# 2005 Topps All Time Fan Favorites card prices (Baseball)

- Page: https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/sets/baseball/2005-topps-all-time-fan-favorites
- Cards tracked: 24; with prices: 22
- Whole set, raw: $127
- Whole set, PSA 10: $134
- Most valuable card: Dennis McLain #56 ($61.54)
- Last price capture: 2026-09-03

## Cards, most valuable first

| # | Card | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | Page |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| — | Dennis McLain #56 | $2.99 | $16.81 | $61.54 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067942 |
| — | Don Zimmer #57 | $3.00 | $16.40 | $59.63 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067943 |
| — | Carl Erskine [Gold Refractor] #24 | $29.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067918 |
| — | Rafael Santana #121 | $1.43 | $18.00 | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-9708472 |
| — | Jim Leyland [Gold Refractor] #16 | $17.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067912 |
| — | Jose Oquendo [Gold Refractor] #96 | $14.72 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067965 |
| — | Rick Dempsey [Gold Refractor] #106 | $10.23 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067971 |
| — | Jesus Alou #67 | $1.40 | — | $8.76 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067949 |
| — | Joe Pepitone [Refractor] #18 | $8.75 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067913 |
| — | Carl Erskine [Refractor] #24 | $8.13 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067919 |
| — | J. R. Richard #19 | $7.38 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067914 |
| — | Oscar Gamble [Refractor] #102 | $4.13 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067967 |
| — | John Tudor #98 | $4.11 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6327069 |
| — | Clem Labine #90 | $1.67 | — | $3.83 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067962 |
| — | Tom Niedenfuer #114 | $1.88 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6138877 |
| — | Bob Dernier #115 | $1.87 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6327071 |
| — | Hank Bauer #103 | $1.84 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067968 |
| — | Matty Alou #41 | $1.79 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067933 |
| — | Johnny Podres #84 | $1.34 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067955 |
| — | Rick Dempsey #106 | $1.15 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6327070 |
| — | Mike Cuellar #136 | $1.02 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6776280 |
| — | Carl Erskine #24 | $1.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2067917 |

---
Prices are USD market values from real sold listings, refreshed daily. Measure your own copy's centering and get a grade estimate with Midpoint (https://www.cardcenteringtool.com) before paying a grading fee.