Midpoint - Card Centering Tool
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18 card

The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

34 cards · 10 sets · 2022–2026

Midpoint tracks 34 The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes wrestling cards across 10 sets (2022–2026), 34 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18 at $861 in PSA 10. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards
34
Sets
10
Priced
34
Top card (PSA 10)
$861
Raw total
$3.5K

Most valuable The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards

1The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18 2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown card
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18
2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown
Raw $141PSA 10 $861
2
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Frozenfractor] #1
2025 Topps Chrome WWE
Raw $700
3The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #MNA-CR 2025 Topps Chrome WWE Mania card
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #MNA-CR
2025 Topps Chrome WWE Mania
Raw $154PSA 10 $380
4
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold Refractor] #1
2025 Topps Chrome WWE
Raw $39.07PSA 10 $303
5
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Gold Shimmer] #1
2023 Panini Prizm WWE
Raw $500Graded $261
6
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Refractor] #1
2025 Topps Chrome WWE
Raw $217
7
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #PA-CRD
2022 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autographs
Raw $86.56PSA 10 $209
8
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red White Blue Refractor] #1
2025 Topps Chrome WWE
Raw $22.53PSA 10 $150
9The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes, #95 2024 Panini Instant WWE card
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes, #95
2024 Panini Instant WWE
Raw —PSA 10 $149
10
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Blue Shimmer] #1
2023 Panini Prizm WWE
Raw $201Graded $146
11
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Gold Refractor] #1
2025 Topps Chrome WWE
Raw $110Graded $144
12The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Zebra] #28 2023 Panini Select WWE card
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Zebra] #28
2023 Panini Select WWE
Raw $274Graded $134

Cards by year

Every tracked The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

20261 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 10
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink Refractor] #212026 Topps Chrome WWE$6.00$20.15$59.59

202517 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 10
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Frozenfractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$700——
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #MNA-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Mania$154$163$380
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Gold Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$39.07$252$303
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$217——
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red White Blue Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$22.53$42.22$150
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Black Gold Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$110$131—
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$8.25$21.82$80.00
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Blue Geometric Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$12.85$30.50$75.00
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Aqua Shimmer Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$10.46$15.50$74.14
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$1.49$49.43$59.00
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Geometric Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$6.96$19.89$55.28
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink Shimmer Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$2.99$35.00$55.00
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Purple Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$4.06$19.53$54.36
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Speckle Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$11.50$26.47$52.71
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #SG-CR2025 Topps Chrome WWE Shifting Gears$3.52$15.71$44.60
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Prism Refractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$3.79$23.07$43.89
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [X-Fractor] #12025 Topps Chrome WWE$3.57$17.50$43.17

20246 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 10
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #182024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown$141$462$861
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes, #952024 Panini Instant WWE——$149
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Blue Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE$1.47$12.68$36.66
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Ice Orange Prizm] #242024 Panini Select WWE$2.87$14.06$20.50
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #192024 Panini Instant WWE$15.49——
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #382024 Panini Instant WWE$12.99——

20239 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 10
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Gold Shimmer] #12023 Panini Prizm WWE$500$238—
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Blue Shimmer] #12023 Panini Prizm WWE$201$133—
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Zebra] #282023 Panini Select WWE$274$122—
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Black Blue] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$900—$67.01
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Silver] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$3.12$13.92$50.00
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes #4002023 Panini Select WWE$6.61$18.33$47.07
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Red Blue] #282023 Panini Select WWE$1.38$11.73$33.56
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Orange Flash] #282023 Panini Select WWE$2.88$16.50$25.35
The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Red Wave] #1292023 Panini Select WWE$0.99—$19.00

20221 card

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 10
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #PA-CRD2022 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autographs$86.56$111$209

Sets featuring The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes

All Wrestling sets →
2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown (1)2025 Topps Chrome WWE (15)2025 Topps Chrome WWE Mania (1)2023 Panini Prizm WWE (2)2022 Panini Chronicles WWE Phoenix Autographs (1)2024 Panini Instant WWE (3)2023 Panini Select WWE (7)2026 Topps Chrome WWE (1)2025 Topps Chrome WWE Shifting Gears (1)2024 Panini Select WWE (2)

Best The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

  1. 1The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #1 2025 Topps Chrome WWE card
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #1
    2025 Topps Chrome WWE
    Raw $1.49PSA 10 $59.0040× premium
  2. 2
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Red Blue Prizm] #24
    2024 Panini Select WWE
    Raw $1.47PSA 10 $36.6625× premium
  3. 3
    The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Red Blue] #28
    2023 Panini Select WWE
    Raw $1.38PSA 10 $33.5624× premium
  4. 4
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Pink Shimmer Refractor] #1
    2025 Topps Chrome WWE
    Raw $2.99PSA 10 $55.0018× premium
  5. 5
    The American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes [Silver] #129
    2023 Panini Select WWE
    Raw $3.12PSA 10 $50.0016× premium
  6. 6
    The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes [Purple Refractor] #1
    2025 Topps Chrome WWE
    Raw $4.06PSA 10 $54.3613× premium

FAQ

How many The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards are there?
Midpoint tracks 34 The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes wrestling cards across 10 sets, released between 2022 and 2026. 34 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What is the most valuable The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes card?
The most valuable The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes card tracked by Midpoint is The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes #18 from 2024 Panini Three Count WWE Downtown, currently $861 in PSA 10 (raw $141).
What years are The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards from?
The American Nightmare Cody Rhodes cards tracked by Midpoint run from 2022 to 2026; the earliest cards are from 2022.

Related

All Wrestling playersWrestling card pricesWrestling setsAll sports

Is your wrestling card centered well enough to grade?

Centering makes or breaks a PSA 10. Scan any card with Midpoint to measure its exact centering, get a grade estimate, and see what your copy is actually worth.

Check my card free