MidpointCard Centering Grading Portfolio App
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18 card

The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

213 cards · 74 sets · 2022–2026

Midpoint tracks 213 The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes wrestling cards across 74 sets (2022–2026), 143 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #4 at $1,011 in PSA 10. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards
213
Sets
74
Priced
143
Top card (PSA 10)
$1,011
Raw total
$15K

Most valuable The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards

1
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #4
2023 Panini Prizm WWE Color Blast
Raw $726PSA 10 $1,011
2
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #5
2023 Panini Revolution WWE Kaboom
Raw $758PSA 10 $949
3
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18 2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown card
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18
2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown
Raw $137PSA 10 $863
4
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #19
2024 Panini Flawless WWE WrestleMania Autographs
Raw $858
5
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Emerald] #1
2024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures
Raw $810
6
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Refractor] #MOC-CR
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph
Raw $825PSA 10 $768
7
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red] #10
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania
Raw $750
8
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #CCA-TAN
2026 Topps Cosmic Chrome WWE Autograph
Raw $151PSA 10 $729
9
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Frozenfractor] #1
2025 Topps Chrome WWE
Raw $700
10
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Refractor] #MOC-CR
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph
Raw $633
11
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Orange Refractor] #MOC-CR
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph
Raw $563
12
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Ruby] #1
2024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures
Raw $546

Cards by year

Every tracked The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

202622 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #CCA-TAN2026 Topps Cosmic Chrome WWE Autograph$151$250$7290%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #SGZ-32026 Topps Chrome WWE Signalz$81.00$137$3950%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #GAM-62026 Topps Chrome WWE Gamut$36.40$66.79$1930%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink Refractor] #212026 Topps Chrome WWE$5.06$17.92$52.760%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Prism Refractor] #212026 Topps Chrome WWE$3.81$15.88$46.890%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Refractor] #SCO-12026 Topps Chrome WWE Scope$2.27$13.71$40.660%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Refractor] #ERA-92026 Topps Chrome WWE Eras Of Excellence$2.19$13.43$39.860%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #ERA-92026 Topps Chrome WWE Eras Of Excellence$1.99$13.19$39.160%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #SCO-12026 Topps Chrome WWE Scope$2.00$13.13$38.990%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #VIR-32026 Topps Chrome WWE Viral Shock$2.25$13.06$38.790%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Refractor] #VIR-32026 Topps Chrome WWE Viral Shock$1.77$12.77$37.940%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #422026 Topps Now$3.48——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Geometric Refractor] #VIR-32026 Topps Chrome WWE Viral Shock$1.51——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Stranger Things] #292026 Topps Now————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Refractor] #BBA-COD2026 Topps Chrome WWE Blue Brand Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Geometric Refractor] #BBA-COD2026 Topps Chrome WWE Blue Brand Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #MEA-CR2026 Topps Chrome WWE Main Event Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Orange Refractor] #VIR-32026 Topps Chrome WWE Viral Shock————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Orange Geometric Refractor] #VIR-32026 Topps Chrome WWE Viral Shock————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Superfractor] #VIR-32026 Topps Chrome WWE Viral Shock————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #BBA-COD2026 Topps Chrome Sapphire WWE Blue Brand Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #MWM-TAN2026 Topps Cosmic Chrome WWE Milky Way Marks————

202556 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Refractor] #MOC-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph$825—$7680%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania$750——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Frozenfractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$700——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Refractor] #MOC-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph$633——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Orange Refractor] #MOC-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph$563——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #MNA-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Mania$161$158$3800%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Orange] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania$300——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania$296——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue Refractor] #MOC-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph$185$220$2750%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Refractor] #MOC-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph$150$222$2700%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #MOC-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph$150$222$2530%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$217——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Laser] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania$200——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #HLX-COD2025 Topps Chrome WWE Helix$125$145$1920%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black] #22025 Topps WWE x BAPE Baby Milo$348—$1780%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$39.74$147$1720%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red White Blue Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$25.58$46.11$1500%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Image Variation] #2272025 Topps Chrome WWE$150——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Gold Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$110$131—0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black] #22025 Topps WWE x BAPE$140——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold Refractor] #SG-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Shifting Gears$19.62$37.77$99.700%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Refractor] #SG-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Shifting Gears$87.50——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$4.26$15.80$84.780%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue Geometric Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$13.18$30.50$75.000%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Aqua Shimmer Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$11.36$15.50$68.170%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Geometric Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$9.00$22.74$62.030%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$1.29$49.43$59.000%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink Shimmer Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$2.25$35.00$55.000%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Speckle Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$5.53$17.78$53.240%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Blue Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$5.37$17.61$49.160%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Yellow Refractor] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE x Cactus Jack$4.49$16.89$48.540%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Prism Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$4.99$23.37$47.750%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Purple Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$4.95$16.76$46.990%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [X-Fractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$3.42$17.50$42.140%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #102025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania$3.18$14.58$41.800%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #SG-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Shifting Gears$3.04$14.28$40.730%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #102025 Topps Chrome WWE x Cactus Jack$2.39$13.54$38.440%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Refractor] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE x Cactus Jack$1.92$12.85$37.640%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Checkerboard Refractor] #SSS-CR2025 Topps Finest WWE Showstoppers$4.08$11.87$35.070%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania$15.50——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Black Refractor] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE x Cactus Jack$14.13——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #862025 Topps Now WWE$3.82$4.29—0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Refractor] #SG-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Shifting Gears$4.98——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [White Refractor] #102025 Topps Chrome WWE x Cactus Jack$3.49——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Refractor] #FVF-242025 Topps Chrome WWE x Cactus Jack Festival Fury————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Ray Wave Refractor] #CJA-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Ray Wave Refractor] #CCA-252025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania Cactus Champions————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Geometric Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Superfractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Superfractor Image Variation] #2272025 Topps Chrome WWE————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Superfractor] #MOC-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Superfractor] #SG-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Shifting Gears————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #CJA-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black] #CJA-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #CCA-252025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black] #CCA-252025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack Autograph————

202485 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #182024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown$137$462$8630%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #192024 Panini Flawless WWE WrestleMania Autographs$858——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Emerald] #12024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures$810——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Ruby] #12024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures$546——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Tiger Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE——$4000%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #22024 Panini Select WWE Color Wheel$200$221$3110%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #242024 Panini Flawless WWE Royal Rumble Autographs$271——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Wave Red Prizm] #92024 Panini Select WWE Ringside Action Signatures—$148——
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #52024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Progressions$150——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #112024 Panini Three Count WWE Massive Mat Autograph$150——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes, #952024 Panini Instant WWE——$1490%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Ice Prizm] #92024 Panini Select WWE Ringside Action Signatures$125——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Purple] #112024 Panini Three Count WWE Massive Mat Autograph$99.99——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #92024 Panini Select WWE Ringside Action Signatures$111——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Diamond] #52024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Progressions$49.00—$96.990%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures$91.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures$76.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #42024 Panini Flawless WWE Jumbo Memorabilia$71.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #72024 Panini Three Count WWE$67.50——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #42024 Panini Flawless WWE Jumbo Memorabilia$64.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Prizm] #102024 Panini Select WWE Throwback$21.47——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue Prizm] #102024 Panini Select WWE Throwback$19.41$42.00—0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #102024 Panini Select WWE Throwback$4.39$16.10$44.910%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Green Flash Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE$3.10$14.22$40.300%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #152024 Panini Select WWE And NEW$2.99$14.15$40.110%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE$2.29$13.18$37.770%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver Prizm] #232024 Panini Select WWE Turbo Charged$2.00$12.78$36.770%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Blue Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE$1.70$12.36$35.760%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #242024 Panini Select WWE$1.62$12.25$34.990%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Tri-Color Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE$1.99$12.76$32.000%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Maze] #52024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Progressions$30.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue Prizm] #152024 Panini Select WWE And NEW$4.88$19.99—0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Ice Orange Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE$2.24$13.11$20.500%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #52024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Progressions$19.52——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #382024 Panini Instant WWE$12.99——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #312024 Panini Instant WWE$11.99——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #252024 Panini Instant WWE$10.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #612024 Panini Instant WWE————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver Prizm Die-Cut] #242024 Panini Select WWE$5.22——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #192024 Panini Instant WWE$5.14——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Blue Retail] #242024 Panini Select WWE$1.99——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Under Card] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Mojo] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Under Card Gold] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold Shimmer FOTL] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [White Sparkle] #102024 Panini Prizm WWE Throwback Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Fireworks] #52024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Progressions————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Platinum] #52024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Progressions————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Flash Prizm] #92024 Panini Select WWE Ringside Action Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold Vinyl Prizm] #102024 Panini Select WWE Throwback————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #112024 Panini Three Count WWE Massive Mat Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink FOTL] #112024 Panini Three Count WWE Massive Mat Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Green] #112024 Panini Three Count WWE Massive Mat Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Holo Gold FOTL] #112024 Panini Three Count WWE Massive Mat Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Platinum] #112024 Panini Three Count WWE Massive Mat Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #172024 Panini Three Count WWE Memorabilia Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #142024 Panini Three Count WWE Timeless Moments Autographs Vertical————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #142024 Panini National Treasures WWE Colossal Mat Materials————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #182024 Panini Flawless WWE Achievements————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #182024 Panini Flawless WWE Achievements————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Amethyst] #182024 Panini Flawless WWE Achievements————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Emerald] #182024 Panini Flawless WWE Achievements————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Platinum] #182024 Panini Flawless WWE Achievements————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #302024 Panini Flawless WWE Finishing Moves————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #82024 Panini Flawless WWE Performances————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #82024 Panini Flawless WWE Performances————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Amethyst] #82024 Panini Flawless WWE Performances————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Emerald] #82024 Panini Flawless WWE Performances————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Platinum] #82024 Panini Flawless WWE Performances————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #142024 Panini Flawless WWE Royal Rumble Autographs————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #252024 Panini Flawless WWE SummerSlam Autographs————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #SP-CRD2024 Panini Flawless WWE Signature Prime Materials————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #12024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #12024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Amethyst] #12024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Platinum] #12024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #162024 Panini Flawless WWE Memorabilia————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Platinum] #42024 Panini Flawless WWE Jumbo Memorabilia————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #42024 Panini Flawless WWE Smackdown Logo Gems————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #52024 Panini Flawless WWE Superstar Logo Gems————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #72024 Panini Flawless WWE Logo Gems————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #632024 Panini Instant WWE————

202346 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #42023 Panini Prizm WWE Color Blast$726$828$1,0110%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #52023 Panini Revolution WWE Kaboom$758$660$9490%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #SA-CRD2023 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autographs$69.05$115$3250%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #402023 Panini Impeccable WWE$266——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Gold Shimmer] #12023 Panini Prizm WWE$500$238—0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Galactic] #172023 Panini Revolution WWE$326$175$2550%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Blue Shimmer] #12023 Panini Prizm WWE$123$133—0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Zebra] #282023 Panini Select WWE$273$122—0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Galactic] #152023 Panini Revolution WWE Shock Wave$119——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #282023 Panini Immaculate WWE$19.76$36.56$91.530%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Black Blue] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$900—$67.250%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #122023 Panini Chronicles WWE Action Packed$6.75$19.04$50.810%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Silver] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$3.12$13.87$50.000%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #4002023 Panini Select WWE$6.59$18.18$46.390%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver Wave] #3852023 Panini Chronicles WWE$5.12$16.90$45.850%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Green] #12023 Panini Prizm WWE$3.80$19.50$39.480%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #3852023 Panini Chronicles WWE$2.00$12.68$36.180%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Astro] #172023 Panini Revolution WWE$2.26$12.81$35.650%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #282023 Panini Select WWE$2.12$12.64$35.300%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Fractal] #172023 Panini Revolution WWE$2.00$12.48$34.970%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Red Blue] #282023 Panini Select WWE$1.88$12.39$34.790%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #12023 Panini Prizm WWE$1.22$11.48$32.950%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver] #92023 Panini Prizm WWE Prizmatic Entrances$1.05$11.29$32.520%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Green] #152023 Donruss Elite WWE Star Status$1.79$12.35$29.000%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Orange Flash] #282023 Panini Select WWE$2.88$16.50$26.070%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Red Wave] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$0.99—$19.000%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Sunburst] #152023 Panini Revolution WWE Shock Wave$12.33——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Cubic] #152023 Panini Revolution WWE Star Gazing$10.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #122023 Panini Chronicles WWE Action Packed$10.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Under Card] #92023 Panini Prizm WWE Prizmatic Entrances$8.00——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver] #3852023 Panini Chronicles WWE$7.10——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Tri-Color] #282023 Panini Select WWE$4.39——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Red Wave] #282023 Panini Select WWE$4.00——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Red Blue] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$3.99——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Groove] #172023 Panini Revolution WWE$3.70——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #152023 Panini Revolution WWE Shock Wave$2.99——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #152023 Panini Revolution WWE Star Gazing$2.99——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Green] #92023 Panini Prizm WWE Prizmatic Entrances$2.58——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Orange Flash] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$4.98——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #152023 Donruss Elite WWE Star Status$2.25——0%
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #1292023 Panini Select WWE$1.68——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #PM-CRD2023 Panini Immaculate WWE Premium Memorabilia Autograph————
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Lava] #152023 Panini Revolution WWE Shock Wave————
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Galactic] #152023 Panini Revolution WWE Star Gazing————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #AG-CDR2023 Panini Revolution WWE Autograph————
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Green] #SA-CRD2023 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autographs————

20224 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold] #PA-CRD2022 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autographs$220——0%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #PA-CRD2022 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autographs$86.56$111$2040%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #2992022 Panini Select WWE$4.58$15.50$23.750%
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver] #422022 Panini Impeccable WWE$19.99——0%

Sets featuring The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes

All Wrestling sets →
2023 Panini Prizm WWE Color Blast (1)2023 Panini Revolution WWE Kaboom (1)2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown (1)2024 Panini Flawless WWE WrestleMania Autographs (1)2024 Panini Flawless WWE Star Swatch Signatures (6)2025 Topps Chrome WWE Marks of Champions Autograph (7)2025 Topps Chrome WWE Cactus Jack x WrestleMania (6)2026 Topps Cosmic Chrome WWE Autograph (1)2025 Topps Chrome WWE (20)2024 Panini Select WWE (9)2026 Topps Chrome WWE Signalz (1)2025 Topps Chrome WWE Mania (1)2023 Panini Prizm WWE Superstar Autographs (2)2024 Panini Select WWE Color Wheel (1)2024 Panini Flawless WWE Royal Rumble Autographs (2)2023 Panini Impeccable WWE (1)2023 Panini Prizm WWE (4)2023 Panini Revolution WWE (4)2022 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autographs (2)2026 Topps Chrome WWE Gamut (1)2025 Topps Chrome WWE Helix (1)2025 Topps WWE x BAPE Baby Milo (1)2024 Panini Select WWE Ringside Action Signatures (4)2024 Panini PhotoGenic WWE Progressions (6)

Best The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

  1. 1
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #1 2025 Topps Chrome WWE card
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #1
    2025 Topps Chrome WWE
    Raw $1.29PSA 10 $59.0046× premium
  2. 2
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Silver] #9
    2023 Panini Prizm WWE Prizmatic Entrances
    Raw $1.05PSA 10 $32.5231× premium
  3. 3
    The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #1
    2023 Panini Prizm WWE
    Raw $1.22PSA 10 $32.9527× premium
  4. 4
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink Shimmer Refractor] #1 2025 Topps Chrome WWE card
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink Shimmer Refractor] #1
    2025 Topps Chrome WWE
    Raw $2.25PSA 10 $55.0024× premium
  5. 5
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #24
    2024 Panini Select WWE
    Raw $1.62PSA 10 $34.9922× premium
  6. 6
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Refractor] #VIR-3
    2026 Topps Chrome WWE Viral Shock
    Raw $1.77PSA 10 $37.9421× premium

FAQ

How many The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards are there?
Midpoint tracks 213 The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes wrestling cards across 74 sets, released between 2022 and 2026. 143 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What is the most valuable The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes card?
The most valuable The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes card tracked by Midpoint is The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #4 from 2023 Panini Prizm WWE Color Blast, currently $1,011 in PSA 10 (raw $726).
What years are The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards from?
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards tracked by Midpoint run from 2022 to 2026; the earliest cards are from 2022.

Related

All Wrestling playersWrestling card pricesWrestling setsAll sports

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your wrestling card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Or try it on the web →

Best on iPhone & Android

The full Midpoint experience is in the app

Scan with your camera, get AI grades with corner and edge close-ups, issue Grade Certificates, set price alerts, track your portfolio and talk to other collectors — everything here, plus the parts a browser can't do. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play