| Matthew Schaefer [10] #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | $2,540 | $4,000 | $11,535 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Exclusives] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | $1,806 | $2,790 | $7,921 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Clear Cut] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | $1,042 | $904 | $7,748 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | $1,386 | $2,243 | $6,582 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | $1,427 | $2,251 | $6,398 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #DDM-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Draft Day Marks | $1,184 | $1,837 | $5,184 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Extended Rookie Blue Line Autograph] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $750 | $1,161 | $3,254 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Deluxe] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | $710 | $1,007 | $3,015 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Outburst Silver] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | $695 | $966 | $2,930 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #P-7 | 2025 SP Authentic Pageantry Autograph | $476 | $788 | $2,310 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #3D-MS | 2025 O-Pee-Chee 3-D Marquee Rookie | $334 | $524 | $1,475 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Autograph] #113 | 2025 SkyBox Metal Universe | $295 | $473 | $1,365 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Green] #5 | 2025 Upper Deck Star Rookies | $1,329 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Rainbow Foil Black] #592 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee | $250 | $395 | $1,113 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Retro Black Border] #592 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee | $235 | $373 | $1,052 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Puzzle Patch | $243 | $374 | $1,035 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #RTL-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Auto Rookie Team Logo Jumbo Patch Full Logo 1 | $214 | $334 | $924 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Extended Rookie Red Rainbow Autograph] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $591 | $825 | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold Glitter Bomb Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $200 | $202 | $891 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Yellow Green Spectrum Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $196 | $310 | $870 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Holiday] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | $187 | $332 | $855 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Green Quartz Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $199 | $315 | $850 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | $164 | $200 | $829 | 0% |
| Matthew Schaefer [Black White] #C-365 | 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series UD Canvas | $375 | $604 | $725 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue Purple Spectrum Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $700 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #P-32 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Portraits | $92.73 | $240 | $684 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Diamond Rainbow Foilboard] #P-92 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee Premier | $142 | $228 | $643 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | $126 | $213 | $607 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Black White Program of Excellence] #C-259 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Canvas | $124 | $202 | $576 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue Purple Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $127 | $205 | $576 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #R-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Exquisite Collection Rookie | $113 | $181 | $503 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Orange Yellow Spectrum Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $102 | $165 | $465 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #S-89 | 2025 SP Authentic Spectrum FX | $69.99 | $150 | $441 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #WF-9 | 2025 Flair Wave of the Future | $89.29 | $150 | $434 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [500] #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | $88.99 | $148 | $422 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Rainbow Foil] #592 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee | $87.79 | $199 | $410 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red Orange Spectrum Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $88.45 | $145 | $409 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #BDB-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond | $72.65 | $265 | $409 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Silver Collection Extended Rookie Copper Script] #275 | 2025 Upper Deck MVP | $95.59 | $151 | $405 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #SL-13 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Slaps | $398 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #P-32 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Portraits | $388 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #SL-13 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Slaps | $81.50 | $136 | $387 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #RG-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Gems | $71.21 | $132 | $365 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Silver Collection] #275 | 2025 Upper Deck MVP | $23.43 | $44.16 | $340 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Neon Yellow Surge] #268 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum | $62.59 | $113 | $328 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Glitter Bomb Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $69.58 | $89.99 | $328 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Authentics Jersey] #111 | 2025 SP | $65.00 | $111 | $316 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #E-149 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Encore | $66.54 | $112 | $313 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #HF-2 | 2025 SP Authentic Holofoil | $58.53 | $103 | $304 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Yellow Green Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $23.00 | $45.30 | $264 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Silver Collection Extended Rookie Silver Script] #275 | 2025 Upper Deck MVP | $12.90 | $47.56 | $251 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Black Rainbow Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $23.83 | $53.10 | $250 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Orange Slice Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $51.00 | $88.30 | $250 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | $11.84 | $45.51 | $223 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #P-92 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee Premier | $17.31 | $47.44 | $220 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [1000] #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | $42.00 | $75.21 | $215 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Retro] #592 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee | $22.68 | $90.00 | $215 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue Border] #592 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee | $41.12 | $73.44 | $209 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #592 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee | $9.26 | $38.01 | $205 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Clear Cut Acetate] #38 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors | $43.74 | $74.79 | $204 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Authentics] #111 | 2025 SP | $9.75 | $25.11 | $201 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Extended Rookie Red Orange] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $17.13 | $100 | $200 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Green Blue Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $81.26 | $135 | $200 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | $41.24 | $70.20 | $200 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #P-32 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Portraits | $1.69 | $31.47 | $198 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue Authentics] #111 | 2025 SP | $8.28 | $63.12 | $196 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Green] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | $17.99 | $37.91 | $195 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Patterned Foilboard Authentics] #111 | 2025 SP | $48.44 | $66.93 | $194 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Jumbo] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | $37.97 | $65.24 | $174 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Rainbow] #R-96 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Retro | $33.75 | $57.72 | $168 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red Authentics] #111 | 2025 SP | $150 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $7.25 | $31.55 | $144 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Jersey] #38 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors | $28.11 | $51.67 | $142 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue Line Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $142 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #R-96 | 2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Retro Red Autograph | $22.75 | $45.95 | $134 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red Rainbow Extended Rookie] #AR-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure | $21.79 | $39.33 | $127 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #OG-28 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 O-Pee-Chee Glossy | $3.40 | $19.33 | $122 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #121 | 2025 Upper Deck Credentials | $20.26 | $41.83 | $122 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | $14.46 | $24.50 | $107 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #NS-24 | 2025 Upper Deck Credentials Now Starring | $16.25 | $35.32 | $103 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #OG-28 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 O-Pee-Chee Glossy | $7.00 | $35.00 | $99.99 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Orange Yellow Extended Rookie] #CF-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Allure Color Flow | $17.84 | $33.55 | $95.97 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #HG-7 | 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series HoloGrFx Rookie | $13.97 | $31.80 | $93.58 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Speckle] #P-32 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Portraits | $3.78 | $40.00 | $90.15 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #P-7 | 2025 SP Authentic Pageantry | $10.65 | $27.96 | $82.68 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #211 | 2025 Parkhurst | $9.38 | $25.03 | $74.33 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #SG-24 | 2025 Upper Deck Credentials Sparks of Greatness | $7.44 | $22.43 | $65.87 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #113 | 2025 SkyBox Metal Universe | $3.59 | $52.27 | $63.00 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #OL-36 | 2025 SkyBox Metal Universe Outer Limits | $8.01 | $20.79 | $61.09 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Speckle] #SL-13 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Slaps | $6.45 | $19.50 | $56.98 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #20 | 2025 Fleer Ultra Team | $4.81 | $18.38 | $53.73 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [SP Signature] #38 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors | $52.89 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #PY-21 | 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Power Play | $3.70 | $16.02 | $47.52 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #SY-1 | 2025 Upper Deck Credentials Sensational Youth | $3.25 | $15.38 | $45.53 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #91 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors | $3.56 | $14.34 | $41.63 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red Foil] #91 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors | $2.85 | $14.22 | $41.30 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #SL-13 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Slaps | $2.25 | $35.00 | $39.89 | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #SB-14 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors Shine Bright | $23.24 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #NP-10 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors National Phenoms | $14.29 | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [SP Signature] #91 | 2025 Upper Deck Team Canada Juniors | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Rookie] #PW-MS | 2025 O-Pee-Chee Premier Jumbo | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Crystal] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Rainbow] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Purple] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Purple Autograph] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Rainbow Autograph] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue Autograph] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red Autograph Jersey] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Purple Autograph Patch] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Patch] #IRS-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Inked Rookie Sweaters | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red Jersey] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold Patch Red Jersey] #AR-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Authentic Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Patch] #RS-MS | 2025 SP Game Used Rookie Sweaters | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold Signature] #111 | 2025 SP | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Outburst Red] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Outburst Gold] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [High Gloss] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #RTD-13 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Rookie Die-Cut | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #RTD-13 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Rookie Die-Cut | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Orange] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Pink] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Black] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Printing Plate] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #E-149 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Encore | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue] #E-149 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Encore | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #E-149 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Encore | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #F-26 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #F-26 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue] #F-26 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Green] #F-26 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Magenta] #F-26 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Fluorescence | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [100] #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [50] #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [25] #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [1] #PC-37 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Population Count | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #RC-21 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Rookie Class Commemorations | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #RC-21 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Rookie Class Commemorations | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Program of Excellence] #C-259 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 UD Canvas | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #5 | 2025 Upper Deck Star Rookies | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #218 | 2025 Upper Deck Artifacts Rookie Redemption | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Purple] #DZ-57 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Dazzlers | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue] #121 | 2025 Upper Deck Credentials | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #SSR-MS | 2025 SPx Rookie SuperScripts | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Sunset] #R-MS | 2025 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Rookie Autograph | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series Acetate Young Guns | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #UD3-4 | 2025 Upper Deck Extended Series UD3 | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #SOTTR-SR | 2025 SP Authentic Sign of the Times Rookie | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #FI-6 | 2025 SP Authentic Future Icons | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #P-7 | 2025 SP Authentic Pageantry | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #S-89 | 2025 SP Authentic Spectrum FX | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Red] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Green] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Acetate] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Horizontal Autograph] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Inscribed Autograph] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Limited Auto Material Vertical Patch] #168 | 2025 SP Authentic | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Blue] #96 | 2025 Upper Deck Overtime | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Acetate] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Silver Foil] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Speckled Rainbow Foil] #451 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #CD-MS | 2025 Upper Deck Clear Cut Canvas Rookie Debut | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer [Gold] #109 | 2025 Upper Deck Premier | — | — | — | — |
| Matthew Schaefer #INC-5 | 2025 Upper Deck Series 2 Incarnations | — | — | — | — |