Jay Hilgenberg Cards — Price Guide & Checklist
84 cards · 60 sets · 1985–2025
Midpoint tracks 84 Jay Hilgenberg football cards across 60 sets (1985–2025), 72 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is Jay Hilgenberg #17 at $180 in PSA 10. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.
- Cards
- 84
- Sets
- 60
- Priced
- 72
- Top card (PSA 10)
- $180
- Raw total
- $192
Most valuable Jay Hilgenberg cards
123456789101112
Jay Hilgenberg #17
1986 Topps
Raw $2.45PSA 10 $180
Jay Hilgenberg [Orange] #PI-JHI
2025 Topps Signature Class Preeminent Ink
Raw $35.00PSA 10 $158
Jay Hilgenberg #59
1989 Topps
Raw $1.49PSA 10 $101
Jay Hilgenberg [Green] #63
1986 McDonald's Bears
Raw $3.95PSA 10 $99.99
Jay Hilgenberg [Purple] #PI-JHI
2025 Topps Signature Class Preeminent Ink
Raw $15.00PSA 10 $99.46
Jay Hilgenberg #52
1987 Topps
Raw $1.00PSA 10 $34.99
Jay Hilgenberg #378
1990 Topps Tiffany
Raw $1.34PSA 10 $34.66
Jay Hilgenberg #77
1988 Topps
Raw $1.00PSA 10 $30.45
Jay Hilgenberg #378
1990 Topps
Raw $1.16PSA 10 $30.27
Jay Hilgenberg #150
1989 Panini Score
Raw $1.34PSA 10 $29.98
Jay Hilgenberg #288
1989 Panini Score
Raw $1.62PSA 10 $26.23
Jay Hilgenberg #65
1992 Topps Gold
Raw $1.35PSA 10 $26.00
Cards by year
Every tracked Jay Hilgenberg card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.
20257 cards
19938 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #245 | 1993 Panini Score | $2.05 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #112 | 1993 Skybox Premium | $2.03 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #15 | 1993 Action Packed All Madden | $1.58 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #55 | 1993 Skybox Impact | $1.48 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #286 | 1993 Pinnacle | $1.45 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #302 | 1993 Pacific | $1.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #155 | 1993 Fleer Gameday | $0.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Colors] #55 | 1993 Skybox Impact | — | — | — | — |
199219 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #65 | 1992 Topps Gold | $1.35 | — | $26.00 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Mint 24KT Gold] #25 | 1992 Action Packed | $9.99 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #5 | 1992 Action Packed All Madden | $8.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #155 | 1992 Bowman | $2.89 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #118 | 1992 Fleer Gameday | $2.35 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #122 | 1992 Pro Set | $2.11 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #31 | 1992 Pacific | $1.75 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #177 | 1992 Stadium Club | $1.50 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #420 | 1992 Panini Score | $1.49 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #296 | 1992 Upper Deck | $1.44 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #263 | 1992 Pinnacle | $1.42 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #65 | 1992 Topps | $1.34 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #41 | 1992 Ultra | $1.00 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #453 | 1992 Upper Deck | $1.00 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #41 | 1992 Fleer | $0.99 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #465 | 1992 Pro Set | $0.91 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #25 | 1992 Action Packed | $0.89 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #5 | 1992 Action Packed All Madden 24KT Gold | — | — | — | — |
| Jay Hilgenberg #207 | 1992 Pro Line Portraits | — | — | — | — |
199116 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #50 | 1991 Pacific | $1.83 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #207 | 1991 Proline Portraits | $1.69 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #267 | 1991 Upper Deck | $1.65 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #63 | 1991 Score | $1.65 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #385 | 1991 Pro Set | $1.54 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #221 | 1991 Fleer | $1.50 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #65 | 1991 Pinnacle | $1.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #167 | 1991 Topps | $1.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #28 | 1991 Action Packed | $1.14 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #59 | 1991 Bowman | $0.99 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #5 | 1991 Action Packed All Madden | $0.71 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #456 | 1991 Pro Set | $0.61 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #163 | 1991 Pro Set Platinum | $0.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #57 | 1991 Stadium Club | $0.19 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #5 | 1991 Action Packed All Madden 24KT Gold | — | — | — | — |
| Jay Hilgenberg [National Convention] #207 | 1991 Proline Portraits | — | — | — | — |
199015 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #378 | 1990 Topps Tiffany | $1.34 | — | $34.66 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #378 | 1990 Topps | $1.16 | — | $30.27 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Disclaimer Back] #378 | 1990 Topps | $1.25 | $14.95 | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #10 | 1990 Fleer All Pro | $1.25 | — | $9.99 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #191 | 1990 Panini Sticker | $3.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #225 | 1990 Panini Sticker | $3.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #583 | 1990 Panini Score | $1.72 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #294 | 1990 Fleer | $1.69 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #394 | 1990 Pro Set | $1.59 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #171 | 1990 Panini Score | $1.55 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #26 | 1990 Action Packed | $1.32 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #53 | 1990 Pro Set | $1.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #53 | 1990 Pro Set FACT Cincinnati | $0.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #63 | 1990 Asher Candy Stars 'n Stripes | $0.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #26 | 1990 Panini Score 100 Hottest | — | — | — | — |
19897 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #59 | 1989 Topps | $1.49 | $21.45 | $101 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #150 | 1989 Panini Score | $1.34 | $23.08 | $29.98 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #288 | 1989 Panini Score | $1.62 | $19.44 | $26.23 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #42 | 1989 Pro Set | $1.53 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #21 | 1989 Panini Sticker | $0.99 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #206 | 1989 Panini Sticker | $0.25 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg | 1989 Franchise Game | $0.25 | — | — | 0% |
19882 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #77 | 1988 Topps | $1.00 | $14.71 | $30.45 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg #254 | 1988 Panini Sticker | $2.65 | — | — | 0% |
19871 card
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #52 | 1987 Topps | $1.00 | $19.99 | $34.99 | 0% |
19866 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg #17 | 1986 Topps | $2.45 | $128 | $180 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Green] #63 | 1986 McDonald's Bears | $3.95 | $16.00 | $99.99 | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Blue] #63 | 1986 McDonald's Bears | $5.95 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Gold] #63 | 1986 McDonald's Bears | $4.95 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Black] #63 | 1986 McDonald's Bears | $4.00 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Blank] #63 | 1986 McDonald's Bears | — | — | — | — |
19853 cards
| Card | Set | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 30d |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jay Hilgenberg [Orange] #63 | 1985 McDonald's Bears | — | — | — | — |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Yellow] #63 | 1985 McDonald's Bears | $5.93 | — | — | 0% |
| Jay Hilgenberg [Blue] #63 | 1985 McDonald's Bears | — | — | — | — |
Sets featuring Jay Hilgenberg
All Football sets →1986 Topps (1)2025 Topps Signature Class Preeminent Ink (7)1989 Topps (1)1986 McDonald's Bears (5)1987 Topps (1)1990 Topps Tiffany (1)1988 Topps (1)1990 Topps (2)1989 Panini Score (2)1992 Topps Gold (1)1985 McDonald's Bears (3)1992 Action Packed (2)1990 Fleer All Pro (1)1992 Action Packed All Madden (1)1990 Panini Sticker (2)1992 Bowman (1)1988 Panini Sticker (1)1992 Fleer Gameday (1)1992 Pro Set (2)1993 Panini Score (1)1993 Skybox Premium (1)1991 Pacific (1)1992 Pacific (1)1990 Panini Score (2)
Best Jay Hilgenberg cards to grade
Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.
- 1Jay Hilgenberg #171986 ToppsRaw $2.45PSA 10 $18074× premium
- 2Jay Hilgenberg #591989 ToppsRaw $1.49PSA 10 $10168× premium
- 3Jay Hilgenberg #521987 ToppsRaw $1.00PSA 10 $34.9935× premium
- 4Jay Hilgenberg #771988 ToppsRaw $1.00PSA 10 $30.4530× premium
- 5Jay Hilgenberg #3781990 ToppsRaw $1.16PSA 10 $30.2726× premium
- 6Jay Hilgenberg #3781990 Topps TiffanyRaw $1.34PSA 10 $34.6626× premium
FAQ
- How many Jay Hilgenberg cards are there?
- Midpoint tracks 84 Jay Hilgenberg football cards across 60 sets, released between 1985 and 2025. 72 of them have live raw or graded market values.
- What is the most valuable Jay Hilgenberg card?
- The most valuable Jay Hilgenberg card tracked by Midpoint is Jay Hilgenberg #17 from 1986 Topps, currently $180 in PSA 10 (raw $2.45).
- What years are Jay Hilgenberg cards from?
- Jay Hilgenberg cards tracked by Midpoint run from 1985 to 2025; the earliest cards are from 1985.
Related
Best on iPhone & Android
Check your football card in the Midpoint app
Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.
