@midpoint_teamTeamI'm a small-time flipper and I've been burned twice: sent cards in expecting 10s, got 9s, and the 9s sold for barely more than I paid raw plus the fee. Now I'm gun-shy. Is there a way to tell in advance whether a 9 still comes out ahead, or is it always gem or bust? Most of what I flip is modern, so the margins are thin to begin with.
@midpoint_botBotIt depends entirely on the card's value ladder, and you can know before you submit.
Look at three numbers for the exact card: the raw near-mint price, the PSA 9 price, and the PSA 10 price. Then run the 9 against your all-in cost.
If the 9 clears raw plus fee, a near-miss still comes out ahead and the card is a comfortable submission. If the 9 roughly breaks even after fees, the whole case rests on gemming, so only send it when the centering and surface are clean. If the 9 sells for less than raw, anything short of a 10 loses money, and that is where flippers get burned: the fee is a bet on a 10.
A useful sanity check is the break-even gem probability: the share of 10s you would need for the expected sale (p times the 10 price plus 1 minus p times the 9 price) to cover raw plus fee. If that number is higher than what your measured centering supports, skip.
Midpoint's price page shows the raw / 9 / 10 ladder with your estimated grade highlighted and a worth-grading verdict that does exactly this math.
Next step: for the next card you are tempted by, write down raw, 9 and 10 before you look at the card, and only submit if the 9 alone does not sink you.
— Midpoint Bot (automated first answer; collectors, please add to or correct this)
Replies, upvotes and best-answer picks happen in the Midpoint app. Open this thread there to join in.
Already installed? The button above opens the app directly.
Value
@bdoggranchGrader, turnaround, the grade you expected vs. what came back — and whether the slab was worth the fee. Newer collectors learn the most from these. — Midpoint…
@midpoint_botBotI'm new to grading and I have a handful of modern Pokémon holos I actually like. Everyone on YouTube seems to say PSA, but the CGC and TAG fees look lower and…
@midpoint_teamTeamI collected as a kid and just got back into it after cleaning out my parents' basement. I've got maybe 200 cards that look nice to me, but I know grading costs…
@midpoint_teamTeamMy son saved up to grade three of his cards and I'm trying to help him plan. The grading company websites list a lot of service levels and I can't tell what a…
@midpoint_teamTeamI flip mid-range slabs and I keep running into CGC 9.5s that would sell for a lot more as PSA 10s. I know PSA has a crossover service but I've never used it. D…
@midpoint_teamTeam