How many Tyrann Mathieu cards are there?

Midpoint tracks 81 Tyrann Mathieu football cards across 42 sets, released between 2013 and 2025. 66 of them have live raw or graded market values.

What is the most valuable Tyrann Mathieu card?

The most valuable Tyrann Mathieu card tracked by Midpoint is Tyrann Mathieu [Prizm] #296 from 2013 Panini Prizm, currently $1,686 in PSA 10 (raw $14.99).

What years are Tyrann Mathieu cards from?

Tyrann Mathieu cards tracked by Midpoint run from 2013 to 2025; the earliest cards are from 2013.

Tyrann Mathieu Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

81 cards · 42 sets · 2013–2025

Midpoint tracks 81 Tyrann Mathieu football cards across 42 sets (2013–2025), 66 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is Tyrann Mathieu [Prizm] #296 at $1,686 in PSA 10. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards: 81
Sets: 42
Priced: 66
Top card (PSA 10): $1,686
Raw total: $349

Most valuable Tyrann Mathieu cards

Tyrann Mathieu [Prizm] #296

2013 Panini Prizm

Raw $14.99PSA 10 $1,686

Tyrann Mathieu #11

2017 Panini Donruss Optic Aka

Raw $3.68PSA 10 $79.50

Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph] #396

2013 Panini Score

Raw $75.00

Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph Silver] #211

2022 Panini Prizm

Raw $20.28PSA 10 $70.64

Tyrann Mathieu [Signature] #96

2025 Panini Score

Raw $10.00PSA 10 $68.73

Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph Silver] #196

2013 Panini Momentum

Raw $14.83PSA 10 $66.00

Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph] #155

2013 Topps Strata

Raw $13.76PSA 10 $59.15

Tyrann Mathieu [Black White Checker] #218

2023 Panini Prizm

Raw $2.08PSA 10 $57.50

Tyrann Mathieu #21

2013 Panini Select Hot Rookies

Raw $1.25PSA 10 $57.22

Tyrann Mathieu [Neon Green Prizm] #194

2021 Panini Prizm No Huddle

Raw $45.00

Tyrann Mathieu [Red Sparkle] #218

2023 Panini Prizm

Raw $3.94PSA 10 $39.86

Tyrann Mathieu #96

2025 Panini Score

Raw $1.25PSA 10 $34.85

Cards by year

Every tracked Tyrann Mathieu card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

20257 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Signature] #96	2025 Panini Score	$10.00	$24.66	$68.73	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #96	2025 Panini Score	$1.25	$11.83	$34.85	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Bronze Pandora] #MMA-TMU	2025 Panini Phoenix Mythical Materials Autograph	—	—	—	—
Tyrann Mathieu [Nike Laundry Tag] #MMA-TMU	2025 Panini Phoenix Mythical Materials Autograph	—	—	—	—
Tyrann Mathieu [Brand Logo] #MMA-TMU	2025 Panini Phoenix Mythical Materials Autograph	—	—	—	—
Tyrann Mathieu [Green] #MMA-TMU	2025 Panini Phoenix Mythical Materials Autograph	—	—	—	—
Tyrann Mathieu [NFL Shield] #MMA-TMU	2025 Panini Phoenix Mythical Materials Autograph	—	—	—	—

20244 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Green Foil] #111	2024 UNO Elite Core Edition	$2.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Yellow] #111	2024 UNO Elite Core Edition	$1.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #399	2024 Panini Select	—	—	—	—
Tyrann Mathieu [Tiger Prizm] #399	2024 Panini Select	—	—	—	—

202317 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Black White Checker] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$2.08	$12.57	$57.50	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Red Sparkle] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$3.94	$25.00	$39.86	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Orange] #69	2023 Panini Score	$5.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #70	2023 Panini Score Top 100	$5.00	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [No Name] #218	2023 Panini Donruss	$3.50	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Orange Ice] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$1.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Gold] #69	2023 Panini Score	$1.79	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Green Wave] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$1.74	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #213	2023 Panini Prestige	$1.52	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$1.50	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Green Ice] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$1.50	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Red White Blue] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$1.50	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Orange Disco] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$1.00	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Galaxy] #213	2023 Panini Prestige	$0.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Hyper] #213	2023 Panini Prestige	$0.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Green] #218	2023 Panini Prizm	$0.96	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #218	2023 Panini Prizm No Huddle	$0.55	—	—	0%

20227 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph Silver] #211	2022 Panini Prizm	$20.28	$47.40	$70.64	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #211	2022 Panini Prizm No Huddle	$6.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #T58	2022 Panini Score Top 100	$3.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #362	2022 Panini Select	$1.75	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Blue] #211	2022 Panini Prizm	$14.99	$1.30	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #48	2022 Panini Player of the Day	$0.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Green Ice] #211	2022 Panini Prizm	—	—	—	—

20215 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Neon Green Prizm] #194	2021 Panini Prizm No Huddle	$45.00	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Prizm] #194	2021 Panini Prizm No Huddle	$2.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Light Blue Prizm] #194	2021 Panini Prizm	$1.75	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #7	2021 Panini Score	$1.70	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Xtra Points Black] #94	2021 Panini Prestige	—	—	—	—

202018 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Holo] #4	2020 Panini Donruss Optic	$1.75	—	$25.00	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Red Zone] #5	2020 Panini Contenders	$17.79	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Stardust] #5	2020 Panini Contenders	$7.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [White Sparkle] #4	2020 Panini Donruss Optic	$4.52	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Xtra Points Blue] #64	2020 Panini Prestige	$3.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #6	2020 Panini Origins	$2.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Red Stars] #4	2020 Panini Donruss Optic	$1.81	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Scorecard] #141	2020 Panini Score	$1.55	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #64	2020 Panini Prestige	$1.55	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #4	2020 Panini Donruss Optic	$1.29	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Xtra Points Green] #64	2020 Panini Prestige	$1.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #141	2020 Panini Score	$1.18	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #5	2020 Panini Contenders	$1.08	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Blue Prizm Die Cut] #239	2020 Panini Select	$0.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Purple] #141	2020 Panini Score	$0.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Gold] #141	2020 Panini Score	$0.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Black] #141	2020 Panini Score	—	—	—	—
Tyrann Mathieu [Green] #141	2020 Panini Score	—	—	—	—

20192 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu #C-28	2019 Panini Score Captains	$1.23	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #100	2019 Panini Player of the Day	$0.99	—	—	0%

20184 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu #81	2018 Panini Playoff	$1.21	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Goal Line] #81	2018 Panini Playoff	$0.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Red Zone] #81	2018 Panini Playoff	$0.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Kickoff] #81	2018 Panini Playoff	—	—	—	—

20173 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu #11	2017 Panini Donruss Optic Aka	$3.68	$29.99	$79.50	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Red] #11	2017 Panini Donruss Optic Aka	$6.50	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Green] #11	2017 Panini Donruss Optic Aka	—	—	—	—

20163 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Gold] #7	2016 Panini Score No Fly Zone	$2.95	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #6	2016 Panini Playoff	$0.25	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Goal Line] #6	2016 Panini Playoff	—	—	—	—

20142 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Gold] #41	2014 Topps	$0.99	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #NG34	2014 Panini Score Numbers Game	—	—	—	—

20139 cards

Card	Set	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	30d
Tyrann Mathieu [Prizm] #296	2013 Panini Prizm	$14.99	$30.00	$1,686	—
Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph] #396	2013 Panini Score	$75.00	—	—	—
Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph Silver] #196	2013 Panini Momentum	$14.83	—	$66.00	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Autograph] #155	2013 Topps Strata	$13.76	$23.20	$59.15	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #21	2013 Panini Select Hot Rookies	$1.25	—	$57.22	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #279	2013 Panini Prestige	$1.42	$24.99	$33.70	0%
Tyrann Mathieu [Gold] #211	2013 Topps	$3.26	—	—	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #21	2013 Panini Prizm Rookie Impact	$2.13	—	$7.50	0%
Tyrann Mathieu #RDC-TM	2013 Topps Strata Rookie Die Cut	$1.98	—	—	0%

Best Tyrann Mathieu cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

FAQ

How many Tyrann Mathieu cards are there?: Midpoint tracks 81 Tyrann Mathieu football cards across 42 sets, released between 2013 and 2025. 66 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What is the most valuable Tyrann Mathieu card?: The most valuable Tyrann Mathieu card tracked by Midpoint is Tyrann Mathieu [Prizm] #296 from 2013 Panini Prizm, currently $1,686 in PSA 10 (raw $14.99).
What years are Tyrann Mathieu cards from?: Tyrann Mathieu cards tracked by Midpoint run from 2013 to 2025; the earliest cards are from 2013.

All Football players Football card prices Football sets All sports

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your football card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Or try it on the web →