# 1909 E95 Philadelphia Caramel card prices (Baseball)

- Page: https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/sets/baseball/1909-e95-philadelphia-caramel
- Cards tracked: 26; with prices: 23
- Whole set, raw: $10,288
- Most valuable card: Christy Matthewson [Mathewson] (—)
- Last price capture: 2026-09-04

## Cards, most valuable first

| # | Card | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | Page |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| — | Christy Matthewson [Mathewson] | — | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724661 |
| — | Ty Cobb | $25.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724649 |
| — | Honus Wagner | $7,900 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724667 |
| — | Art Devlin | $52.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724653 |
| — | Cy Morgan | $53.79 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724664 |
| — | Eddie Plank | $721 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724665 |
| — | Sam Crawford | $239 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724651 |
| — | Chief Bender | $228 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724645 |
| — | Ed Cicotte | $185 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724648 |
| — | Frank Chance | $176 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724647 |
| — | Johnny Evers | $91.50 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724655 |
| — | Tommy Leach | $76.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724658 |
| — | Ed Willetts [Willett] | $75.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724668 |
| — | Harry Krause | $62.16 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724657 |
| — | Solly Hoffman [Hofman] | $59.38 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724656 |
| — | Larry Doyle | $58.18 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724654 |
| — | Bill Carrigan | $57.34 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724646 |
| — | Nick Maddox | $50.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724660 |
| — | Hooks Wiltse | $46.51 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724670 |
| — | Ed Reulbach | $36.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724666 |
| — | Harry Lord | $36.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724659 |
| — | Fred Merkle | $33.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724663 |
| — | Matty McIntyre | $28.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1724662 |

---
Prices are USD market values from real sold listings, refreshed daily. Measure your own copy's centering and get a grade estimate with Midpoint (https://www.cardcenteringtool.com) before paying a grading fee.