MidpointCard Centering Grading Portfolio App

Baseball sets by year

1958 Baseball Cards — Sets, Checklists & Prices

BaseballAll years5 sets440 cards416 priced

Midpoint's price guide covers 5 Baseball sets from 1958, with 440 cards (416 priced). The most valuable 1958 Baseball set is 1958 Topps, whose PSA 10 copies total $971K. The single most valuable 1958 baseball card is Mickey Mantle #150 (1958 Topps) at $90,492 in PSA 10.

Sets: 5
Cards: 440
With prices: 416
PSA 10 total: $971K
Raw total: $12K

Sets released in 1958

1958 Topps
Topps · 318 cards · 317 priced
Mickey Mantle #150
$90,492 PSA 10
1958 Hires Root Beer
Hires Root Beer · 84 cards · 82 priced
Don Newcombe [With Tab] #13
$45.99 raw
1958 San Francisco Call Bulletin Giants
San Francisco Call Bulletin Giants · 29 cards · 14 priced
1958 Bell Brand Dodgers
Bell Brand Dodgers · 3 cards · 3 priced
Junior Gilliam
$31.00 raw

…and 1 more small or unpriced set

1958 Topps Salesman Panel
Topps Salesman Panel · 6 cards

Most valuable 1958 Baseball cards

The 24 highest-value baseball cards from 1958 sets, ranked by PSA 10 price (best graded or raw where no PSA 10 sale exists).

Mickey Mantle #150 1958 Topps card

Mickey Mantle #150

Raw $460PSA 10 $90,4920% 30d

World Series Batting Foes #418 1958 Topps card

World Series Batting Foes #418

Raw $152PSA 10 $70,5600% 30d

Ted Williams #1 1958 Topps card

Ted Williams #1

Raw $113PSA 10 $55,9470% 30d

Hank Aaron [Yellow] #30 1958 Topps card

Hank Aaron [Yellow] #30

Raw $259PSA 10 $48,8970% 30d

Sandy Koufax #187 1958 Topps card

Sandy Koufax #187

Raw $82.90PSA 10 $44,4580% 30d

Bob Clemente [Yellow] #52 1958 Topps card

Bob Clemente [Yellow] #52

Raw $217PSA 10 $43,5720% 30d

Mickey Mantle: All Star #487 1958 Topps card

Mickey Mantle: All Star #487

Raw $166PSA 10 $32,3720% 30d

Bob Clemente [White] #52 1958 Topps card

Bob Clemente [White] #52

Raw $148PSA 10 $29,8110% 30d

Roger Maris #47 1958 Topps card

Roger Maris #47

Raw $142PSA 10 $28,0260% 30d

Hank Aaron [White] #30 1958 Topps card

Hank Aaron [White] #30

Raw $144PSA 10 $24,4340% 30d

Willie Mays #5 1958 Topps card

Raw $91.00PSA 10 $18,7430% 30d

Ted Williams [All Star] #485 1958 Topps card

Ted Williams [All Star] #485

Raw $80.63PSA 10 $17,472-7% 30d

Al Kaline [Yellow] #70 1958 Topps card

Al Kaline [Yellow] #70

Raw $84.21PSA 10 $16,0050% 30d

Willie Mays [All Star] #486 1958 Topps card

Willie Mays [All Star] #486

Raw $75.38PSA 10 $15,1330% 30d

Yogi Berra #370 1958 Topps card

Yogi Berra #370

Raw $70.88PSA 10 $13,4980% 30d

Pancho Herrera [Herrer] #433 1958 Topps card

Pancho Herrera [Herrer] #433

Raw $4,440Graded $13,2000% 30d

Ernie Banks #310 1958 Topps card

Ernie Banks #310

Raw $60.00PSA 10 $12,2790% 30d

Brooks Robinson #307 1958 Topps card

Brooks Robinson #307

Raw $59.65PSA 10 $10,9060% 30d

Orlando Cepeda #343 1958 Topps card

Orlando Cepeda #343

Raw $51.00PSA 10 $10,5660% 30d

Don Zimmer [Yellow] #77 1958 Topps card

Don Zimmer [Yellow] #77

Raw $47.63PSA 10 $9,5810% 30d

Don Drysdale #25 1958 Topps card

Don Drysdale #25

Raw $15.00PSA 10 $8,6400% 30d

Hank Aaron [All Star] #488 1958 Topps card

Hank Aaron [All Star] #488

Raw $42.45PSA 10 $8,610+6% 30d

Harmon Killebrew #288 1958 Topps card

Harmon Killebrew #288

Raw $39.45PSA 10 $7,5460% 30d

Frank Robinson #285 1958 Topps card

Frank Robinson #285

Raw $33.05PSA 10 $7,1100% 30d

Frequently asked questions

What is the most valuable 1958 Baseball card?: The single most valuable 1958 baseball card is Mickey Mantle #150 (1958 Topps) at $90,492 in PSA 10.
Which 1958 Baseball set is worth the most?: The most valuable 1958 Baseball set is 1958 Topps, whose PSA 10 copies total $971K. Its top card is Mickey Mantle #150.
How many 1958 Baseball sets are in the price guide?: Midpoint's price guide covers 5 Baseball sets from 1958, with 440 cards (416 priced).

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your baseball card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Or try it on the web →

Best on iPhone & Android

The full Midpoint experience is in the app

Scan with your camera, get AI grades with corner and edge close-ups, issue Grade Certificates, set price alerts, track your portfolio and talk to other collectors — everything here, plus the parts a browser can't do. Free to start.