby Layne #32Bobby Layne | $19.00 | $1,557 | $3,917 | $2,350 | $5,092 | 0% |
| Bobby Walston #61Bobby Walston | $2.54 | $106 | $671 | $402 | $872 | 0% |
| Buck Lansford #90Buck Lansford | $7.88 | $529 | $1,664 | $999 | $2,164 | 0% |
| Bud McFadin #108Bud McFadin | $10.79 | $788 | $2,327 | $1,396 | $3,025 | 0% |
| Carl Tasseff #77Carl Tasseff | $2.87 | $675 | $810 | $486 | $1,053 | 0% |
| Charley Conerly #109Charley Conerly | $13.04 | $402 | $2,330 | $1,398 | $3,029 | 0% |
| Charlie Ane #56Charlie Ane | $2.74 | $94.89 | $596 | $358 | $775 | 0% |
| Chuck Bednarik #49Chuck Bednarik | $16.02 | $1,236 | $3,245 | $1,947 | $4,218 | 0% |
| Chuck Drazenovich #60Chuck Drazenovich | $2.80 | $103 | $652 | $391 | $848 | 0% |
| Chuck Ulrich #136Chuck Ulrich | $4.68 | $662 | $1,085 | $651 | $1,410 | 0% |
| Clarence Peaks #37Clarence Peaks | $3.42 | $505 | $2,052 | $1,231 | $2,668 | 0% |
| Darrel Brewster #40Darrel Brewster | $3.72 | $126 | $805 | $483 | $1,047 | 0% |
| Dave Hanner #21Dave Hanner | $3.64 | $122 | $774 | $464 | $1,006 | 0% |
| Dave Mann #50Dave Mann | $2.33 | $99.84 | $629 | $378 | $818 | 0% |
| Dave Middleton #8Dave Middleton | $3.66 | $374 | $845 | $507 | $1,098 | 0% |
| Dick Bielski #13Dick Bielski | $3.53 | $114 | $721 | $432 | $937 | 0% |
| Dick James #134Dick James | $11.34 | $361 | $2,368 | $1,421 | $3,079 | 0% |
| Dick Lane #85Dick Lane | $42.65 | $2,229 | $8,570 | $5,142 | $11,141 | 0% |
| Dick Moegle #116Dick Moegle | $7.38 | $239 | $1,560 | $936 | $2,028 | 0% |
| Don Bingham #117Don Bingham | $8.49 | $626 | $1,789 | $1,074 | $2,326 | 0% |
| Don Chandler #23Don Chandler | $3.00 | $107 | $679 | $407 | $883 | 0% |
| Don Heinrich #47Don Heinrich | $4.06 | $122 | $777 | $466 | $1,010 | 0% |
| Don Paul #114Don Paul | $11.17 | $362 | $2,380 | $1,428 | $3,094 | 0% |
| Don Stonesifer #38Don Stonesifer | $2.31 | $80.25 | $499 | $299 | $648 | 0% |
| Dorne Dibble #97Dorne Dibble | $5.69 | $209 | $1,357 | $814 | $1,764 | 0% |
| Duane Putnam #87Duane Putnam | $3.25 | $505 | $704 | $422 | $915 | 0% |
| Earl Morrall #104Earl Morrall | $21.74 | $2,939 | $4,537 | $2,722 | $5,897 | 0% |
| Ed Brown #43Ed Brown | $3.12 | $188 | $673 | $404 | $875 | 0% |
| Ed Modzelewski #127Ed Modzelewski | $3.35 | $4,100 | $4,920 | $2,952 | — | 0% |
| Eddie Bell #99Eddie Bell | $6.55 | $214 | $1,388 | $833 | $1,805 | 0% |
| Eddie LeBaron #1Eddie LeBaron | $6.18 | $775 | $1,444 | $866 | $1,877 | 0% |
| Elbie Nickel #101Elbie Nickel | $4.47 | $786 | $952 | $571 | $1,238 | 0% |
| Elroy Hirsch #46Elroy Hirsch | $11.31 | $361 | $2,371 | $1,422 | $3,082 | 0% |
| Emlen Tunnell #35Emlen Tunnell | $6.89 | $221 | $1,436 | $862 | $1,867 | 0% |
| Ernie Stautner #92Ernie Stautner | $6.59 | $545 | $1,399 | $839 | $1,819 | 0% |
| Fran Rogel #27Fran Rogel | $2.66 | $91.46 | $573 | $344 | $745 | 0% |
| Frank Gifford #88Frank Gifford | $16.65 | $1,527 | $3,999 | $2,400 | $5,199 | 0% |
| Fred Cone #107Fred Cone | $3.40 | $121 | $772 | $463 | $1,003 | 0% |
| Gary Knafelc #45Gary Knafelc | $2.92 | $101 | $635 | $381 | $826 | 0% |
| Gene Brito #48Gene Brito | $2.38 | $221 | $575 | $345 | $748 | 0% |
| George Blanda #31George Blanda | $16.41 | $180 | $3,275 | $1,965 | $4,257 | 0% |
| George Shaw #115George Shaw | $8.00 | $587 | $1,689 | $1,013 | $2,195 | 0% |
| George Tarasovic #39George Tarasovic | $3.25 | $111 | $704 | $422 | $915 | 0% |
| Gino Marchetti #5Gino Marchetti | $8.52 | $728 | $2,149 | $1,289 | $2,793 | 0% |
| Gordon Soltau #54Gordon Soltau | $2.25 | $79.91 | $496 | $298 | $645 | 0% |
| Harlon Hill #67Harlon Hill | $3.06 | $671 | $805 | $483 | $1,047 | 0% |
| Howard Cassady #80Howard Cassady | $10.38 | $779 | $2,035 | $1,221 | $2,645 | 0% |
| Howard Ferguson #132Howard Ferguson | $12.38 | $1,569 | $2,596 | $1,558 | $3,375 | 0% |
| Hugh McElhenny #95Hugh McElhenny | $18.91 | $598 | $3,949 | $2,369 | $5,133 | 0% |
| J.C. Caroline #79J.C. Caroline | $2.53 | $183 | $550 | $330 | $716 | 0% |
| J.C. Caroline, Leo Elter, Mike McCormack [Advertising Panel]J.C. Caroline, Leo Elter, Mike McCormack | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Jack Butler #15Jack Butler | $15.50 | $1,129 | $3,244 | $1,947 | $4,218 | 0% |
| Jack Christiansen #106Jack Christiansen | $8.47 | $144 | $923 | $554 | $1,200 | 0% |
| James Root #112James Root | $7.01 | $1,048 | $1,484 | $890 | $1,929 | 0% |
| Jim David #150Jim David | $11.01 | $1,211 | $2,622 | $1,573 | $3,409 | 0% |
| Jim Doran #131Jim Doran | $10.24 | $210 | $2,103 | $1,262 | $2,734 | 0% |
| Jim Mutscheller #103Jim Mutscheller | $3.25 | $418 | $704 | $422 | $915 | 0% |
| Jim Patton #83Jim Patton | $2.42 | $513 | $623 | $374 | $810 | 0% |
| Jimmy Harris #135Jimmy Harris | $8.63 | $278 | $1,820 | $1,092 | $2,365 | 0% |
| Joe Arenas #66Joe Arenas | $3.50 | $109 | $687 | $412 | $894 | 0% |
| Joe Childress #100Joe Childress | $3.01 | $674 | $809 | $485 | $1,052 | 0% |
| Joe Perry #129Joe Perry | $8.62 | $3,051 | $3,661 | $2,197 | $4,759 | 0% |
| Joe Scudero #98Joe Scudero | $3.25 | $182 | $704 | $422 | $915 | 0% |
| John Henry Johnson #16John Henry Johnson | $6.70 | $234 | $1,521 | $913 | $1,977 | 0% |
| John Martinkovic #142John Martinkovic | $12.25 | $754 | $2,498 | $1,499 | $3,247 | 0% |
| John Olszewski #62John Olszewski | $2.60 | $114 | $723 | $434 | $939 | 0% |
| John Unitas #138John Unitas | $362 | $12,440 | $82,929 | $49,758 | $107,808 | 0% |
| Johnny Carson #123Johnny Carson | $8.00 | $321 | $1,688 | $1,013 | $2,195 | 0% |
| Ken Keller #111Ken Keller | $3.00 | $103 | $652 | $391 | $848 | 0% |
| Kenny Konz #52Kenny Konz | $3.33 | $118 | $749 | $450 | $974 | 0% |
| Kyle Rote #59Kyle Rote | $2.98 | $88.01 | $550 | $330 | $715 | 0% |
| Larry Strickland #105Larry Strickland | $7.76 | $251 | $1,639 | $983 | $2,131 | 0% |
| Lenny Moore #128Lenny Moore | $27.50 | $6,750 | $8,100 | $4,860 | $10,530 | 0% |
| Leo Elter #36Leo Elter | $2.98 | $283 | $644 | $386 | $837 | 0% |
| Leo Nomellini #6Leo Nomellini | $9.50 | $726 | $1,339 | $803 | $1,740 | 0% |
| Leo Sanford #74Leo Sanford | $2.67 | $770 | $924 | $554 | $1,201 | 0% |
| Leon Hart #118Leon Hart | $6.68 | $411 | $1,587 | $952 | $2,063 | 0% |
| Les Richter #10Les Richter | $3.45 | $1,129 | $1,355 | $813 | $1,762 | 0% |
| Lindon Crow #91Lindon Crow | $2.85 | $126 | $639 | $384 | $831 | 0% |
| Lou Creekmur #20Lou Creekmur | $4.28 | $804 | $1,065 | $639 | $1,384 | 0% |
| Lou Groza #28Lou Groza | $7.52 | $225 | $1,461 | $876 | $1,899 | 0% |
| Lynn Chandnois #137Lynn Chandnois | $13.57 | $440 | $2,896 | $1,738 | $3,765 | 0% |
| Mike McCormack #3Mike McCormack | $4.25 | $132 | $843 | $506 | $1,096 | 0% |
| Norm Van Brocklin #22Norm Van Brocklin | $19.66 | $1,207 | $4,085 | $2,451 | $5,311 | 0% |
| Ollie Matson #26Ollie Matson | $5.94 | $2,856 | $3,427 | $2,056 | $4,455 | 0% |
| Pat Summerall #14Pat Summerall | $11.26 | $382 | $2,508 | $1,505 | $3,261 | 0% |
| Paul Hornung #151Paul Hornung | $348 | $25,601 | $72,685 | $43,611 | $94,491 | 0% |
| Paul Larson #146Paul Larson | $6.21 | $247 | $1,237 | $742 | $1,608 | 0% |
| Paul Miller #120Paul Miller | $2.38 | $312 | $609 | $365 | $791 | 0% |
| Pete Retzlaff #2Pete Retzlaff | $4.25 | $251 | $963 | $578 | $1,252 | 0% |
| Preston Carpenter #93Preston Carpenter | $4.00 | $134 | $860 | $516 | $1,117 | 0% |
| Ray Krouse #141Ray Krouse | $7.74 | $316 | $1,436 | $861 | $1,866 | 0% |
| Ray Mathews #63Ray Mathews | $2.63 | $438 | $619 | $371 | $805 | 0% |
| Ray Renfro #76Ray Renfro | $3.01 | $823 | $988 | $593 | $1,284 | 0% |
| Ray Wietecha #122Ray Wietecha | $5.15 | $178 | $1,150 | $690 | $1,495 | 0% |
| Raymond Berry #94Raymond Berry | $92.83 | $5,100 | $18,670 | $11,202 | $24,272 | 0% |
| Rick Casares #55Rick Casares | $3.29 | $93.49 | $714 | $428 | $928 | 0% |
| Ron Waller #82Ron Waller | $2.63 | $97.00 | $610 | $366 | $793 | 0% |
| Roosevelt Brown #11Roosevelt Brown | $4.99 | $537 | $1,065 | $639 | $1,384 | 0% |
| Royce Womble #86Royce Womble | $3.25 | $289 | $652 | $391 | $848 | 0% |
| Sam Baker #72Sam Baker | $2.78 | $886 | $1,063 | $638 | $1,382 | 0% |
| Stan Jones #96Stan Jones | $12.47 | $399 | $2,623 | $1,574 | $3,410 | 0% |
| Steve Meilinger #89Steve Meilinger | $7.50 | $263 | $1,720 | $1,032 | $2,236 | 0% |
| Tank Younger #152Tank Younger | $8.10 | $4,161 | $4,993 | $2,996 | $6,491 | 0% |
| Ted Marchibroda #113Ted Marchibroda | $5.33 | $175 | $1,131 | $679 | $1,470 | 0% |
| Tobin Rote #81Tobin Rote | $3.84 | $128 | $816 | $489 | $1,060 | 0% |
| Tom Scott #25Tom Scott | $3.51 | $116 | $739 | $443 | $961 | 0% |
| Tom Wilson #133Tom Wilson | $8.00 | $728 | $1,792 | $1,075 | $2,330 | 0% |
| Tommy McDonald #124Tommy McDonald | $14.86 | $1,035 | $3,116 | $1,869 | $4,050 | 0% |
| Volney Peters #84Volney Peters | $2.40 | $314 | $492 | $295 | $640 | 0% |
| Walt Michaels #102Walt Michaels | $9.43 | $305 | $1,999 | $1,200 | $2,599 | 0% |
| Y.A. Tittle #30Y.A. Tittle | $11.98 | $382 | $2,514 | $1,508 | $3,268 | 0% |
| Yale Lary #68Yale Lary | $4.97 | $154 | $990 | $594 | $1,287 | 0% |
| Zeke Bratkowski #140Zeke Bratkowski | $3.40 | $1,822 | $2,186 | $1,312 | $2,842 | 0% |
Players in this set
All Football players →About this set
1957 Topps is a Football set from 1957. Midpoint tracks 136 cards from it, 134 with market prices from recent sales and 132 with a PSA 10 value. The set's most valuable card is Bart Starr #119 at $124,797 in PSA 10 ($600 raw). Priced raw copies add up to $2.4K, and PSA 10 copies to $501K.
Frequently asked questions
- How many cards are in 1957 Topps?
- Our Football price guide lists 136 cards for 1957 Topps, 134 of them with live market prices.
- What is the most valuable card in 1957 Topps?
- The most valuable card in 1957 Topps is Bart Starr #119 at $124,797 in PSA 10 ($600 raw).
- Is Bart Starr #119 worth grading?
- A PSA 10 Bart Starr #119 sells for $124,797 vs $600 raw — a 208× premium. That gap is what makes grading a well-centered, clean copy worthwhile.
- When was 1957 Topps released?
- 1957 Topps was released in 1957.
Best on iPhone & Android
Check your football card in the Midpoint app
Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.
