# Paul O'Neill card prices (Baseball)

- Page: https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/players/baseball/paul-o-neill
- Cards tracked: 207 across 165 sets, 1986–2026
- Most valuable card: Paul O'Neill [Foilfractor] #95CA-PO ($425)

## Cards, most valuable first

| Card | Set | Year | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | Page |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Paul O'Neill [Foilfractor] #95CA-PO | 2025 Topps Archives 1995 Cyberstats Autograph | 2025 | $425 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11350372 |
| Paul O'Neill #PO | 1999 SP Signature Autographs | 1999 | $34.41 | $225 | $400 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2026190 |
| Paul O'Neill [Refractor] #170 | 1993 Finest | 1993 | $75.56 | $114 | $392 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1959723 |
| Paul O'neill #75YA-PO | 2026 Topps 75 Years Of Topps Die-Cut Autograph | 2026 | $65.00 | $108 | $308 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11891187 |
| Paul O'Neill [Refractor] #322 | 1998 Topps Chrome | 1998 | $20.02 | $170 | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2019853 |
| Paul O'Neill #95CA-PO | 2025 Topps Archives 1995 Cyberstats Autograph | 2025 | $25.25 | $150 | $180 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11350364 |
| Paul O'Neill #37 | 1986 Donruss | 1986 | $2.11 | $30.85 | $156 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1917217 |
| Paul O'Neill [Class 2 Red Label] #33 | 1998 Topps Gold Label | 1998 | $150 | — | $150 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2019158 |
| Paul O'Neill #170 | 1993 Finest | 1993 | $1.20 | — | $150 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1959722 |
| Paul O'Neill #PO | 2001 SP Game Bat Piece of the Game | 2001 | $5.64 | $19.99 | $143 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2041877 |
| Paul O'Neill #89BA-PO | 2024 Topps 1989 Autograph | 2024 | $36.85 | $20.50 | $130 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6808402 |
| Paul O'Neill #SPTRA-PO | 2025 Topps Museum Collection Single-Player Signature Swatch Triple Relic Autograph | 2025 | $24.99 | $44.70 | $128 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11835618 |
| Paul O'Neill #CBA-PO | 2026 Topps Chrome Black Autograph | 2026 | $18.52 | $42.22 | $123 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-12740949 |
| Paul O'Neill [Members Only] #20 | 1995 Stadium Club Ring Leaders | 1995 | $3.00 | $25.51 | $122 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-13347775 |
| Paul O'Neill [Refractor] #20 | 1999 Bowman Chrome International | 1999 | — | $110 | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2022082 |
| Paul O'Neill #20 | 1995 Stadium Club Ring Leaders | 1995 | $2.64 | $23.63 | $111 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2514147 |
| Paul O'Neill #11 | 1992 Upper Deck Denny's Grand Slam Holograms | 1992 | $1.74 | $20.93 | $96.64 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-10257521 |
| Paul O'Neill #198 | 1990 Donruss Aqueous Test | 1990 | $24.29 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1940962 |
| Paul O'Neill #604 | 1989 Topps | 1989 | $1.35 | $26.99 | $89.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1937552 |
| Paul O'Neill #DK-7 | 1995 Donruss Diamond Kings | 1995 | $1.82 | $19.50 | $86.23 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11358536 |
| Paul O'Neill  [Gold Rainbow] #18 | 1998 Topps Stars | 1998 | $79.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8452318 |
| Paul O'Neill #68AA-PO | 2024 Topps Archives 1968 Action All-Stars Autograph | 2024 | $20.35 | $36.38 | $75.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8223465 |
| Paul O'Neill #50 | 1995 Panini Donruss Elite | 1995 | $9.99 | $37.39 | $74.89 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1976242 |
| Paul O'Neill #427 | 1990 Fleer | 1990 | $0.97 | $16.93 | $72.88 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1939698 |
| Paul O'Neill #276 | 1993 Topps Gold | 1993 | $1.54 | $29.00 | $69.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1963720 |
| Paul O'Neill #FSA-PO | 2022 Topps Five Star Autographs | 2022 | $18.66 | $31.62 | $67.28 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4575802 |
| Paul O'Neill #144 | 1998 Metal Universe | 1998 | $1.46 | $22.00 | $63.96 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2017162 |
| Paul O'Neill [Blue] #95CA-PO | 2025 Topps Archives 1995 Cyberstats Autograph | 2025 | $60.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11350367 |
| Paul O'Neill #77 | 1995 Summit | 1995 | $1.59 | — | $59.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1978911 |
| Paul O'Neill #122 | 1991 Topps | 1991 | $1.35 | $19.50 | $59.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1950517 |
| Paul O'Neill #583 | 1991 Donruss | 1991 | $0.55 | — | $59.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1946723 |
| Paul O'Neill #604 | 1989 Topps Tiffany | 1989 | $1.97 | $35.00 | $55.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1936609 |
| Paul O'Neill #717 | 1993 Stadium Club 1st Day Production | 1993 | $4.58 | — | $54.53 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1962723 |
| Paul O'Neill | 1998 Donruss Signature Century Marks | 1998 | $52.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2015657 |
| Paul O'Neill #122 | 1991 Topps Tiffany | 1991 | $1.95 | — | $51.76 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1949954 |
| Paul O'Neill #266 | 1993 SP | 1993 | $1.51 | $14.99 | $47.10 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1961986 |
| Paul O'Neill #1 | 1995 Ultra League Leaders | 1995 | $1.20 | — | $44.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11358558 |
| Paul O'Neill #276 | 1993 Topps | 1993 | $0.99 | — | $44.98 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1964826 |
| Paul O'Neill #332 | 1990 Topps | 1990 | $0.99 | $19.99 | $44.20 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1943844 |
| Paul O'Neill #T1TA-PO | 2023 Topps Tier One Talent Autographs | 2023 | $20.75 | $28.00 | $40.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6174199 |
| Paul O'Neill #546 | 1994 Topps Bilingual | 1994 | — | $35.00 | $40.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1970670 |
| Paul O'Neill #137 | 1996 Pinnacle Starburst | 1996 | $1.83 | $35.00 | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1999785 |
| Paul O'Neill #166 | 1989 Fleer Glossy | 1989 | $1.69 | — | $36.53 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1933192 |
| Paul O'Neill #304 | 1988 Score | 1988 | $0.99 | — | $35.89 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1929063 |
| Paul O'Neill #84T | 1993 Topps Traded | 1993 | $1.57 | $12.00 | $34.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1964475 |
| Paul O'Neill #U-85 | 1988 Fleer Update Glossy | 1988 | $1.68 | $2.94 | $34.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1926703 |
| Paul O'Neill #U-94 | 1987 Fleer Update Glossy | 1987 | $1.30 | $9.72 | $33.28 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1921591 |
| Paul O'Neill #HR15 | 1992 Upper Deck Homerun Heroes | 1992 | $1.59 | — | $33.24 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4631626 |
| Paul O'Neill #U-94 | 1987 Fleer Update | 1987 | $1.69 | $8.61 | $30.88 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1921633 |
| Paul O'Neill #133 | 1991 Upper Deck | 1991 | $1.05 | — | $30.00 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1951458 |
| Paul O'Neill #70 | 1990 Leaf | 1990 | $1.00 | $9.98 | $29.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1940098 |
| Paul O'Neill #5 | 1989 Score Young Superstars Series 2 | 1989 | — | — | $29.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-13635804 |
| Paul O'Neill #U-85 | 1988 Fleer Update | 1988 | $1.38 | $7.02 | $29.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1926762 |
| Paul O'Neill #198 | 1990 Donruss | 1990 | $1.00 | $3.00 | $29.94 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1941327 |
| Paul O'Neill #HR27 | 1993 Upper Deck Homerun Heroes | 1993 | $1.27 | — | $28.29 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2594496 |
| Paul O'Neill #61 | 1992 Topps Gold | 1992 | $1.25 | — | $26.67 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1955979 |
| Paul O'Neill [Gold Script] #141 | 1999 Upper Deck MVP | 1999 | $25.68 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8821276 |
| Paul O'Neill [Gold] #68AA-PO | 2024 Topps Archives 1968 Action All-Stars Autograph | 2024 | $22.51 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-9353848 |
| Paul O'Neill #AA-PO | 2022 Topps Museum Collection Archival Autographs | 2022 | $22.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4065178 |
| Paul O'Neill #433 | 1988 Donruss | 1988 | $1.26 | — | $21.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1928330 |
| Paul O'Neill [Copper] #SPTRA-PO | 2025 Topps Museum Collection Single-Player Signature Swatch Triple Relic Autograph | 2025 | $20.38 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11835621 |
| Paul O'Neill [Row 1] #130 | 1999 Flair Showcase | 1999 | $3.25 | — | $19.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2025038 |
| Paul O'Neill #61 | 1992 O Pee Chee | 1992 | $1.80 | — | $17.99 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1953878 |
| Paul O'Neill #FTS-PO | 2024 Topps Five Star Five Time Signature | 2024 | $17.50 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-7561145 |
| Paul O'Neill #BSA-PO | 2023 Topps Series 1 Stars Autographs | 2023 | $16.68 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4777393 |
| Paul O'Neill #20 | 1999 Bowman Chrome | 1999 | $1.38 | $8.22 | $15.50 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2022337 |
| Paul O'Neill [Gold] #99 | 1992 Leaf | 1992 | $14.95 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1953435 |
| Paul O'Neill [Black and White] #AS-PO | 2016 Topps Archives Snapshots | 2016 | $9.73 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1376838 |
| Paul O'Neill [Members Only] #717 | 1993 Stadium Club | 1993 | $2.17 | — | $9.68 | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1963103 |
| Paul O'Neill [Die Cut] #199 | 1994 SP | 1994 | $1.26 | $8.55 | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1969639 |
| Paul O'Neill #717 | 1993 Stadium Club | 1993 | $2.67 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1963102 |
| Paul O'Neill [Artist's Proof] #137 | 1996 Pinnacle Starburst | 1996 | $5.94 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1999786 |
| Paul O'Neill  [Gold] #18 | 1998 Topps Stars | 1998 | $4.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8452317 |
| Paul O'Neill #PP-17 | 1995 Pinnacle Performers | 1995 | $4.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-10456269 |
| Paul O'Neill #71 | 2001 Topps Stars | 2001 | $4.45 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4893437 |
| Paul O'Neill [Mini Black Border] #280 | 2016 Topps Allen & Ginter | 2016 | $4.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1372737 |
| Paul O'Neill [Gold Signature] #243 | 1995 Collector's Choice Se | 1995 | $3.36 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8437044 |
| Paul O'Neill #153 | 1996 Topps Gallery | 1996 | $3.20 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2001578 |
| Paul O'Neill [Player's Private Issue] #45 | 1997 Topps Gallery | 1997 | $2.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2011294 |
| Paul O'Neill [Bronze] #64 | 1997 Panini Donruss Preferred | 1997 | $2.74 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-10109730 |
| Paul O'neill [Platinum Edition] #91 | 1996 Metal Universe | 1996 | $2.69 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1999265 |
| Paul O'Neill [Bronze Press Proof] #13 | 1996 Leaf | 1996 | $2.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8845373 |
| Paul O'Neill [Mini] #280 | 2016 Topps Allen & Ginter X | 2016 | $2.28 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1374950 |
| Paul O'Neill [Black Back] #6 | 2001 Topps Heritage | 2001 | $2.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2045009 |
| Paul O'Neill #30 | 2001 Topps Limited Edition | 2001 | $2.17 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-9356881 |
| Paul O'Neill #45 | 1997 Topps Gallery | 1997 | $2.17 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2011293 |
| Paul O'Neill [Radiance] #107 | 1998 SPx Finite | 1998 | $1.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11807317 |
| Paul O'Neill #50 | 1996 Leaf Preferred | 1996 | $1.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4034958 |
| Paul O'Neill #245 | 1995 Pinnacle Museum Collection | 1995 | $1.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1976353 |
| Paul O'Neill #49 | 1990 Bowman Tiffany | 1990 | $1.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1938761 |
| Paul O'Neill #243 | 1995 Collector's Choice Se | 1995 | $1.98 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1975925 |
| Paul O'Neill [Devil Rays Inaugural] #322 | 1998 Topps | 1998 | $1.95 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2020908 |
| Paul O'neill [Silver Press Proof] #35 | 1997 Panini Donruss | 1997 | $1.95 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2007390 |
| Paul O'Neill #178 | 1995 SP | 1995 | $1.93 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1978193 |
| Paul O'Neill [Series 2 Artist's Proof] #21 | 1996 Score Dugout Collection | 1996 | $1.88 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1999471 |
| Paul O’Neill #66 | 1992 Score Impact Players | 1992 | $1.88 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6021369 |
| Paul O'Neill #267 | 1992 Bowman | 1992 | $1.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1952550 |
| Paul O'Neill #68 | 1995 Sportflix UC3 | 1995 | $1.79 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1978282 |
| Paul O'Neill #322 | 1998 Topps Chrome | 1998 | $1.74 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2019852 |
| Paul O'Neill #313 | 1989 Bowman Tiffany | 1989 | $1.70 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1932361 |
| Paul O'Neill #133 | 1999 Topps Opening Day | 1999 | $1.69 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2028411 |
| Paul O'Neill #39 | 1990 Donruss Best NL | 1990 | $1.67 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1941115 |
| Paul O'Neill #167 | 1998 Fleer Tradition | 1998 | $1.66 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4895814 |
| Paul O'Neill #218 | 1991 Stadium Club | 1991 | $1.62 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1947361 |
| Paul O'Neill #182 | 2001 Bowman Heritage | 2001 | $1.61 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-7420020 |
| Paul O'Neill #17 | 1999 Skybox Premium | 1999 | $1.60 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2025877 |
| Paul O'Neill #140 | 1993 Studio | 1993 | $1.60 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1963161 |
| Paul O'Neill [Class 1] #73 | 1999 Topps Gold Label | 1999 | $1.50 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2027415 |
| Paul O'Neill [Members Only] #124 | 1995 Stadium Club | 1995 | $1.50 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1978485 |
| Paul O'Neill #TM-62 | 2013 Topps 1972 Minis | 2013 | $1.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2137144 |
| Paul O’Neill #10 | 2001 Topps Opening Day | 2001 | $1.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-5604231 |
| Paul O'Neill #39 | 1993 Fleer | 1993 | $1.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1959914 |
| Paul O'Neill #14 | 1993 O Pee Chee Premier | 1993 | $1.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1960290 |
| Paul O'Neill #120 | 1991 Panini Stickers | 1991 | $1.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1947072 |
| Paul O'Neill #77 | 1989 Panini Stickers | 1989 | $1.49 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1934932 |
| Paul O'Neill #194 | 1992 Ultra | 1992 | $1.45 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1957790 |
| Paul O'Neill #75 | 1993 Bowman | 1993 | $1.40 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1959010 |
| Paul O'Neill [Winner] #61 | 1992 Topps Gold | 1992 | $1.40 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1955980 |
| Paul O’Neill #230 | 1989 Donruss Baseball's Best | 1989 | $1.39 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6399940 |
| Paul O'Neill #49 | 2016 Topps Archives | 2016 | $1.37 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1375096 |
| Paul O'Neill #PIS-5 | 2016 Topps Pressed Into Service | 2016 | $1.37 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6590932 |
| Paul O'Neill #131 | 1995 Select | 1995 | $1.35 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-7532792 |
| Paul O'Neill #20 | 1999 Bowman Chrome International | 1999 | $1.34 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2022081 |
| Paul O'Neill #25 | 1992 Studio | 1992 | $1.33 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1955865 |
| Paul O'Neill #206 | 1989 Score | 1989 | $1.32 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1935326 |
| Paul O'Neill #17 | 1996 Pinnacle Aficionado | 1996 | $1.29 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-7222146 |
| Paul O'Neill #304 | 1988 Score Glossy | 1988 | $1.27 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1928594 |
| Paul O'Neill #280 | 2016 Topps Allen & Ginter | 2016 | $1.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1371347 |
| Paul O'Neill #45 | 1996 Zenith | 1996 | $1.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2002406 |
| Paul O'Neill [Silver] #178 | 1995 SP | 1995 | $1.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1978194 |
| Paul O'Neill #169 | 1991 Studio | 1991 | $1.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1948559 |
| Paul O'Neill #87 | 2000 Fleer Showcase | 2000 | $1.22 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2033576 |
| Paul O'Neill [Mini A & G Back] #280 | 2016 Topps Allen & Ginter | 2016 | $1.20 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1372047 |
| Paul O'Neill #17 | 1990 Score Superstars | 1990 | $1.20 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2209894 |
| Paul O’Neill #14 | 1993 Stadium Club Yankees | 1993 | $1.19 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-5157074 |
| Paul O'Neill #100 | 1991 Ultra | 1991 | $1.14 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1951129 |
| Paul O’Neill #59 | 2001 Ultra | 2001 | $1.13 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-5886102 |
| Paul O'Neill #AS-PO | 2016 Topps Archives Snapshots | 2016 | $1.12 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1376789 |
| Paul O'Neill #427 | 1990 Fleer Canadian | 1990 | $1.11 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1939384 |
| Paul O'Neill #199 | 1994 SP | 1994 | $1.06 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1969638 |
| Paul O'Neill [Gold Script] #215 | 2000 Upper Deck MVP | 2000 | $1.05 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2037798 |
| Paul O'Neill  [Silver] #18 | 1998 Topps Stars | 1998 | $1.05 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8452319 |
| Paul O'Neill #215 | 2000 Upper Deck MVP | 2000 | $1.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2037797 |
| Paul O'Neill #14 | 1995 Ultra All Stars | 1995 | $1.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-11358564 |
| Paul O'Neill [World Series Winners] #124 | 1995 Stadium Club | 1995 | $1.00 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1978486 |
| Paul O'Neill [Mini] #280 | 2016 Topps Allen & Ginter | 2016 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1371698 |
| Paul O'Neill #166 | 1999 Pacific Omega | 1999 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-4613793 |
| Paul O'Neill #104 | 1998 Stadium Club | 1998 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-10042689 |
| Paul O'Neill #40 | 1998 Fleer Vintage 63 | 1998 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2016592 |
| Paul O'Neill #80 | 1995 Zenith | 1995 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1979833 |
| Paul O'Neill #13 | 1995 Stadium Club Super Skills | 1995 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8801809 |
| Paul O'neill [Members Only] #74 | 1994 Stadium Club | 1994 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1969954 |
| Paul O'Neill #245 | 1990 Panini Stickers | 1990 | $0.99 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1942082 |
| Paul O'Neill #219 | 1991 Leaf | 1991 | $0.92 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1945721 |
| Paul O'Neill #360 | 1989 Donruss | 1989 | $0.86 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1934782 |
| Paul O'Neill #39 | 1989 Topps Big | 1989 | $0.86 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1935620 |
| Paul O'Neill #117 | 1990 Classic | 1990 | $0.78 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-6755418 |
| Paul O'Neill  [Bronze] #18 | 1998 Topps Stars | 1998 | $0.75 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8452316 |
| Paul O'Neill #218 | 1993 O Pee Chee | 1993 | $0.72 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-8136151 |
| Paul O'Neill #76 | 1991 Fleer | 1991 | $0.72 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-3400983 |
| Paul O'Neill #439 | 1993 Score | 1993 | $0.71 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-3921900 |
| Paul O'Neill #280 | 2016 Topps Allen & Ginter X | 2016 | $0.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1374606 |
| Paul O'Neill #103 | 2001 Leaf Limited | 2001 | $0.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-3699041 |
| Paul O'Neill [Series 2] #21 | 1996 Score Dugout Collection | 1996 | $0.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1999470 |
| Paul O'Neill #284 | 1996 Topps Team Topps | 1996 | $0.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-2001991 |
| Paul O'Neill #86 | 1993 Score Select | 1993 | $0.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1961635 |
| Paul O'Neill #58 | 1992 Score Superstars | 1992 | $0.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1954518 |
| Paul O'Neill #4 | 1990 Sportflics | 1990 | $0.25 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-7877159 |
| Paul O'Neill #276 | 1993 Topps Micro | 1993 | $0.10 | — | — | https://www.cardcenteringtool.com/prices/pricecharting-1964328 |

---
Prices are USD market values from real sold listings, refreshed daily. Measure your own copy's centering and get a grade estimate with Midpoint (https://www.cardcenteringtool.com) before paying a grading fee.