MidpointCard Centering Grading Portfolio App
Payton Tolle #AA-19 card

Payton Tolle Cards — Price Guide & Checklist

121 cards · 28 sets · 2024–2026

Midpoint tracks 121 Payton Tolle baseball cards across 28 sets (2024–2026), 52 of them with live raw and graded market values. The most valuable is Payton Tolle #RR-PT at $2,750 in PSA 10. Prices come from real market sales and are refreshed daily.

Cards
121
Sets
28
Priced
52
Top card (PSA 10)
$2,750
Raw total
$2.5K

Most valuable Payton Tolle cards

1
Payton Tolle #RR-PT
2026 Topps Chrome Radiating Rookies Autograph
Raw $575PSA 10 $2,750
2
Payton Tolle #AA-19 2026 Topps Series 2 All Aces card
Payton Tolle #AA-19
2026 Topps Series 2 All Aces
Raw $488PSA 10 $2,298
3
Payton Tolle [Lightboard Refractor] #177
2026 Topps Chrome
Raw $125PSA 10 $635
4
Payton Tolle [Vintage Stock Variation] #15
2026 Topps
Raw $125PSA 10 $575
5
Payton Tolle [Teal Refractor] #RA-PT 2026 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph card
Payton Tolle [Teal Refractor] #RA-PT
2026 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph
Raw $120PSA 10 $563
6
Payton Tolle #ROA-PT 2026 Topps Heritage Real One Autograph card
Payton Tolle #ROA-PT
2026 Topps Heritage Real One Autograph
Raw $98.01PSA 10 $560
7
Payton Tolle [Autograph] #91C2-31 2026 Topps Series 2 1991 Chrome card
Payton Tolle [Autograph] #91C2-31
2026 Topps Series 2 1991 Chrome
Raw $99.50PSA 10 $555
8
Payton Tolle #15 2026 Topps Flagship Real One Autograph card
Payton Tolle #15
2026 Topps Flagship Real One Autograph
Raw $110PSA 10 $510
9
Payton Tolle #BOA-PT 2026 Topps Tier One Break Out Autograph card
Payton Tolle #BOA-PT
2026 Topps Tier One Break Out Autograph
Raw $85.00PSA 10 $424
10
Payton Tolle #RA-PT 2026 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph card
Payton Tolle #RA-PT
2026 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph
Raw $76.00PSA 10 $390
11
Payton Tolle #CPA-PT 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph card
Payton Tolle #CPA-PT
2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph
Raw $90.00PSA 10 $371
12
Payton Tolle [Lunar Glow Refractor] #BDC-63
2024 Bowman Draft Chrome
Raw $15.06PSA 10 $200

Cards by year

Every tracked Payton Tolle card grouped by set year, newest first — most valuable at the top of each year.

202637 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Payton Tolle #RR-PT2026 Topps Chrome Radiating Rookies Autograph$575$931$2,7500%
Payton Tolle #AA-192026 Topps Series 2 All Aces$488$786$2,2980%
Payton Tolle [Lightboard Refractor] #1772026 Topps Chrome$125$215$6350%
Payton Tolle [Vintage Stock Variation] #152026 Topps$125$203$5750%
Payton Tolle [Teal Refractor] #RA-PT2026 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph$120$190$5630%
Payton Tolle #ROA-PT2026 Topps Heritage Real One Autograph$98.01$230$5600%
Payton Tolle [Autograph] #91C2-312026 Topps Series 2 1991 Chrome$99.50$190$5550%
Payton Tolle #152026 Topps Flagship Real One Autograph$110$180$5100%
Payton Tolle #BOA-PT2026 Topps Tier One Break Out Autograph$85.00$144$4240%
Payton Tolle #RA-PT2026 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph$76.00$132$3900%
Payton Tolle #152026 Topps$1.53$34.11$1160%
Payton Tolle [Team Color Border Variation] #152026 Topps$19.48$40.07$1150%
Payton Tolle [Gold] #152026 Topps$14.06$31.72$91.360%
Payton Tolle [Pink Diamante] #152026 Topps$8.62$23.33$67.730%
Payton Tolle [Refractor] #432026 Topps Pristine$3.60$20.47$61.110%
Payton Tolle [75 Years] #152026 Topps$12.00$19.25$56.110%
Payton Tolle [Bronze] #932026 Topps Tier One$7.49$18.76$55.670%
Payton Tolle [Baseball Seams Refractor] #1772026 Topps Chrome$4.29$16.41$48.950%
Payton Tolle [Green Laser] #132026 Panini Donruss Elite Series$3.12$14.94$44.370%
Payton Tolle [Chrome] #882026 Topps Flagship Collection$3.00$14.64$43.110%
Payton Tolle [Refractor] #1772026 Topps Chrome$2.64$14.23$42.500%
Payton Tolle [Sandglitter] #152026 Topps$2.88$14.07$41.500%
Payton Tolle [Red Rookie Variation] #262026 Bowman$2.93$13.94$41.430%
Payton Tolle [Holo] #152026 Topps$1.99$12.61$37.380%
Payton Tolle [Crackle Foil] #SMLB-342026 Topps Series 2 Stars Of MLB$1.50$12.38$36.960%
Payton Tolle #942026 Panini Donruss$1.44$12.28$36.620%
Payton Tolle #132026 Panini Donruss Elite Series$1.41$12.18$36.350%
Payton Tolle [Mojo] #262026 Bowman$1.00$11.80$35.210%
Payton Tolle #SMLB-342026 Topps Series 2 Stars Of MLB$1.25$11.78$35.190%
Payton Tolle #262026 Bowman$1.06$11.61$34.660%
Payton Tolle [Canvas] #152026 Topps————
Payton Tolle [1952 Variation] #152026 Topps————
Payton Tolle #A-PT2026 Topps Now Road To Opening Day Autograph————
Payton Tolle #412026 Topps Series 2 The Flagship Collection Chrome Autograph————
Payton Tolle [Gold] #AA-192026 Topps Series 2 All Aces————
Payton Tolle [Refractor] #1422026 Topps Finest————
Payton Tolle [Topps Refractor] #1772026 Topps Chrome————

202557 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Payton Tolle #6262025 Topps Now$8.25$14.99$70.000%
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Green] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Orange] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Pink] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Platinum Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Purple] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Red] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Silver] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Super Prismatic Gold] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Black] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Gold] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Green] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Orange] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Pink] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Platinum Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Purple] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Red] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Silver] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Black] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Gold] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Green] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Orange] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Pink] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Platinum Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Purple] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Red] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Lava Silver] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Printing Plate] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Black] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Gold] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Green] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Platinum Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Purple] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Red] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Prismatic Silver] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Red Flood] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Black] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Gold] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Green] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Orange] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Pink] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Platinum Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Red] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Shimmer Silver] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Black] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Blue] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Gold] #MB-552025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Black] #NB-822025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Blue] #NB-822025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Green] #NB-822025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Purple] #NB-822025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn————
Payton Tolle [Crystal Silver] #NB-822025 Leaf Baseball Nation New Dawn————

202427 cards

CardSetRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Payton Tolle #CPA-PT2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph$90.00$143$3710%
Payton Tolle [Lunar Glow Refractor] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome$15.06$68.00$2000%
Payton Tolle [Sapphire] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome$15.50$40.00$1500%
Payton Tolle [Holo Ticket Signature] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$21.75$37.42$1370%
Payton Tolle [Refractor] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome$6.75$41.13$1350%
Payton Tolle #372024 Panini Prospect Edition Future Legends Signature$26.49$40.09$1330%
Payton Tolle [Silver Holo Ticket Signature] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$21.60$40.50$1070%
Payton Tolle [Sky Blue Refractor] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome$14.00$28.17$78.180%
Payton Tolle #BD-632024 Bowman Draft$1.00$10.00$59.510%
Payton Tolle [Pearl Refractor] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome$150——0%
Payton Tolle [Ticket Holo] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$3.03$14.29$40.870%
Payton Tolle [Ticket Stub] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$2.38$13.39$38.610%
Payton Tolle #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$1.79$12.55$36.470%
Payton Tolle [Red Ice Ticket Holo] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$1.50$12.14$35.420%
Payton Tolle [Popcorn] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome$34.95——0%
Payton Tolle [Sparkles Refractor] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome$32.90——0%
Payton Tolle [Green Holo Ticket Signature] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$25.00——0%
Payton Tolle [Holo Ticket Stub] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$16.25——0%
Payton Tolle [Green] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$2.90——0%
Payton Tolle [Green] #112024 Panini Prospect Edition Aces$1.99——0%
Payton Tolle [Silver Ticket Holo] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition$1.52——0%
Payton Tolle [Black] #BD-632024 Bowman Draft————
Payton Tolle [Red] #BD-632024 Bowman Draft————
Payton Tolle [Peanuts] #BDC-632024 Bowman Draft Chrome————
Payton Tolle [Red] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition————
Payton Tolle [Green Ticket Holo] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition————
Payton Tolle [Pandora Holo Ticket Signature] #802024 Panini Prospect Edition————

Sets featuring Payton Tolle

All Baseball sets →
2026 Topps Chrome Radiating Rookies Autograph (1)2026 Topps Series 2 All Aces (2)2026 Topps Chrome (4)2026 Topps (10)2026 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph (2)2026 Topps Heritage Real One Autograph (1)2026 Topps Series 2 1991 Chrome (1)2026 Topps Flagship Real One Autograph (1)2026 Topps Tier One Break Out Autograph (1)2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autograph (1)2024 Bowman Draft Chrome (8)2024 Panini Prospect Edition (13)2024 Panini Prospect Edition Future Legends Signature (1)2025 Topps Now (1)2026 Topps Pristine (1)2024 Bowman Draft (3)2026 Topps Tier One (1)2026 Panini Donruss Elite Series (2)2026 Topps Flagship Collection (1)2026 Bowman (3)2026 Topps Series 2 Stars Of MLB (2)2026 Panini Donruss (1)2024 Panini Prospect Edition Aces (1)2025 Leaf Baseball Nation MiLB Top 100 (51)

Best Payton Tolle cards to grade

Cards with the widest gap between raw and PSA 10 value — where a clean, well-centered copy gains the most from grading.

  1. 1
    Payton Tolle #15 2026 Topps card
    Payton Tolle #15
    2026 Topps
    Raw $1.53PSA 10 $11676× premium
  2. 2
    Payton Tolle #BD-63
    2024 Bowman Draft
    Raw $1.00PSA 10 $59.5160× premium
  3. 3
    Payton Tolle [Mojo] #26 2026 Bowman card
    Payton Tolle [Mojo] #26
    2026 Bowman
    Raw $1.00PSA 10 $35.2135× premium
  4. 4
    Payton Tolle #26 2026 Bowman card
    Payton Tolle #26
    2026 Bowman
    Raw $1.06PSA 10 $34.6633× premium
  5. 5
    Payton Tolle #SMLB-34
    2026 Topps Series 2 Stars Of MLB
    Raw $1.25PSA 10 $35.1928× premium
  6. 6
    Payton Tolle #13
    2026 Panini Donruss Elite Series
    Raw $1.41PSA 10 $36.3526× premium

FAQ

How many Payton Tolle cards are there?
Midpoint tracks 121 Payton Tolle baseball cards across 28 sets, released between 2024 and 2026. 52 of them have live raw or graded market values.
What is the most valuable Payton Tolle card?
The most valuable Payton Tolle card tracked by Midpoint is Payton Tolle #RR-PT from 2026 Topps Chrome Radiating Rookies Autograph, currently $2,750 in PSA 10 (raw $575).
What years are Payton Tolle cards from?
Payton Tolle cards tracked by Midpoint run from 2024 to 2026; the earliest cards are from 2024.

Related

All Baseball playersBaseball card pricesBaseball setsAll sports

Best on iPhone & Android

Check your baseball card in the Midpoint app

Scan with your camera to measure centering to the millimeter, get an AI grade with corner and edge close-ups, see what your copy is worth, and track it in your portfolio. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Or try it on the web →

Best on iPhone & Android

The full Midpoint experience is in the app

Scan with your camera, get AI grades with corner and edge close-ups, issue Grade Certificates, set price alerts, track your portfolio and talk to other collectors — everything here, plus the parts a browser can't do. Free to start.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play